- Joined
- Dec 3, 2012
- Messages
- 39,759
- Reaction score
- 7,032
I have disagreements on the postulates of your theory:
- Tobirama's opinions are hogwash at best. I wouldn't consider the segregation or subjugation as something which he reverted to as the best course of action for the Uchiha. Both clans had shady pasts because of - both of us agreed in another thread - their prior status as mercenary or bounty hunter factions that continuously shed blood as long as someone ponied up the doe. This doesn't put any clan over the other in terms of 'moralities'. Let's not even go there.
His 'mental instability' justifications are border-line hilarious as all Uchihas were well- respected and immensely loved by the entire village, despite the fact that there were about 57 Sharingans - given Tobi and Danzo's stocks - at the time of the coup and yet, no one fell into the 'hate' rationalization he subjectively created. I wouldn't use any of his nutty rants as something substantial for the theory.
- The reason why Tobi eliminated the clan doesn't have anything to do with Madara. Given their recent exchanges, it's kind of Obvious the man never wanted to revive him. He was already planning to align Sasuke with his cause when Nagato was still around. Which means that he didn't come up with a plan B after Nagato betrayed them with his Tensai. He planned to sync Sasuke with the Mazo all along. Why didn't he revive Madara before sending Nagato off? Obito foresaw a lot of kinks in his plans, and he knew there might be set backs. So everything he accomplished was to meet his own ends, not Madara's.
- The reason why Obito helped slaughter the uchiha clan was because of eternal Tsukkuyomi itself. The genjutsu is an Uchiha clan genjutsu which would be most certainly cast with the said MS technique reflected at the moon, but it would attain the eternal status through Juubi's chakra. Now this process is hypothetical of me, but it makes sense as Obito planned for Sasuke to be synced with the Mazo. So possibily, an EMS user is required.
Regardless, being an uchiha jutsu makes it susceptible for others - Uchiha clan - with a Sharingan to break free of the genjutsu. Remember only 'Itachi's' Tsukuyomi is special as he himself said that 'his MS genjugsu is special and can only be broken by Sasuke and no one else', which means that the rest of Moon Genjutsus are weak before a fellow clan member. Obito doesn't want anyone to break free of the jutsu and jeopardize his plans. Hence the reason he eliminated the clan.
- I hardly doubt Danzo did anything to 'save' Konoha. If I am to flip your theory, it would make a lot of sense; he aided Obito - not Madara - to wipe out the Uchiha as both of them needed the spare sharingans. Don't you find it odd that Danzo only has a few compared to Obito who has them by the bucket, and he has never posed a question that where are the missing Sharingans? He graved robbed the clan and I highly doubt he would have been content with a few of them at his disposal. Both of them probably made a deal to share them amongst one another.
He already knew he had KA and would eliminate Madara - he obviously didn't know this guy wasn't him - when they met again. Everyone was happy. Henceforth, Danzo did everything including his manipulation of Itachi because he believed in Senju hold over the government and desired to permanently eradicate the clan to climb up from roots onto the leaf seat; something he coveted all his life.
Great theory though.
1. I think it is a categorical error to assume that Tobirama was lying because the Senjus were not morally superior to the Uchihas (at least accdg. to your view) the veracity of his statements are proven by the fact that the curse of hatred is real and backed up by bioneurological evidence of its' origins. He was not giving opinions about the Uchihas, he was stating facts.
2. As I have posted in my OP, the reason for the elimination of the Uchihas are two-fold, revenge and elimination of any potential threats for the Eye of the Moon Plan, both of which is achieved by getting them out of the way, regardless of Madara's intention for revenge, Tobi must follow if he wants the Eye of the Moon Plan to be successful, since I have also stated in my OP that the Uchihas Sharingans coud pose a treat to their plans, regardless of Tobi's agreement on Madara's revenge he must push through in eliminating the Uchihas. At what point did Tobi deviated from the original plan and decided not to revive Madara is a moot point for reasons not yet explained, he could have intended to revive him but discovered Madara's hand in Rin's death which would have made him not want to revive him, also, the linking on the Mazo is also a moot point. What did Tobi meant in linking Sasuke with the statue? I think it's a leap in logic to say that Tobi intended to use Sasuke as a replacement for Madara because, as rollin pointed out, what Tobi meant could have simply been to link Sasuke to the statue for the extraction process of the remaining Bijuus much like what the other Akatsuki did when they extracted the previous Bijuus.
3. I have already answered that in #1 it was a two-fold motive in Madara's part, Tobi needed only one but either way both were achieved by the slaughtering of the clan (revenge and elim. Of potential threat)
4. Danzo and Tobi shared the loot of the Sharingans, but it's also logical to assume that he made a deal that Tobi (who was acting in accordance to Madara's plans) would leave Konoha alone if he aided in the massacre, mirroring Itachi who made a deal with Tobi to leave Konoha alone in exchange for his aide in eliminating the Uchiha Clan.
Last edited: