Proof that possibily can't be countered: Preta Path failed to absorb Ninjutsu

[Retsu]

his death obviously had to be believable so he died to powers that were stronger than his own. that is the combined force of itachi, naruto and bee.

no denying that, but it's obvious kishi handicapped him to make it easier than normal, he was too strong for the story.

 

[Draphsin]

to the nagato fanboys in this thread:

if nagato could absorb ms dojutsu then he wouldnt have gotten fodderized by them in the manga.

nagato has used preta path to absorb any ninjutsu that can be absorbed 100% of the time. you are the ones that have the burden of evidence and need to prove why nagato would suddenly do a 90 degree turn from his in character actions and not use it in the face of ninjutsu.

Its been proven why ama/susanoo werent absorbed multiple times throughout this thread, but deny it & make excuses if you must XD.

 

[TheSages456]

That's nice but i'll borrow your words, "what you are saying is a logical fallacy. you tried to disprove the manga with logically unsound reasoning."



Looks like you've also stooped to the lowest level of debating on the debate pyramid.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

wait, so you and your selective reading somehow missed the bottom portion of the post? are you actually saying that you couldnt counter so you responded with fluff?

it looks you stooped to the bottom of the debate pyramid:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[Midday]

wait, so you and your selective reading somehow missed the bottom portion of the post? are you actually saying that you couldnt counter so you responded with fluff?

it looks you stooped to the bottom of the debate pyramid:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I've read your posts. We've had debates before and I know it's pointless to continue with you since you wont admit being wrong when wrong, we'll both end up wasting more time.

It's more of the same. If Nagato could have done something he would have done it. My response is not doing something =/= not being able to do something, Kabuto chose what he felt was best.

Also my posts do not match what's at the bottom of that pyramid.

 

[TheSages456]

Its been proven why ama/susanoo werent absorbed multiple times throughout this thread, but deny it & make excuses if you must XD.

you say its proven because that simply what you want to believe. anyone with a working brain sees that if:
a) nagato, a preta path user responds to ninjutsu with preta path 100% of the time.
b) nagato, a preta path user is effectively damaged by susano and amaterasu.
conclusion: preta path cant absorb susano and amaterasu. its a simple concept. your meaningless excuses arent valid.

 

[Fanta]

wait, so you and your selective reading somehow missed the bottom portion of the post? are you actually saying that you couldnt counter so you responded with fluff?

it looks you stooped to the bottom of the debate pyramid:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Please just stop...

You're saying that because Kabuto decided to use Shinra Tensei instead of Preta path that means he couldn't of used Preta path??

Lol

 

[Kira was Righteous]

you say its proven because that simply what you want to believe. anyone with a working brain sees that if:
a) nagato, a preta path user responds to ninjutsu with preta path 100% of the time.
b) nagato, a preta path user is effectively damaged by susano and amaterasu.
conclusion: preta path cant absorb susano and amaterasu. its a simple concept. your meaningless excuses arent valid.

is Amateseru ninjutsu? Yes or No

Nagato summons gedo mazo to kill hashiramas summon and uses celestial tera blast to kill hashirama.

Flawless victory.

 

[TheSages456]

I've read your posts. We've had debates before and I know it's pointless to continue with you since you wont admit being wrong when wrong, we'll both end up wasting more time.

It's more of the same. If Nagato could have done something he would have done it. My response is not doing something =/= not being able to do something, Kabuto chose what he felt was best.

Also my posts do not match what's at the bottom of that pyramid.

your post is the 2nd to last on the debate pyramid.
the substance in the manga pages i presented werent countered. your 'argument' isnt a scenario that was ever implied in the manga so what you presented was worthless. going against IC reactions from the manga doesnt help your case.

 

[TheSages456]

is Amateseru ninjutsu? Yes or No

was nagato hit by amaterasu? yes or no.

 

[Midday]

your post is the 2nd to last on the debate pyramid.
the substance in the manga pages i presented werent countered. your 'argument' isnt a scenario that was ever implied in the manga so what you presented was worthless. going against IC reactions from the manga doesnt help your case.

It's been countered before it's pointless repeating. Plenty evidence supporting for petra path working, very weak evidence supporting against.

What is "IC"?

 

[Kira was Righteous]

your post is the 2nd to last on the debate pyramid.
the substance in the manga pages i presented werent countered. your 'argument' isnt a scenario that was ever implied in the manga so what you presented was worthless. going against IC reactions from the manga doesnt help your case.

are you arguing amateseru isn't ninjutsu?

 

[Draphsin]

you say its proven because that simply what you want to believe. anyone with a working brain sees that if:

Lol so youre saying that everybody on this thread doesnt have a working brain? Seems like a pretty big coincidence, or the more likely alternative would involve a certain somebody lacking a working brain instead .

a) nagato, a preta path user responds to ninjutsu with preta path 100% of the time.

Nagato, a six path user responds to situations as he sees fit with whatever path he sees fit. When & how he uses preta is not up for us to decide.

Shinra tensei was a better alternative than preta for ama, so kabuto used it, its simple logic.

b) nagato, a preta path user is effectively damaged by susano and amaterasu.

Because kabuto was in full control of nagato, who was focused on bee & naruto, this is a manga fact my friend XD

\conclusion: preta path cant absorb susano and amaterasu. its a simple concept. your meaningless excuses arent valid.

Okay & I respect your opinion, but its nothing more than that, opinion.

& my "excuses" prove you wrong at every turn, please leave

 

[Kira was Righteous]

was nagato hit by amaterasu? yes or no.

Yes under kabutos control unless you can prove it was Nagato fighting them( Auto counts as edo control) .

is Amateseru a ninjutsu Yes or No answer please i answered yours

 

[TheSages456]

It's been countered before it's pointless repeating. Plenty evidence supporting for petra path working, very weak evidence supporting against.

What is "IC"?

so the actual manga encounter between nagato and amaterasu is "weak evidence" but your speculation is the golden source of truth? LOL classic.
IC=in character

are you arguing amateseru isn't ninjutsu?

are you arguing that amaterasu cant affect nagato despite the manga disagreeing?

 

[Blunt]

I agree with this. Nagato wanted naruto to move, and he warned him about amaterasu, before Itachi blasted him with it. Were he anticipating the attack I'm sure he would have absorbed it.

I believe he felt the pressure and assumed it was Amaterasu, it was actually KA I believe, I'll look back later.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Midday]

so the actual manga encounter between nagato and amaterasu is "weak evidence" but your speculation is the golden source of truth? LOL classic.
IC=in character


are you arguing that amaterasu cant affect nagato despite the manga disagreeing?

When amaterasu hit's the petra path barrier that is strong evidence. When it hits him who is not in control of his body and not using the barrier, that is poor evidence. Also opting for one technique over the other does not mean the other technique can't work, Kabuto chose what is best.

Would someone with massive chakra reserves and unlimited chakra benefit much from absorbing amaterasu? Or would it be best to remove it asap and get on with the fight? I'm guessing that's Kabuto's reasoning.

Also stop hiding behind the manga, it's not disagreeing at all. The various of examples of petra path absorbing a wide range of ninjutsu and the databook vs that one scenario where he had more than 1 option.

 

[Kira was Righteous]

so the actual manga encounter between nagato and amaterasu is "weak evidence" but your speculation is the golden source of truth? LOL classic.
IC=in character


are you arguing that amaterasu cant affect nagato despite the manga disagreeing?

No Nagato was burnt badly by it but it was kabuto controlling him are you saying preta path cannot absorb it if its activated?

 

[S A G E]

so the actual manga encounter between nagato and amaterasu is "weak evidence" but your speculation is the golden source of truth? LOL classic.
IC=in character


are you arguing that amaterasu cant affect nagato despite the manga disagreeing?

I swear that this guy must be the alt account of the OP.
He made a thread with the noob account, then use his real account to respond every time.

 

[Dragon1]

to the nagato fanboys in this thread:

if nagato could absorb ms dojutsu then he wouldnt have gotten fodderized by them in the manga.

It seems to me that you're trolling, am I correct? Otherwise... well...

 

[TheSages456]

When amaterasu hit's the petra path barrier that is strong evidence. When it hits him who is not in control of his body and not using the barrier, that is poor evidence. Also opting for one technique over the other does not mean the other technique can't work, Kabuto chose what is best.

there was nothing stopping nagato from using preta path. nagato uses preta path when in the face of ninjutsu attacks 100% of the time. you need to prove why nagato or kabuto would suddenly change their approaches with absolutely no evidence instead of going with the simplest conclusion which is nagato not being able to absorb amaterasu.

Would someone with massive chakra reserves and unlimited chakra benefit much from absorbing amaterasu? Or would it be best to remove it asap and get on with the fight? I'm guessing that's Kabuto's reasoning.

then he shouldnt have absorbed narutos rasengan or v2 bees cloak going by your logic. you "guessing" means that all you have is an opinion which holds no value.

Also stop hiding behind the manga, it's not disagreeing at all. The various of examples of petra path absorbing a wide range of ninjutsu and the databook vs that one scenario where he had more than 1 option.

the manga is the ultimate source of truth. you cant "hide behind the manga".
when you actually show panels of nagato opting to use shinra tensei against ninjutsu that can be absorbed instead of preta path then your argument may hold some validity.