That's an... interesting interpretation. While I agree the majority of it is superfluous, there are some key lines in there that I feel reveals quite a lot about the mindstate Imperfection is currently in, as well as how it informs reads of others listed within. I'm surprised you haven't seen that, too.
First this is Toujo's opinion about Imp's beginner analysis. Looks to me he gave positive remark to it.
And then X reply to Toujo, he said this,
Is it? To me, that's a meta read list and what the hell is that supposed to help? But what do you see in Imp's list that could potentially be helpful?
And this's Toujo's response to X's post,
Well the ins and outs will have to wait until I've finished work, but I'd like you to reread the lines where he gives an actual read on people. And then ask - does this make sense as scum? What about who he is giving town reads to. Is he likely to give town reads to scum mates. I don't know Imperfection as a player, so I can't make informed conclusions from this, but if nothing else it's worth noting while his general behaviour can fill in the rest, no?
Still positive remark he gave to Imp,
But take a look at his response to Poison,
A number of players here have played with me before, or at least heard of me. But that, too, is interesting. Imperfection strikes me as a confident player, and one where he would appeal to me by stroking my ego to win me onside. I actually have that down as one of his bad posts in there, as it strikes me as him essentially saying he's not going to bother reading me until the thread decides for him.
I subbed in to one game like two years, but for all intents and purposes yeah it is.
Look here, when he responded to X about Imp he always trying to take/advice X to see Imp in positive light. But when he responded to Poison out of nowhere he had something he think is negative about Imp.
Yes I know it's an attempt to shade. But what kind of shade? Scum shading scum or Scum shading town?
Scum shading scum is an effort to make Imp looks like town if something bad happen to Poison and Toujo in the future.