Proof that possibily can't be countered: Preta Path failed to absorb Ninjutsu

[TheSages456]

It means it's not proof which you claim. Proof is a ninjutsu hitting the barrier and the barrier failing to absorb the technique.

no, proof is nagato getting smacked by ninjutsu in the middle of combat when his canonical reaction against all ninjutsu that can be absorbed is preta path.

 

[Midday]

no, proof is nagato getting smacked by ninjutsu in the middle of combat when his canonical reaction against all ninjutsu that can be absorbed is preta path.

Seeing as you haven't figured it out i'll use an example with your flawed reasoning.

"Susanoo can't block rasenshuriken as Madara used petra path instead."


I can also ignore every thing that leading up to that situation and call it proof.

 

[TheSages456]

Seeing as you haven't figured it out i'll use an example with your flawed reasoning.

"Susanoo can't block rasenshuriken as Madara used petra path instead."


I can also ignore every thing that leading up to that situation and call it proof.

what you are saying is a logical fallacy. you tried to disprove the manga with logically unsound reasoning.

there was nothing stopping nagato from using preta path to rid of amaterasu or susano when he actually came in contact with them so you do not have the grounds to make a claim that he can when this didnt happen in the canon encounter in the manga.

 

[Retsu]

Seeing as you haven't figured it out i'll use an example with your flawed reasoning.

"Susanoo can't block rasenshuriken as Madara used petra path instead."


I can also ignore every thing that leading up to that situation and call it proof.

Don't waste your breath, some ppl are just too caught up in what they think is right.

 

[zahari]

That is the real Naruto and he can't be absorbed..

 

[Midday]

what you are saying is a logical fallacy. you tried to disprove the manga with logically unsound reasoning.

there was nothing stopping nagato from using preta path to rid of amaterasu or susano so you do not have the grounds to make a claim that he can when this didnt happen in the canon encounter in the manga.

The bold is exactly what you've been doing. You've ignored the fact that edo's aren't in control and can't kill one another shown by the Mizukage trying to kill Mu so there's no need for them to defend against each other. Secondly you ignore that Kabuto was dealing only with Naruto and Bee and completely ignored Itachi.

Also since when does choosing one option over another mean that the option not used can not work. That's like me choosing to drive somewhere does that mean my legs wont be able to get me to the same place?

You cling to manga facts and cannon material. Here are the facts petra path has yet to fail against absorbing any ninjutsu, by fail I mean petra path activated and ninjutsu hitting it and being absorbed. It's even absorbed transformation justu's and sage energy. This supports the databooks statement of it being able to absorb all ninjutsu regardless of its properties.

Going by the facts you love to cling to petra path absorbs that mass of chakra(susanoo) and that high level katon(amaterasu).

Don't waste your breath, some ppl are just too caught up in what they think is right.

Totally agree, I'm getting tired of thesages nonsense.

 

[Retsu]

The bold is exactly what you've been doing. You've ignored the fact that edo's aren't in control and can't kill one another shown by the Mizukage trying to kill Mu so there's no need for them to defend against each other. Secondly you ignore that Kabuto was dealing only with Naruto and Bee and completely ignored Itachi.

You cling to manga facts and cannon material. Here are the facts petra path is yet to fail against absorbing any ninjutsu, by fail I mean petra path activated and ninjutsu hitting it and being absorbed. It's even absorbed transformation justu's and sage energy. This supports the databooks statement of it being able to absorb all ninjutsu regardless of its properties.

Going by the facts you love to cling to petra path absorbs that mass of chakra(susanoo) and that high level katon(amaterasu).

You go boy

 

[ninthgate]

fail thread ftl

 

[TheSages456]

The bold is exactly what you've been doing. You've ignored the fact that edo's aren't in control and can't kill one another shown by the Mizukage trying to kill Mu so there's no need for them to defend against each other. Secondly you ignore that Kabuto was dealing only with Naruto and Bee and completely ignored Itachi.

preta path is activated at the speed of thought. in the anime has shown that nagato or more specifically kabuto saw itachis susano coming towards him before it sliced nagatos arm off. that means that nagato had time to physically react so erecting preta paths barrier wouldve been easy.

You cling to manga facts and cannon material. Here are the facts petra path is yet to fail against absorbing any ninjutsu, by fail I mean petra path activated and ninjutsu hitting it and being absorbed. It's even absorbed transformation justu's and sage energy. This supports the databooks statement of it being able to absorb all ninjutsu regardless of its properties.

absolutely laughable.
kabuto whos knows the workings of the 6 paths abilities used shinra tensei instead of preta path to rid of amaterasu. we have seen amaterasu and susanos effect on a conscious rinnegan user(kabuto who controlled nagato). whether nagato had preta path up and it failed against these techs are irrelevant as there was nothing stopping him from using preta path.

Going by the facts you love to cling to petra path absorbs that mass of chakra(susanoo) and that high level katon(amaterasu).

this was debunked by the manga. there isnt a discussion to be had.

 

[Draphsin]

The bold is exactly what you've been doing. You've ignored the fact that edo's aren't in control and can't kill one another shown by the Mizukage trying to kill Mu so there's no need for them to defend against each other. Secondly you ignore that Kabuto was dealing only with Naruto and Bee and completely ignored Itachi.

Also since when does choosing one option over another mean that the option not used can not work. That's like me choosing to drive somewhere does that mean my legs wont be able to get me to the same place?

You cling to manga facts and cannon material. Here are the facts petra path has yet to fail against absorbing any ninjutsu, by fail I mean petra path activated and ninjutsu hitting it and being absorbed. It's even absorbed transformation justu's and sage energy. This supports the databooks statement of it being able to absorb all ninjutsu regardless of its properties.

Going by the facts you love to cling to petra path absorbs that mass of chakra(susanoo) and that high level katon(amaterasu).



Totally agree, I'm getting tired of thesages nonsense.

Wow, this thread turned out great in my absence =D

@Midday: Im so glad im not the only one to see how terrible his logic is, you deserve two thumbs

You must be registered for see images

 

[Midday]

preta path is activated at the speed of thought. in the anime has shown that nagato or more specifically kabuto saw itachis susano coming towards him before it sliced nagatos arm off. that means that nagato had time to physically react so erecting preta paths barrier wouldve been easy.

absolutely laughable.
kabuto whos knows the workings of the 6 paths abilities used shinra tensei instead of preta path to rid of amaterasu. we have seen amaterasu and susanos effect on a conscious rinnegan user(kabuto who controlled nagato). whether nagato had preta path up and it failed against these techs are irrelevant as there was nothing stopping him from using preta path.

this was debunked by the manga. there isnt a discussion to be had.

Not going to bother since you're just repeating the same flawed reasoning and refuse to concede when wrong.

Amaterasu = high level katon. Katons can be absorbed, amaterasu can be absorbed.

Susanoo = mass of chakra which can be absorbed, I don't even know why you're trying to debate otherwise.

Plenty of evidence pointing in petra paths favour. I'm sticking with petra path.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Retsu]

Wow, this thread turned out great in my absence =D

@Midday: Im so glad im not the only one to see how terrible his logic is, you deserve two thumbs

You must be registered for see images

I agree, bad logic is bad

 

[TheSages456]

Not going to bother since you're just repeating the same flawed reasoning and refuse to concede when wrong.

Amaterasu = high level katon. Katons can be absorbed, amaterasu can be absorbed.

Susanoo = mass of chakra which can be absorbed, I don't even know why you're trying to debate otherwise.

Plenty of evidence pointing in petra paths favour. I'm sticking with petra path.

You must be registered for see images

we already saw the canon encounter between nagato and ms dojutsu so i do indeed accept your concession since you did nothing but use logical fallacies.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Draphsin]

preta path is activated at the speed of thought. in the anime has shown that nagato or more specifically kabuto saw itachis susano coming towards him before it sliced nagatos arm off. that means that nagato had time to physically react so erecting preta paths barrier wouldve been easy.

Non canon compared to manga, nice try

absolutely laughable.

My thoughts exactly XD

kabuto whos knows the workings of the 6 paths abilities used shinra tensei instead of preta path to rid of amaterasu. we have seen amaterasu and susanos effect on a conscious rinnegan user(kabuto who controlled nagato). whether nagato had preta path up and it failed against these techs are irrelevant as there was nothing stopping him from using preta path.

Kabuto wasnt aware of Nagato, manga fact.

preta would take longer to be rid of ama than shinra tensei, fact.

this was debunked by the manga. there isnt a discussion to be had.

No this was apparently debunked by you, & your awful reasoning .

 

[Midday]

we already saw the canon encounter between nagato and ms dojutsu so i do indeed accept your concession since you did nothing but use logical fallacies.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

This gif sums up your argument.

 

[TheSages456]

to the nagato fanboys in this thread:

if nagato could absorb ms dojutsu then he wouldnt have gotten fodderized by them in the manga.

nagato has used preta path to absorb any ninjutsu that can be absorbed 100% of the time. you are the ones that have the burden of evidence and need to prove why nagato would suddenly do a 90 degree turn from his in character actions and not use it in the face of ninjutsu.

 

[TheSages456]

You must be registered for see images

This gif sums up your argument.

You must be registered for see images

This gif sums up your argument.

 

[Retsu]

to the nagato fanboys in this thread:

if nagato could absorb ms dojutsu then he wouldnt have gotten fodderized by them in the manga.

nagato has used preta path to absorb any ninjutsu that can be absorbed 100% of the time. you are the ones that have the burden of evidence and need to prove why nagato would suddenly do a 90 degree turn from his in character actions and not use it in the face of ninjutsu.

Nagato died for the story to progress, it's not hard to figure that out.

 

[TheSages456]

Nagato died for the story to progress, it's not hard to figure that out.

his death obviously had to be believable so he died to powers that were stronger than his own. that is the combined force of itachi, naruto and bee.

 

[Midday]

You must be registered for see images

This gif sums up your argument.

That's nice but i'll borrow your words, "what you are saying is a logical fallacy. you tried to disprove the manga with logically unsound reasoning."

Nagato fanboy's.

Looks like you've also stooped to the lowest level of debating on the debate pyramid.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images