Is sarutobi equally to blame for the Uchiha Genocide

Is Hiruzen Responsible or not?


  • Total voters
    166

~Naruto&Itachi~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
10,491
Reaction score
850
They were out on the field .. just like the police is suppose to be JUST because they weren't shown doesn't mean they weren't there lol.


2. Sir listen, im basing this off from the first Kage Hashirama Senju.. ok?. Also, do you know HOW MUCH trouble Danzo has caused the leaf?? hell he was working with Oro.. UCHIHA WERE PART OF THE VILLAGE till the leaders decided to put them to the side
1. like you said show me manga page....lol that is STUPID we didn't see ONE uchiha facing the kyuubi

2. no you aren't you are just hating on him because hiruzen fanboys say Hashi < hiruzen and at that time oro was part of the village as well and thats danzo a TOTAL different person and he didn't want to be like madara he was trying to act like a shinobi because that's how shinobis are.....95% of shinobis are like him and other 5 are like hiruzen and hashi and naruto......Uchiha < Fire Country....only senjus believed in will of fire and hiruzen got that from 1st and 2nd
 

Netsui

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
5,628
Reaction score
408
I think tobi explained this already, only Danzo, Sarutobi, the other 2 consular knew about the Genocide.

the LEADERS OF KONOHA moved from a assumption.. You do know why there was gonna be a coup'd right??.

Yes, I do. I know what I'm talking about. For a big decision like that the councilmen and the Hokage probably have to decide together. If the councilmen out voted the Hokage, which they did, there wasn't much he could do.

And I don't get how the Hashirama could be related to this. Sure, he taught Sarutobi, and he fought Madara, wouldn't he be to blame as well? He could have made Madara a co-kage, or on the council, right?

The Uchiha's had other choices besides war, but they didn't take those other choices.
 

~Naruto&Itachi~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
10,491
Reaction score
850
I think tobi explained this already, only Danzo, Sarutobi, the other 2 consular knew about the Genocide.

the LEADERS OF KONOHA moved from a assumption.. You do know why there was gonna be a coup'd right??.
Ya and tobi also said that kyuubi attack was accidental to sasuke
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
The uchiha could of talked this out with Hiruzen or the elders, but they didn't.
They could of slowly gained the leaf's trust back, but they didn't
They chose to start a War.

The uchiha posed a threat to the village, Thus they were wiped out.

Simple as that really.


But is it not the Hokage's responsibility to put make both sides sit down and talk.? lol.

But, sir you have been seeing they posed a threat to the village.. BUT why did the village segregate them??
 

Netsui

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
5,628
Reaction score
408
But is it not the Hokage's responsibility to put make both sides sit down and talk.? lol.

But, sir you have been seeing they posed a threat to the village.. BUT why did the village segregate them??

I believe we answered your question. They separated them from the village so they could keep an eye on them. The elders thought that if the Uchiha's were behind the Kyuubi attack then they were still a threat to the village.

And don't you think Hiruzen tried that? The Uchiha's were beyond negotiations, I said that a few times already. The Uchiha's wouldn't talk, and Hiruzen wanted to talk to them.
 

Exaar

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 2, 2011
Messages
12,773
Reaction score
1,296
But is it not the Hokage's responsibility to put make both sides sit down and talk.? lol.

But, sir you have been seeing they posed a threat to the village.. BUT why did the village segregate them??

As i keep saying, The uchiha are beyond words, Even if he wanted to get both sides together i doubt the uchiha would agree.
Also if he did this, This would expose Itachi as the Spy for the village.

If words could of stopped this, He would of done it, Hiruzen/Danzo and itachi all knew this had gone beyond mere words.

Not all the village segregated them, They could of easily cleared this matter up and Slowly Regained the leafs trust.
Plus there are only Two ways to controll the Kyuubi, Hashirama's wood or Sharingan Genjutsu, Since hashirama is dead you figure it out.

Hiruzen would of listened to them if they wanted to Argue the matter of the kyuubi attack, but they didn't want to talk about it.

There is a time for talking and there is a time for action, The time for talking was over.
 

~Naruto&Itachi~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
10,491
Reaction score
850
But is it not the Hokage's responsibility to put make both sides sit down and talk.? lol.

But, sir you have been seeing they posed a threat to the village.. BUT why did the village segregate them??
i have a question for you question.....Why did they not help during the kyuubi attack?? and Danzo went behind 3rds back and ordered itachi to choose side just in case you forgot here is the manga....
1.
You must be registered for see images
than danzo does this:
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
1. like you said show me manga page....lol that is STUPID we didn't see ONE uchiha facing the kyuubi

2. no you aren't you are just hating on him because hiruzen fanboys say Hashi < hiruzen and at that time oro was part of the village as well and thats danzo a TOTAL different person and he didn't want to be like madara he was trying to act like a shinobi because that's how shinobis are.....95% of shinobis are like him and other 5 are like hiruzen and hashi and naruto......Uchiha < Fire Country....only senjus believed in will of fire and hiruzen got that from 1st and 2nd

o_O Actually i always used to agree with Hiruzen being the Strongest.. lol. until the Tobi flashback. And Oro was not part of the village at that time He had already left.

And it wasn't uchiha< Fire country.. Fire country had no clue about this lol. Hell uchiha AGREED TO THE DEAL with fire country.. UCHIHA BELIEVED IN THE WILL OF FIRE (Itachi).

Also it doesn't matter if danzo wanted to be like madara or not in the end They shared the Same belief.. Through power comes peace. BUT hiruzen believe through love comes peace..
And also the whole konoha believe in the Will of Fire not JUST the senju.. the senju faded away after the leaf was created


Yes, I do. I know what I'm talking about. For a big decision like that the councilmen and the Hokage probably have to decide together. If the councilmen out voted the Hokage, which they did, there wasn't much he could do.

And I don't get how the Hashirama could be related to this. Sure, he taught Sarutobi, and he fought Madara, wouldn't he be to blame as well? He could have made Madara a co-kage, or on the council, right?

The Uchiha's had other choices besides war, but they didn't take those other choices.

I never said you didn't know what you were talking about. Also, Councilman are there to advice the Hokage.. they do not run the village with him. And also Coup'd isn't a war.. Uchiha never called for a war... Danzo and them assumed there was gonna be war.. BUT WHAT HOKAGE SEGREGATES HIS OWN PEOPLE?!

Also Hashirama was chosen by the people.. He respected the uchiha.. He respected other countries to. And co-kage is like co-president..lol not a safe move.

Ya and tobi also said that kyuubi attack was accidental to sasuke

And come on really.. we all know about this from what tobi said.. otherwise we don't know anything about the incident at all besides the fact itachi killed them. Tobi said kyuubi attack was a accident but that was prooven wrong... nothing else has been prooved wrong ;p
 

Netsui

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
5,628
Reaction score
408
o_O Actually i always used to agree with Hiruzen being the Strongest.. lol. until the Tobi flashback. And Oro was not part of the village at that time He had already left.

And it wasn't uchiha< Fire country.. Fire country had no clue about this lol. Hell uchiha AGREED TO THE DEAL with fire country.. UCHIHA BELIEVED IN THE WILL OF FIRE (Itachi).

Also it doesn't matter if danzo wanted to be like madara or not in the end They shared the Same belief.. Through power comes peace. BUT hiruzen believe through love comes peace..
And also the whole konoha believe in the Will of Fire not JUST the senju.. the senju faded away after the leaf was created

I never said you didn't know what you were talking about. Also, Councilman are there to advice the Hokage.. they do not run the village with him. And also Coup'd isn't a war.. Uchiha never called for a war... Danzo and them assumed there was gonna be war.. BUT WHAT HOKAGE SEGREGATES HIS OWN PEOPLE?!

Also Hashirama was chosen by the people.. He respected the uchiha.. He respected other countries to. And co-kage is like co-president..lol not a safe move.

And come on really.. we all know about this from what tobi said.. otherwise we don't know anything about the incident at all besides the fact itachi killed them. Tobi said kyuubi attack was a accident but that was prooven wrong... nothing else has been prooved wrong ;p

I know a coup isn't a war, but if they did attack Konoha it would have caused a Civil War. A whole clan attacking a whole village. It probably would have took time until the battle would end. Not to mention other villages could have attacked from all the confusion of the Civil War.
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
As i keep saying, The uchiha are beyond words, Even if he wanted to get both sides together i doubt the uchiha would agree.
Also if he did this, This would expose Itachi as the Spy for the village.

If words could of stopped this, He would of done it, Hiruzen/Danzo and itachi all knew this had gone beyond mere words.

Not all the village segregated them, They could of easily cleared this matter up and Slowly Regained the leafs trust.
Plus there are only Two ways to controll the Kyuubi, Hashirama's wood or Sharingan Genjutsu, Since hashirama is dead you figure it out.

Hiruzen would of listened to them if they wanted to Argue the matter of the kyuubi attack, but they didn't want to talk about it.

There is a time for talking and there is a time for action, The time for talking was over.

Uchiha are beyond words?? really?? is that why they made friends with there arch-rivals? And also there was no talk.. they weren't even asked.. INSTEAD what the hokage did was listen to his buddy Danzo and segregate them.. OF COURSE THERE ARE GONNA COUP'D. WHY WOULD THEY NOT ?? THEY HELPED MADE THE DAMN VILLAGE. lol.
 

~Naruto&Itachi~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
10,491
Reaction score
850
1. o_O Actually i always used to agree with Hiruzen being the Strongest.. lol. until the Tobi flashback. And Oro was not part of the village at that time He had already left.

And it wasn't uchiha< Fire country.. Fire country had no clue about this lol. Hell uchiha AGREED TO THE DEAL with fire country.. 2. UCHIHA BELIEVED IN THE WILL OF FIRE (Itachi).

And come on really.. we all know about this from what tobi said.. otherwise we don't know anything about the incident at all besides the fact itachi killed them. Tobi said kyuubi attack was a accident but that was prooven wrong... 3. nothing else has been prooved wrong ;p
1. You joined THIS month
2. NO THEY DIDN'T....are you stupid??? or do you not read the manga???? Uchihas NEVER believed in will of fire....
3. he isn't madara
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
I know a coup isn't a war, but if they did attack Konoha it would have caused a Civil War. A whole clan attacking a whole village. It probably would have took time until the battle would end. Not to mention other villages could have attacked from all the confusion of the Civil War.

They weren't gonna attack konoha.. But instead the leaders.. Coup'd is a rebellion against a goverment. (should watch V for Vendetta , if you haven't). Thats a coup'd. It can go either way . The people of Konoha had no clue about this .. Instead only four people..
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
1. You joined THIS month
2. NO THEY DIDN'T....are you stupid??? or do you not read the manga???? Uchihas NEVER believed in will of fire....
3. he isn't madara

And what does me joining have anything to do with me agreeing Hiruzen was the strongest.. lol. I do have youtube accounts.. lol.

2. The will of fire became the motto for the leaf village. (Naruto wikia states it to and Itachi prooves it)

3. Never said he was madara but his ideals are the same Control and Power
 

Exaar

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 2, 2011
Messages
12,773
Reaction score
1,296
Uchiha are beyond words?? really?? is that why they made friends with there arch-rivals? And also there was no talk.. they weren't even asked.. INSTEAD what the hokage did was listen to his buddy Danzo and segregate them.. OF COURSE THERE ARE GONNA COUP'D. WHY WOULD THEY NOT ?? THEY HELPED MADE THE DAMN VILLAGE. lol.

The uchiha should of Proven danzo wrong then, Not Threaten to take over the leaf.

The Hokage didn't just listen to Danzo, Hiruzen wanted to stop the uchiha clan with words, While danzo wanted to kill them.
Thus hiruzen going against danzo's Plans.

If words could of saved the clan do you not think Itachi would have done it?.

They helped make the village yes, But that doesn't give them the right to put the village in danger.

If the hokage had doubts he has to follow them up, Just in case, it's his job to keep the village safe.

The uchiha could of had talks befor they started to plan to take over the leaf, They're more to blame that Hiruzen or Danzo.
The uchiha wern't thinking of their children when planning this, they wernt thinking of their village or country.

They were only thinking of themselves
 

Exaar

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 2, 2011
Messages
12,773
Reaction score
1,296
They weren't gonna attack konoha.. But instead the leaders.. Coup'd is a rebellion against a goverment. (should watch V for Vendetta , if you haven't). Thats a coup'd. It can go either way . The people of Konoha had no clue about this .. Instead only four people..

Yes they would.

The village would attack them to defend their village/Hokage.

You really think the leaf shinobi would stand back as the uchiha attack their Hokage?.
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
The uchiha should of Proven danzo wrong then, Not Threaten to take over the leaf.

The Hokage didn't just listen to Danzo, Hiruzen wanted to stop the uchiha clan with words, While danzo wanted to kill them.
Thus hiruzen going against danzo's Plans.

If words could of saved the clan do you not think Itachi would have done it?.

They helped make the village yes, But that doesn't give them the right to put the village in danger.

If the hokage had doubts he has to follow them up, Just in case, it's his job to keep the village safe.

The uchiha could of had talks befor they started to plan to take over the leaf, They're more to blame that Hiruzen or Danzo.
The uchiha wern't thinking of their children when planning this, they wernt thinking of their village or country.

They were only thinking of themselves



Coup'd doesn't mean a war or a civil war.. or taking over the village.

Also, really they are to blame?? your not gonna blame the leaders for not sitting down and talking?? instead blame the people who got tired of Segregation. Also Even itachi says that all of it was true..


but why did the leaders put them to the side of the village after the nine-tails attack ??? why? there was no reason. You didn't see hashirama killing the "Uchiha for what madara did.


Also, If sarutobi didn't agree with Danzo.. about Segregating the Uchiha then it wouldn't have happened
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
Yes they would.

The village would attack them to defend their village/Hokage.

You really think the leaf shinobi would stand back as the uchiha attack their Hokage?.

uh uchiha are leaf shinobi to.. Naruto's mom was friends with Sasukes.. lol.

And, your saying the leaf shinobi would attack there own people?? without even asking the damn reason? uh no. If it had happened. DANZO's power would have been gone. This was basically politics.

But im not mad at Sarutoi for letting it happen. But instead For letting Danzo control part of the Goverment
 

Exaar

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Jul 2, 2011
Messages
12,773
Reaction score
1,296
Coup'd doesn't mean a war or a civil war.. or taking over the village.

Also, really they are to blame?? your not gonna blame the leaders for not sitting down and talking?? instead blame the people who got tired of Segregation. Also Even itachi says that all of it was true..


but why did the leaders put them to the side of the village after the nine-tails attack ??? why? there was no reason. You didn't see hashirama killing the "Uchiha for what madara did.


Also, If sarutobi didn't agree with Danzo.. about Segregating the Uchiha then it wouldn't have happened

Is it really that hard to understand?.

Yes the uchiha are to Blame, They could of Proved everyone wrong by Regaining Trust.
They could of just Put up and shut up, But no they didn't.
They planned to take over the leaf, They put themselves above the village.

The uchiha could of done things different but they didn't, They chose the wrong path and payed for it.

uh uchiha are leaf shinobi to.. Naruto's mom was friends with Sasukes.. lol.

And, your saying the leaf shinobi would attack there own people?? without even asking the damn reason? uh no. If it had happened. DANZO's power would have been gone. This was basically politics.

But im not mad at Sarutoi for letting it happen. But instead For letting Danzo control part of the Goverment

IF they attacked the Hokage, They would be no longer leaf shinobi, They would of been classes as Rogue Ninja.
Leaf shinboi defend their Hokage no questions asked, If you attack your own kage you are no longer a shinobi of that village.

Danzo has a vital role, He protects the village no matter the cost, Every village needs a Danzo character to survive.
Every village has dark secrets.
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
Is it really that hard to understand?.

Yes the uchiha are to Blame, They could of Proved everyone wrong by Regaining Trust.
They could of just Put up and shut up, But no they didn't.
They planned to take over the leaf, They put themselves above the village.

The uchiha could of done things different but they didn't, They chose the wrong path and payed for it.



IF they attacked the Hokage, They would be no longer leaf shinobi, They would of been classes as Rogue Ninja.
Leaf shinboi defend their Hokage no questions asked, If you attack your own kage you are no longer a shinobi of that village.

Danzo has a vital role, He protects the village no matter the cost, Every village needs a Danzo character to survive.
Every village has dark secrets.



Ok Danzo DOES NOT protect the village.. but instead does whatever he can to make himself HOKAGE. (he didn't do shit when Oro attacked and letted the third hokage die).

And just because they attack the Hokage does not mean they are Rouge ninja. Also, they won't be directly attacking.. instead its more like a Protest.. Cause apparently the damn leaders were blind as hell.

So far your blaming the cuhiha. Yet not Danzo. who responsible for the Sand attacking the konoha.. Letting Pein destroy the village...
 

~Naruto&Itachi~

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
10,491
Reaction score
850
Ok Danzo DOES NOT protect the village.. but instead does whatever he can to make himself HOKAGE. (he didn't do shit when Oro attacked and letted the third hokage die).

And just because they attack the Hokage does not mean they are Rouge ninja. Also, they won't be directly attacking.. instead its more like a Protest.. Cause apparently the damn leaders were blind as hell.

So far your blaming the cuhiha. Yet not Danzo. who responsible for the Sand attacking the konoha.. Letting Pein destroy the village...
Yes attacking your kage means you are a criminal......they were attack them you don't know what civil war is?..are you mental????? lol so you think you can attack your president and not get in trouble??? and Uchiha didn't believe in will of fire only senjus did
 
Top