Who did more for their Country? Minato or Itachi?
- Thread starter -Liquid Cefka-
- Start date
uchiha defender
Member
You must be registered for see images
You're point? I don't see how that has anything to do with what I said. Minato's heir is saving the world and his village while Itachi's is trying to destroy it.
Flame Alchemist
Active member
if itachi didn't exterminate his clan danzo would find another way to do it. however that would make them in front of villagers eyes. having itachi do it was the most logical option that's why it happened. however if it weren't for minato konoha would've been destroyed. third would've probably died same goes for naruto, and tobi would have one less village to fight in order to achieve his goals.
so I'll go with minato (I congratulate you for the title. this is the first time I'm picking minato over itachi)
so I'll go with minato (I congratulate you for the title. this is the first time I'm picking minato over itachi)
Prince Charles
Active member
minato did
itachi killed his whole clan which wasnt necessary what about all the non sharigan users? the children? the old plp? they didnt have to do die but they werent speared ? he did it for his village? did what? he created a monster in the end ( sasuke ) he had other options then killed off innocent plp. and his plan backed fired on him he tells his little brother to gain more hate and veagance but he doesnt want him to take veagance out on his village hm..?
minato saved the village from a fox attack sacrificed his own life and defeated tobi without killing innocent plp
itachi plan is fail from the start.
itachi killed his whole clan which wasnt necessary what about all the non sharigan users? the children? the old plp? they didnt have to do die but they werent speared ? he did it for his village? did what? he created a monster in the end ( sasuke ) he had other options then killed off innocent plp. and his plan backed fired on him he tells his little brother to gain more hate and veagance but he doesnt want him to take veagance out on his village hm..?
minato saved the village from a fox attack sacrificed his own life and defeated tobi without killing innocent plp
itachi plan is fail from the start.
Naruto N. Uzumaki
Active member
Naruto N. Uzumaki
Active member
he forgets minato saved kid itachi and baby sasuke by taking care of tobi+kurama
-Liquid Cefka-
Active member
Black Adam
Active member
Blaze Release
Active member
And in return itachi has saved naruto on several occasions.
.Anyway ill agree that minato's gamble, yes thats what it is if you know the definition of a gamble, is paying of in naruto whilst itachi's gamble isnt. This is an entirely different scenario because you cannot fully judge them and base your decision on others.
Still believe it was a good idea not to kill sasuke though. U_U
Well i guess they are equal, the only reason i chose Minato is because Itachi had a choice, Minato on the other hand didn't, he took all the decisions in the middle of the battle while trying to protect Konoha, Kushina and Naruto.
Yea he could have left Kushina die with the nine tails but he would still sacrifice his wife.
Yea he could have left Kushina die with the nine tails but he would still sacrifice his wife.
I think Itachi did more. Its pretty close though. Itachi went as far as to kill his own clan to protect the village. Not only that he acted as a rouge ninja to Konoha. He kept Tobi from capturing Naruto as well by making that pact with Tobi not to attack Konoha.
Both are the Same really.
If Minato Didn't stop Tobi/Kyuubi, the Leaf would be Gone, the whole Fire country would be in Ruins.
Also depends if after Gaining the kyuubi and Destroying the Leaf if he would go after the other countries for their Beasts. (if this would of been the case, then Minato would come out on Top, But we will never know so it's kinda invalid)
Also if Minato Failed Itachi could have died when he was a Kid, so thank minato, Itachi Grew up to be a Badass
Itachi Saved the Leaf and Stopped a War. Stopped Tobi making other attempts on the Leaf/Kyuubi
If Minato Didn't stop Tobi/Kyuubi, the Leaf would be Gone, the whole Fire country would be in Ruins.
Also depends if after Gaining the kyuubi and Destroying the Leaf if he would go after the other countries for their Beasts. (if this would of been the case, then Minato would come out on Top, But we will never know so it's kinda invalid)
Also if Minato Failed Itachi could have died when he was a Kid, so thank minato, Itachi Grew up to be a Badass
Itachi Saved the Leaf and Stopped a War. Stopped Tobi making other attempts on the Leaf/Kyuubi
Last edited:
Raidenuser
Active member
Minato, all his instincts seem spot on - sealing Kurama in Naruto and also part of his own and Kushina's chakra (anticipating the future need)
Much as I like Itachi what he did was misguided killing innocent children. I know he was ordered but still
Much as I like Itachi what he did was misguided killing innocent children. I know he was ordered but still
Last edited:
Who ever Say Itachi has to be high.
Manito Protected a Entire village+uchiha population combined with Leaf.
He protected the "future" and commited suicide. He did not do it for Naruto Only he did it for the whole Nation of Shinobi and he is still doing it as we speak with "that" jutsu. Itachi kill his own clan with "help" to protect "one" person and the "leaf" Government from being run by uchiha which in general wouldn't hurt the leafs population one bit, might even make them stronger. Sadly his Plan "fail" while Minato plan is still a success. "Get the Picture?"
Manito Protected a Entire village+uchiha population combined with Leaf.
He protected the "future" and commited suicide. He did not do it for Naruto Only he did it for the whole Nation of Shinobi and he is still doing it as we speak with "that" jutsu. Itachi kill his own clan with "help" to protect "one" person and the "leaf" Government from being run by uchiha which in general wouldn't hurt the leafs population one bit, might even make them stronger. Sadly his Plan "fail" while Minato plan is still a success. "Get the Picture?"
