you shouldn't have split the post

.... i've clearly mentioned Naruto had help from bee and kakashi
this is my exact line "Yes naruto had kakashi's training and bee's help but Naruto being who he is now also bcos of Jman's Ideology"
again i mentioned Hizuren bcos he failed to stop Orochimaru from being evil
@bold ... The student's talent before they met the teacher and the time it took the teacher to get them from how they were to where they are.
this is what i disagree on.... you are judging the sensei
1.on the time it took to teach a student
2.the talent b4 training
3.talent after training
^^^^ correct me if i'm wrong in this
while i judge a sensei on
1.how he influenced the student's life
2.the students overall attitude toward the world
based on my criteria which is also more compatible with this thread's OP
jiraiya successfully influenced a positive attitude on the life of Naruto,Minato on the first try
when konan,nagato (yahiko was already dead) turned bad jiraiya tried to stop them but died then Naruto used Jiraiya's ideology to change nagato and Konan into good side
so indirectly Jiraiya influenced all his 5 students to be in a positive attitude in life and be good guys
if you take Hiruzen for eg Hiruzen influnced positive thoughts into Jiraiya and Tsunade but failed in Orochimaru's(though its not Hiruzen's fault)
But Hiruzen had an second chance to convince Orochimaru when he was caught in his hideout during the flash back but Hiruzen didn't try to stop him
Then Hiruzen had a third chance during chunin exam fight again failed to convince oro and had to use RDS to seal him and oro's hands
and if you take Madara
he never intended to give obito positive attitudes and make obito a good guy .... indirectly he was using Obito to carry out his plans so madara helped obito get stronget in the shortest amount of time
i cannot explain this any better ...
and yes there is no correct answer we have different views