Theory: The Bitter Truth About The Uchiha Massacre and the Kyuubi Attack on Konoha

SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
39,759
Reaction score
7,032

“The pure and simple truth is rarely pure and never simple.” ― Oscar Wilde



I have come to the realization about the bitter truth of the Nine-Tails attack on Konoha, it was not aimed to destroy it, it was aimed to protect it and for a reason that is even more foul: Frame-Up

Have you ever wondered what was the real reason Tobi set the Kyuubi lose on Konoha and only retreat afterwards? yes Minato did injure him but: Why didn't Tobi return to Konoha after Minato died if his true intention was to destroy it?

Because Konoha's destruction was not his or Madara's intention: it was to frame-up the Uchihas

But.. at the same time... it was done to protect Konoha... by Danzo

You must be registered for see images



This is what I think what happened:

Take a look at this, from here we can infer that there was a former alliance between Danzo and Tobi/Obito:

You must be registered for see images



But what would Danzo gain by allying himself with Tobi, and to an extent: Madara Uchiha?

The Answer: The Safety and Protection of Konoha

But how is that so? what type of protection could Tobi/Madara offer Konoha, and from whom?

The Answer:

You must be registered for see images



The Protection of Konoha through the elimination of its' cursed clan: The Uchihas


As the recent chapters have shown: Tobirama knew the the curse of the Uchihas: The Curse of Hatred he knew that the Uchihas were pathologically dangerous, so he had them appointed to a position that would allow them to focus their power and passion, not for the detriment of Konoha, but for the benefit of it: The Konoha Military Police Force.

Tobirama was more than anything a Utilitarian, he knew the intrinsic inclination of the Uchihas towards hatred, but he wanted to use that zeal for the betterment and safety of Konoha, that's why he gave them a role that best suited them: Law Enforcers.

Danzo on the other hand, was an extremist he saw no reason for the Uchiha's continued existence in the village, he saw them as walking time bombs, ready to explode at any moment, their hatred overwhelming their sensibilities, which ultimately would lead to the destruction of the village they swore to protect.

He wanted to eliminate them, to blot out their existence from Konoha's surface, but how will he do it? Hiruzen Sarutobi, the third Hokage, was a pacifist, he wanted to maintain good relations with the Uchihas, despite the tension between the clan and the Village, the majority of the Shinobis of the Leaf were loyal to the Hokage, he only had the small faction of Root/The Foundation to support him, he could not raise arms and wipe out the Uchihas with such meager means, he had to find something, someone to help him get rid of them.

But who could Danzo possibly ally with that would have enough power and means to machinate the fall of the Uchihas and lead to their utter annihilation?

The Answer: Madara Uchiha

Yes, Danzo and Madara most probably knew each other, had contacted each other to scheme on the Uchiha Clan's fall from grace. But a question arises again: Why would Madara Uchiha want to cause his own clan's downfall?

The Answer: Revenge

You must be registered for see images



So great was Madara's love for Izuna (as stated by Hashirama) that the Uchiha Clan's alliance with the Senjus and the foundation of the Leaf Village was an absolute insult to Izuna's memory and sacrifice, how his brother gave his eyes and the entirety of his being for the greater glory of the Uchiha Clan only for that clan to trample and spit on that sacrifice by signing a treaty of peace with their bitterest rival: The Senjus, forming an alliance with them to establish the first Shinobi Village: Konoha.

[Madara, as the leader of the Uchihas, was merely forced from pressure by his clan to sign a treaty of peace with the Senjus, even though he did not want to, he had to abide with his clan's wishes and do it]

You must be registered for see images


How much loathing must Madara have felt deep inside when he shook the hand of Hashirama Senju, his most bitter rival, the leader of the enemy Senju Clan, the clan who made Izuna sacrifice so much in order to defeat them, and for what? for his own clan to make peace with a loathed enemy?! what insult Madara must've felt!

We all know the story, of how Madara could not stomach the Senju's dominance and wanted to take the mantle of power of Konoha for the Uchiha Clan alone, perhaps, in Madara's mind, in order to make Izuna's sacrifice worth something,but the Uchihas did what?! they added insult to injury! not only did they made a mockery of Izuna by allying with the Senjus, but they have deserted Madara in his planned revolt, in their desertion of Madara they have killed Izuna more than once, but twice! it was something Madara cannot forgive, his curse of hatred was too great, he will take revenge on the clan that trampled on his beloved brother Izuna's memory no matter what, he waited in the shadows, to await for the time of retribution...


Danzo wanted the Uchihas eliminated, Madara wanted revenge against them, it was a perfect alliance: An alliance born from hatred.

But Danzo had limited power to take the Uchihas out, he neither has the support of the Hokages or the Shinobis of the Leaf, Madara was old and frail, he does not have the strength to challenge the Uchihas in open combat, not in his decrepit state inside the cave [where he spent decades to recuperate and awaken the Rinnegan]

Danzo wanted the Uchihas out, Madara wanted them out, but besides the Uchiha's elimination, what else could Danzo gain from allying himself with Madara?

The Answer: Madara leaving the village alone.

Madara will help Danzo wipe out the Uchihas, Danzo will help Madara frame-up the Uchihas, with Danzo's cooperation, Madara promises that he, his protege' and his agents will leave Konoha alone. [or so at least that's what Madara promised to Danzo in exchange for his help]

Danzo allying with Madara benefits:

1. He gets to frame-up the Uchihas and eliminate them from Konoha

2. He made Madara promised to leave Konoha alone. like how Itachi asked him to leave Konoha alone in exchange for wiping out the Uchiha Clan

It was two birds in one stone for Danzo

Madara knew that he was old and barely alive, he needed someone to continue his plans, someone to bring he and Danzo's meticulous scheme into action, he needed someone young, an agent of his will:

You must be registered for see images

Obito Uchiha

Acquiring someone to continue his legacy, Madara let himself die, it was now up to Obito, who had taken the guise of his master, to collaborate with Danzo and execute their nefarious scheme. But what was the perfect opportunity to take the Uchihas down?

The Answer:


You must be registered for see images

Kushina Uzumaki: The Jinchuuriki of the Nine-Tailed Fox


Danzo knows, Tobi knows, and Konoha knows that the Uchiha's Sharingan has the power to control Kurama
if they somehow took the Kyuubi from the Jinchuuriki and let it lose in Konoha, who do you think will the blame lay on?

The Answer: The Uchihas would've been the primary suspect if the Kyuubi attacked Konoha.

So when will Danzo and Tobi seize Kurama from Kushina? when was the perfect opportunity?

The Answer: The birth of Naruto

Since the seal of Kurama is weakened when the Jinchuuriki gives birth, then it served as the perfect opportunity to take the Kyuubi from its' host and unleash it to wreck havoc on Konoha (not to destroy Konoha, but to cause havoc in order to frame-up the Uchihas)


As we know Tobi took the Kyuubi from Kushina, and the Kyuubi went on a rampage, Minato stopped the Kyuubi from rampaging, he and Kushina died in the process of saving Naruto and sealing the Kyuubi inside their newborn son.

And who gets the blame for the Nine-Tails attack? The Uchihas

Something to ponder about:
Why didn't Tobi/Obito tried to destroy Konoha again after Minato died?

It's because Tobi didn't intend to destroy Konoha, he and Danzo just wanted to frame up the Uchihas for the incident. It was all set-up

Since Tobi and Danzo knew about the special pathological disposition of the Uchihas (curse of hatred) they had expertly calculated that the accusations would fall on the Uchihas, the Uchihas being a sensitive clan (as Tobirama stated) reacted in anger and planned to stage an uprising: The Uchiha Uprising

Now the Uchihas are clearly the perceived enemy of Konoha, a modicum of doubt might have been given to the Uchihas if they were actually behind the Nine-Tails attack or not, but, it is certain that they were planning an uprising.
The Third Hokages hands are tied, he can do nothing anymore, the Uchihas and Hiruzen fell for Danzo and Tobi's trap, they have been played as pawns in their little game of chess, the stage is all set:


Because peace talks is no longer a viable option, the Third Hokage, the Village Elders and Danzo (In his secret delight :D) had Itachi eliminate the Uchihas.


You must be registered for see images


The Uchihas were wiped out:

You must be registered for see images



Danzo had the Uchihas eliminated, made Madara promise to leave Konoha alone. like how Itachi asked Madara/Tobi to leave Konoha alone in exchange for massacring the Uchihas.

and

Madara finally got his revenge for Izuna. [And eliminated a potential threat to the Eye of the Moon Plan]



It was an alliance of hatred, an alliance of mutual beneficence



 
Last edited:

Ryuujinn

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jan 18, 2013
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
125
awesome cosplay pic is it u ?
O.T: still reading
 

Kages

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Nov 23, 2012
Messages
16,549
Reaction score
877
Omg nice theory!! :)
 

Ryuujinn

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Jan 18, 2013
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
125
I wouldnt be suprised if it became true danzo is badguy enough to do things like that but i feel really sad cuz kyuubi used as their toys like in hashi n madara's luv fight
 
Last edited:

Snape Uchiha

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Nov 14, 2012
Messages
4,175
Reaction score
767
Amazing theory. I wonder though why Obito wanted to destroy the Uchiha also. My guess is he did it because Madara told him and he really didn't care about them anymore.
 

MMaElite

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
1,508
Reaction score
76
I agree with all of it besides the protection part. Mardara would still hate the village. Madara is the type to backtrack on his words and betray you.
 

sasuke007

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
187
Reaction score
10
i agree with all accept...kakashi only knew minato was having a baby
and nothing else, not when or where so you lost me with kakashi's part
 

JIRAIYA perv

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Aug 4, 2012
Messages
5,160
Reaction score
454
this is an awesome theory (like the music too lol), it makes sense looking at the events that happened and knowing of each character's true intentions. + rep :D great job bro
 

Reynfall

Banned
Regular
Joined
Nov 29, 2012
Messages
677
Reaction score
65
It's a good theory but Madara wanted to fulfill the Moon's Eye Plan through Obito, he didn't want to wipe out the Uchihas through Obito.

If the latter was his goal, he might as well have just killed Obito right there.
 

shogun973

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Nov 19, 2011
Messages
1,586
Reaction score
49
no he was surprised when tobi said he was madara... he never allied himself with madara he thought itachi did the job(which he could have)
 

gypsy4343435

Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
14
Reaction score
2
Nice to see sensible posts like this once in a while,was a good read with no noticeable discrepancies :)
 

SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
39,759
Reaction score
7,032
It's a good theory but Madara wanted to fulfill the Moon's Eye Plan through Obito, he didn't want to wipe out the Uchihas through Obito.

If the latter was his goal, he might as well have just killed Obito right there.

Ah But that's the thing, it's two birds with one stone, he wipes out the Uchihas who could possibly oppose his Eye of the Moon Plan with their Sharingans, and he gets revenge at the same time. Obito was the exception because he needed an Uchiha to continue his legacy
 
Last edited:

SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
39,759
Reaction score
7,032
i agree with all accept...kakashi only knew minato was having a baby
and nothing else, not when or where so you lost me with kakashi's part

Kakashi knew that Minato was having a baby, but Tobi knew it was the time of the weakening of the Seal. And Danzo definitely knew Kushina was the Fourth Hokage's wife.
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
great read, great theory. Fine work again Derp. Keep it up.
 

Itachi Rane

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Dec 19, 2012
Messages
1,321
Reaction score
101
so tobi did it to protect konoha and to take revenge in behalf of madara? Then why is he trying to destroy everything now??? Btw, awesome theory dude!!
 
Top