Hidan cannot take a rod to the head.

[RedRobin]

You have shown NO TYPE OF EVIDENCE. The only evidence you have is your pathetic little opinion, which doesn't mean shit if its not backed up by some kind of evidence. Do I need to show you examples and the definition of EVIDENCE? "It just doesn't" isn't evidence.

You made the claim buddy, you are expected to back it up. Which you haven't done. I've shown you evidence (Along with at least 2 other people in this thread) that real life logic DOESN'T apply here, meaning you have no argument. A man, in real life, spoke and walked after a metal rod had been shot through his head...yet you think that based on real life logic, I'll, or anyone else with a functioning brain, will admit that Hidan won't be able to do anything with a rod in his head?

Hidan has gone on despite his brain being without oxygen, but you throw out those examples and say that this is the brain so its different...based on what? Oh wait, nothing but your opinion.



What you don't understand is that you can't apply real life logic to a manga. This is getting pretty damn pathetic.

Lack of oxygen is not going to effect someone who is immortal, there organs will continue to strive since they are immortal even if he leaves a rod in his heart he will survive. But the brain is different its not simple like the heart, its completely different. Sticking a rod in the brain is going to effect him on matter what and since the rod is staying in his brain the effect wont ware off until the rod is removed.

 

[RedRobin]

A head attached to the body makes any human what they are but Hidan survives wo that.

Honestly you are applying some irrelevant logic to a completely different concept and scaling of living. It is like...comparing a desert to arctic and saying "we can not have snow there".

Random people survive it yet supernatural ninja would get incapacitated? Lol.

No the body hardly matters. The brain is everything about a person.

The comparison makes no sense.

You are making the brain out to be less important when its the most important thing.

 

[ShiroT]

No the body hardly matters. The brain is everything about a person.

The comparison makes no sense.

You are making the brain out to be less important when its the most important thing.

AH! you just said the brain is everything about a person when it is infact not. naruto has souls and a afterlife. the brain is not hidan, hidans souls is hidan. and you just said organs will continue to strive. please tell me where you got this idea that the brain sends "immortal" signals throughout the body? and since the organs of a body will strive, the brain will to.

 

[paratise]

No the body hardly matters. The brain is everything about a person.

Brain is inside the head doe.

The comparison makes no sense.

You make no sense.

You are making the brain out to be less important when its the most important thing.

Sorry for offending brain community.

 

[RedRobin]

AH! you just said the brain is everything about a person when it is infact not. naruto has souls and a afterlife. the brain is not hidan, hidans souls is hidan. and you just said organs will continue to strive. please tell me where you got this idea that the brain sends "immortal" signals throughout the body? and since the organs of a body will strive, the brain will to.

Not when the part of the brain which makes thoughts, and then tells the body to do these thoughts is destroyed.

Every ability has a weakness, immortal yes but doesnt mean he cant be incapacitated. Manga shows that lol.

 

[Kirokill]

PawnX, talking civily, what are you basing your theory off, if it's not real life?

A heart is crucial as much as the brain is, if not more, without the heart, you are dead, as the heart circulates the blood, and adds the oxygen to it, without the heart. you are rotten.
The brain is the part that send functions to the body for it to move, however it also contains the thoughts, memory in the back(not quite the brain) and all others.
Hidan is an immortal being, immortals do not exist in real life. Immortals seen to be undying. From shows, we can see different types of immortality.
There are immortals who do not die from starvation or old age, yet they die when slain.
There are immortals who die for old age and starvation, but they do not die from being slain or cut, this is the case with Hidan.

Using real life logic, excluding the blood circulation(because immortality), being hit in the brain should stop or impale, corrupt organs, in the body, and the body would either lose function, or not fully function.(This is what you're saying).
However having your head cut off would do the same thing, the brain would not be able to send signals to the body, the brain would not get oxygen from the heart, and both should be rotten and dead in little time, but because Hidan is immortal, he doesn't need that.
So we get two things, one being that Hidan doesn't need blood, two Hidan doesn't need oxygen, therefor his head can always move by itself when it's cut, but the body isn't.

Hidan stabbing his own heart is a backup to what I said, I don't recall seeing blood from Hidan, if it happened I think it was black. Seeing as Hidan doesn't regrow limbs, we see that he has no need for his organs other that.

What you are trying to say, is that why, why does his heart being useless for his survival, and why isn't his brain since he can always move it(his head). Which you try to seem to imply that his brain still has functions, if his body and head got separated, only his head is managed to move.

But the thing is I got from the conclusion is, if he doesn't need his organs in his body, I don't why he wouldn't need it in his head as well, which proves your theory being flawed in a way.

Am I saying in a right way, can you point out any mistakes, without just denying all, but point by point.

 

[KidGamer65]

Lack of oxygen is not going to effect someone who is immortal, there organs will continue to strive since they are immortal even if he leaves a rod in his heart he will survive. But the brain is different its not simple like the heart, its completely different. Sticking a rod in the brain is going to effect him on matter what and since the rod is staying in his brain the effect wont ware off until the rod is removed.

Lack of Oxygen affects the brain, and by your logic since the brain is different than the rest of the organs, it should be adversely affected by the lack of Oxygen, but it wasn't. We aren't talking about the rest of his organs here, we are talking about the brain. Why should I believe a metal rod in his brain will deprive him of all function? Especially when people have had parts of their brains destroyed and still had function.

Phineas Gage had a metal pole shot through his head. His frontal lobe and the left lobe of his cerebrum are areas where the pole passed through. Guess what? He lived a normal life after they had finished treating him.

You must be registered for see links

And don't say "The rod wasn't stuck there" cause it doesn't make a difference. A damaged brain is a damaged brain.

This is a manga about ninja, and Hidan is even stranger than the rest of them. A small metal pike stabbing him in the brain isn't going to make him lose brain function. Not a chance.

 

[ShiroT]

Not when the part of the brain which makes thoughts, and then tells the body to do these thoughts is destroyed.

Every ability has a weakness, immortal yes but doesnt mean he cant be incapacitated. Manga shows that lol.

you didnt answer my question. where did you get these "immortality" signals from?