ok some very good points.. i get what your saying,
but on the kakashi gaiden: wasn't that to show how kakashi got his sharingan???...
and i might have been to hasty with dismissing the theory, i give you that, but there are so many other things that just don't ad up.
yes it's true you can get a haircut...but to make it grow first and then later on cut it again just seems like convenient theorizing to me.
on the one eye thing, i find it kinda easy to say tobi only has one eye just cuz we've never seen it...like i said couldn't it be that he is concealing one, cuz otherwise it would use op to much chackra, or not to let everbody in akatsuki know he is an uchiha????
and to really put it into words...why would an all powerfull shinobi, who has managed to live for DECADES after he fought shodaime, suddenly take over the half crushed..if not fully crushed body of an 12 year old?????...if he really needed another body he would have taken one long time b4 obito died and even if he did lose an eye against shodaime..
why take a body thats also missing an eye instead of taking one that has both, there were still plenty uchiha alive back then so obito would seem, like the last choice if ya ask me??? and if he didnt lose an eye then it would make even less sence to take obito's body....
Madara:HAHAHA, I still have 2 good working sharingan let me switch body's with an 12 year old so i can go on having one eye?????you get what i'm trying to say here???
and yes you can kinda make obito out of tobi but i really think kishi is playin with our heads on this one, your points are good, but i'm still gonna wright them of as kishi playing with our heads.
like i said there are to many things that dont ad up, even though the name and the mask with one eye hole leaves allot of things open for debate, that's just 2 points everybody basing their theory on..
against a good few more that i just put up there.
so like miggy said in his post
I HOPE THIS WILL END ALL THE TOBI IS OBITO TALK!!!!!
thank you for listening