Hidan cannot take a rod to the head.

[RedRobin]

The only logic I've seen is coming from your opposition.



Well, since you stated it like that, I'll just take your word for it.. Or nah. Get proof for the stuff you are posting or concede. You must be getting desperate since you decided to pull this out of your arse.

lol I have shown you the evidence but you dont want to see it. Not my fault. You keep telling me to get evidence but bring your own that shows he can. But I already know you cant.

You obviously dont understand immortality or how the brain works and how important the brain is to everything that lives in NV.

 

[RedRobin]

do you know how immortals work? im starting to think you dont understand what it means. there are infact animals without brains who can live forever. they have no brains.

lol no brain no life. Please stop with that ridiculous argument.

 

[ShiroT]

lol no brain no life. Please stop with that ridiculous argument.

how are jelly fish alive then? they have no brains.

oh this must be trolling lol

 

[RedRobin]

how are jelly fish alive then? they have no brains.

oh this must be trolling lol

Of course bring something so irrelevant as that up. Way to take what i said extremely literally.

We are talking about things like humans. When humans are brain dead, there is no coming back from that.

 

[ShiroT]

Of course bring something so irrelevant as that up. Way to take what i said extremely literally.

We are talking about things like humans. When humans are brain dead, there is no coming back from that.

you said there is no life without brains. i gave you life.

you wanted to use real world logic of how hidan would pass out if his brain was injuryed. i show you how his brain didnt even need his lungs and all his other organs worked after being injured.

i dont know what else you want

 

[Dannie]

Hidan stabbed his heart to kill Asuma.

Don't think a little stab to the brain will kill him not to mention he got stabbed in two vital points. Shikamaru also pierced his body in several locations and he was fine after all this.

And yes, as others has already mentioned his head was chopped off and he could still talk.

 

[RedRobin]

Hidan stabbed his heart to kill Asuma.

Don't think a little stab to the brain will kill him not to mention he got stabbed in two vital points. Shikamaru also pierced his body in several locations and he was fine after all this.

And yes, as others has already mentioned his head was chopped off and he could still talk.

That is his immortality. It wont work when there is a rod in his brain.

The brain allows for his immortality, the brain is his immortality, its the core of of everything about Hidan.

Its so simple I dont understand how people cant get it.

 

[paratise]

Hidan stabbed his heart to kill Asuma.

Don't think a little stab to the brain will kill him not to mention he got stabbed in two vital points. Shikamaru also pierced his body in several locations and he was fine after all this.

And yes, as others has already mentioned his head was chopped off and he could still talk.

Join the FC in my sig plz i am cat btw.

OT: You are using real life logic and even in real life some people survived getting impaled/stabbed into their brains.

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

 

[RedRobin]

Join the FC in my sig plz i am cat btw.

OT: You are using real life logic and even in real life some people survived getting impaled/stabbed into their brains.

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

In all those cases have the objects been left in their heads?

 

[ShiroT]

That is his immortality. It wont work when there is a rod in his brain.

The brain allows for his immortality, the brain is his immortality, its the core of of everything about Hidan.

Its so simple I dont understand how people cant get it.

if the brain is immortality, then when his head was severed his brain could no longer send signals do his body. his body would decay since his brain cant send the "immortality" signals. his heart wouldve stopped. all his blood wouldve poured out. he would have no blood in him. His spinal cord was severed so even after his head was put back on he brain couldnt send the "immortal" signal anymore because there was no spine to send it through. Not to mention all his other organs wouldve shut down

Why didnt this happen?

 

[paratise]

In all those cases have the objects been left in their heads?

Does it matter? All we can see is a stab to the brain is not shutting the whole system down.

And for example for that:

You must be registered for see links

 

[ShiroT]

Does it matter? All we can see is a stab to the brain is not shutting the whole system down.

And for example for that:

You must be registered for see links

/thread .

 

[RedRobin]

Does it matter? All we can see is a stab to the brain is not shutting the whole system down.

And for example for that:

You must be registered for see links

It does matter. As my whole point was having the rod stay in his head and go through his brain.

Also if that is the game which wants to be played then its only logical that Tsunade survives the same thing with her regeneration. But of course it wont be I guess.

 

[paratise]

It does matter. As my whole point was having the rod stay in his head and go through his brain.

Also if that is the game which wants to be played then its only logical that Tsunade survives the same thing with her regeneration. But of course it wont be I guess.

Well it does not matter for a supernatural immortal ninja when humans can survive it.

Even in rl logic, to incapacitate Hidan completely someone has to pinpoint and simply destroy or remove the place in Hidan's brain which controls movements (cerebellum):

You must be registered for see images

So he can not remove the thing from his brain as other parts of his brain would be irrelevant to incapacitating him.

Some random stab is not taking him down.


I did not get the 2nd part of your post btw.

 

[Dannie]

That is his immortality. It wont work when there is a rod in his brain.

The brain allows for his immortality, the brain is his immortality, its the core of of everything about Hidan.

Its so simple I dont understand how people cant get it.

Ok, I'm not really going to bother with this thread considering it's from you but..
His immortality worked when he stabbed his own heart and killed Asuma, but you are trying to say that he will die if he gets stabbed in the brain because his brain performs his immortal ability, but where is this evidence again? Is this evidence in your real life anatomy book or is it in the manga? His head got chopped off and he was still able to speak, but don't you need your neck to breath in oxygen so you can live? Why didn't Hidan die then? Do you even know what the word immortal means?

im·mor·tal /i(m)ˈmôrtl/ adjective

adjective: immortal

1. living forever; never dying or decaying.
"our mortal bodies are inhabited by immortal souls"
synonyms: undying, deathless, eternal, everlasting, never-ending, endless, lasting, enduring, ceaseless; More

> In real life, if someone's head gets chopped off then they will be unable to speak and will die. Hidan could speak and was completely fine afterwards.


> In real life, if someone gets stabbed in multiple vital points on the body then they will die. Hidan was fine afterwards and could still move.

> In real life, if someone gets stabbed in the heart then they will die instantly. Hidan was fine.

2. If you want to state that the brain allows for his immortality ability then I could say that the heart allows for his living functions for the blood and since he had already been stabbed in the heart, why didn't he die? Surely if you get stabbed in the heart then you should die right? So why did Hidan survive it? He is immortal that's why, so why can't he survive a stab to the brain again? According to you, Because his brain is his leading function and controls his movements including his immortality??

If you haven't noticed, Hidan is not normal nor does he follow any type of logic, so coming up with this fallacy of Hidan dying while being impaled to the brain is really stupid.

The only way for Hidan to die is for his whole body to be completely annihilated in an instant like what Shikamaru did, but when his body parts were scattered throughout the hole he could still talk, and you want to argue that his brain will end his life when Hidan should have died on several occasions, but didn't?

You obviously don't know anything about fictional immortality or human anatomy while at the same time you are trying to use real instances of life in a fictional based manga.

*Also, weren't you that same little punk that said that Tsuande or Sakura could survive a stab to the head when they themselves don't even have any type of immortality ability? You hate on Hidan and wank Sakura at the same time, so your whole thread is full of errors.

 

[RedRobin]

Well it does not matter for a supernatural immortal ninja when humans can survive it.

Even in rl logic, to incapacitate Hidan completely someone has to pinpoint and simply destroy or remove the place in Hidan's brain which controls movements (cerebellum):

You must be registered for see images

So he can not remove the thing from his brain as other parts of his brain would be irrelevant to incapacitating him.

Some random stab is not taking him down.


I did not get the 2nd part of your post btw.

The frontal lobe controls decision making, consciousness and purposeful behaviors. That gone, Hidan has no idea what to do in life anymore.

All lobes work together to make the person what they are. Getting stabbed anywhere in the head will effect you no matter what.

People are making out the brain to not be how big it actually is but if Tsunade was to be in the same situation then of course she would die because the brain controls everything right?

 

[RedRobin]

Ok, I'm not really going to bother with this thread considering it's from you but..
His immortality worked when he stabbed his own heart and killed Asuma, but you are trying to say that he will die if he gets stabbed in the brain because his brain performs his immortal ability, but where is this evidence again? Is this evidence in your real life anatomy book or is it in the manga? His head got chopped off and he was still able to speak, but don't you need your neck to breath in oxygen so you can live? Why didn't Hidan die then? Do you even know what the word immortal means?

im·mor·tal /i(m)ˈmôrtl/ adjective

adjective: immortal

1. living forever; never dying or decaying.
"our mortal bodies are inhabited by immortal souls"
synonyms: undying, deathless, eternal, everlasting, never-ending, endless, lasting, enduring, ceaseless; More

> In real life, if someone's head gets chopped off then they will be unable to speak and will die. Hidan could speak and was completely fine afterwards.


> In real life, if someone gets stabbed in multiple vital points on the body then they will die. Hidan was fine afterwards and could still move.

> In real life, if someone gets stabbed in the heart then they will die instantly. Hidan was fine.

2. If you want to state that the brain allows for his immortality ability then I could say that the heart allows for his living functions for the blood and since he had already been stabbed in the heart, why didn't he die? Surely if you get stabbed in the heart then you should die right? So why did Hidan survive it? He is immortal that's why, so why can't he survive a stab to the brain again? According to you, Because his brain is his leading function and controls his movements including his immortality??

If you haven't noticed, Hidan is not normal nor does he follow any type of logic, so coming up with this fallacy of Hidan dying while being impaled to the brain is really stupid.

The only way for Hidan to die is for his whole body to be completely annihilated in an instant like what Shikamaru did, but when his body parts were scattered throughout the hole he could still talk, and you want to argue that his brain will end his life when Hidan should have died on several occasions, but didn't?

You obviously don't know anything about fictional immortality or human anatomy while at the same time you are trying to use real instances of life in a fictional based manga.

*Also, weren't you that same little punk that said that Tsuande or Sakura could survive a stab to the head when they themselves don't even have any type of immortality ability? You hate on Hidan and wank Sakura at the same time, so your whole thread is full of errors.

lol I never said he would die. He would be put out of commission until said object was removed from his brain.

Also no I never once said Tsunade or Sakura survive getting their heads cut of or getting stabbed in the head. But you can leave since this thread was made by me and you have some issue with me.

 

[ShiroT]

The frontal lobe controls decision making, consciousness and purposeful behaviors. That gone, Hidan has no idea what to do in life anymore.

All lobes work together to make the person what they are. Getting stabbed anywhere in the head will effect you no matter what.

People are making out the brain to not be how big it actually is but if Tsunade was to be in the same situation then of course she would die because the brain controls everything right?

this isnt a thread about tsunade if you want to discuss her make a thread about her then.

again. his heart worked completely fine after being impaled. his brain doesnt circulate the blood his heart does. what makes you think hitting his frontal lobe would shut him down?

 

[KidGamer65]

lol I have shown you the evidence but you dont want to see it. Not my fault. You keep telling me to get evidence but bring your own that shows he can. But I already know you cant.

You have shown NO TYPE OF EVIDENCE. The only evidence you have is your pathetic little opinion, which doesn't mean shit if its not backed up by some kind of evidence. Do I need to show you examples and the definition of EVIDENCE? "It just doesn't" isn't evidence.

You made the claim buddy, you are expected to back it up. Which you haven't done. I've shown you evidence (Along with at least 2 other people in this thread) that real life logic DOESN'T apply here, meaning you have no argument. A man, in real life, spoke and walked after a metal rod had been shot through his head...yet you think that based on real life logic, I'll, or anyone else with a functioning brain, will admit that Hidan won't be able to do anything with a rod in his head?

Hidan has gone on despite his brain being without oxygen, but you throw out those examples and say that this is the brain so its different...based on what? Oh wait, nothing but your opinion.

You obviously dont understand immortality or how the brain works and how important the brain is to everything that lives in NV.

What you don't understand is that you can't apply real life logic to a manga. This is getting pretty damn pathetic. "His brain tells his body about his immortality" lmao. Get some proof for this bullshit buddy, I'll be waiting.

 

[paratise]

The frontal lobe controls decision making, consciousness and purposeful behaviors. That gone, Hidan has no idea what to do in life anymore.

All lobes work together to make the person what they are. Getting stabbed anywhere in the head will effect you no matter what.

A head attached to the body makes any human what they are but Hidan survives wo that.

Honestly you are applying some irrelevant logic to a completely different concept and scaling of living. It is like...comparing a desert to arctic and saying "we can not have snow there".

Random people survive it yet supernatural ninja would get incapacitated? Lol.