Minato, Jman, Kakashi and the Third Hokage

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
Enforce Moon's eye plan on everyone, despite losing any form of freedom for themselves.
Morally wrong and unfair.

How will a person learn to understand if they can't accept?
Strive and survive, you become wiser through that.
You don't " live " when someone gives you everything on a silver platter (Moon's eye plan), you're just surviving but not moving forward.
Just my opinion...
must of them dont accept it, which causes built up anger. Naruto did too, but he was able to face it by fighting against it at the waterfall.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
They all kind of got out played by Madara in terms of the influence they had on their students. Except Hiruzen, though I bet Orochimaru flashback to being manipulated by Madara is in coming.
the fact that someone who barely knew them could easily influence them and not their teachers who have been there from the start says a lot.
 

Niwdog

Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
453
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
Good thread, interesting points. Obito is still a little bitch though. Your girl died? Go play depressing music and get 50 cats.
I know right?

They're all little bitches. I understand them being angry at the people responsible for the deaths of their loved ones, but WHY their mentors, who tried so hard to help them and guide them? It makes no sense! Not even a shred of gratitude or mercy. Ungrateful little pricks. Fine, get your revenge, but surely, you should remember the man who helped you learn the ninjutsu you are using to achieve your revenge and at least give him a merciful defeat/death if he is an obstacle/in the way of your revenge. Seriously, the intense hate Orochimaru, Nagato, Tobi and Sasuke have for their teachers actually makes no sense and doesn't really follow in terms of character and logic. Like, WTAF. Well, Nagato is a bit of an exception.
 

Niwdog

Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
453
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
It would be TOOOO wierd, I repeat TOOOOO WIERD! if Naruto managed to change Orochimaru...

Kakashi, imo, has been the most effective pawn sensei in Madara's plan. Kakashi has always been very distant with the group, whereas Hiruzen actively gives advice, Jiraiya gave very intensive focused training and mentoring but it was for too short a time, and with Minato, whereas he would and should be the worst (I mean, he practically abandoned his group to fend for themselves during missions and the war, which led to Obito's death in the first place), Minato's influence and significance in his team didn't appear as wide-scoping as Kakashi's due to how much detailed focus we've seen on Team 7. Kakashi had a lot of time to do a lot with both Naruto and Sasuke, but rather spent most of his time training Sasuke and giving him the 1-off advice about his revenge, which wasn't very stressed or deep-reaching like Hiruzen's sort of advice was. When he started to really focus on the Sasuke issue, it was too late, cos the Sound 4 came and took him away to Orochimaru. Later in Shippuden though, Kakashi seemed to get better because he became much more of involved with Naruto, in terms of being a mentor. Sakura has had the least personal/emotional mentoring, which probably explains why she's so all over the place right now lol.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
It would be TOOOO wierd, I repeat TOOOOO WIERD! if Naruto managed to change Orochimaru...

Kakashi, imo, has been the most effective pawn sensei in Madara's plan. Kakashi has always been very distant with the group, whereas Hiruzen actively gives advice, Jiraiya gave very intensive focused training and mentoring but it was for too short a time, and with Minato, whereas he would and should be the worst (I mean, he practically abandoned his group to fend for themselves during missions and the war, which led to Obito's death in the first place), Minato's influence and significance in his team didn't appear as wide-scoping as Kakashi's due to how much detailed focus we've seen on Team 7. Kakashi had a lot of time to do a lot with both Naruto and Sasuke, but rather spent most of his time training Sasuke and giving him the 1-off advice about his revenge, which wasn't very stressed or deep-reaching like Hiruzen's sort of advice was. When he started to really focus on the Sasuke issue, it was too late, cos the Sound 4 came and took him away to Orochimaru. Later in Shippuden though, Kakashi seemed to get better because he became much more of involved with Naruto, in terms of being a mentor. Sakura has had the least personal/emotional mentoring, which probably explains why she's so all over the place right now lol.
good post, you made very good points and I agree!! They all differed on how they trained their students and intereacted differently, it's just weird how all have been praised, yet their closest students failed to connect with them
 

Shisui Namikaze

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
3,451
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
I agree and out of all the reasons to turn to the dark side I say obitos is the best. I mean look at what happened to him all in within what a year or 2? He loses half his body. He gives his sharingan to his rival then witness his rival and friend kill the girl he was in love with. That can be hard for a 13 year old boy or however old he was.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
I agree and out of all the reasons to turn to the dark side I say obitos is the best. I mean look at what happened to him all in within what a year or 2? He loses half his body. He gives his sharingan to his rival then witness his rival and friend kill the girl he was in love with. That can be hard for a 13 year old boy or however old he was.
never really looked at it like that, that would be me mad as hell too when you put it like that. lol

Also, i cant blame Sasuke for his hate
 
Last edited:

Shisui Namikaze

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
3,451
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
never really looked at it like that, that would be me mad as hell too when you put it like that. lol

Also, i cant blame Sasuke for his hate
Yeah but what I don't like about sasuke is that he just wants to kill. His reason to be mad is good but him killin danzo should have been enough. But now he wants to kill innocent people. While Tobi just wants a dream land with all good lol.
 

Niwdog

Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
453
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
Yeah but what I don't like about sasuke is that he just wants to kill. His reason to be mad is good but him killin danzo should have been enough. But now he wants to kill innocent people. While Tobi just wants a dream land with all good lol.
Me too. I have a long-lasting hope that Sasuke is/was trolling when he told Tobi "I want to get revenge and wipe out everyone in Konoha" because in that chapter I was just like "Please tell me you're joking, Sasuke. Please tell me you can't be that stupid to be SO easily used by Tobi after what he just said about everything Itachi did for YOU. Please!" Lol. Killing Danzo, the Elders, fine... but wipe out the entire village/country???

Oh, and also, I think Orochimaru, Nagato, Tobi and Sasuke should be contrasted and compared to Sasori, who suffered in a similar way to those four, but still managed to show some level of mercy to his grandmother who was his parent and mentor.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
Yeah but what I don't like about sasuke is that he just wants to kill. His reason to be mad is good but him killin danzo should have been enough. But now he wants to kill innocent people. While Tobi just wants a dream land with all good lol.
i use to think that too, but this made me think otherwise.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images


he hate is beyond just random killing
 

thegame

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 15, 2012
Messages
3,129
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
they failed from having an emotional bond with their students. thus if they had emotional bond with their teachers (as students usually do) things would have been different. Even if they were to turn evil, they would have at least shown some remorse towards those they loved. This didnt occur at all.
No if Nagato could show remorse for Jiraya, Naruto would had been caught, and the infinite tsukyomi had been shadowing the world. Besides Jiraya trains him for 3 years (7-10 years old I assume). He was just a kid - yet to experience the true world of shinobi. Jiraya had to let him experience this on his own, so that Nagato would come up with his own answer. The same goes for Naruto. He made them experience the same thing, and thus they ended up with different answers, but in the end united. Had he shown remorse for Jiraya that had not been real, and Jiraya had failed. Nagato came to his own solution and thus to do that he had to take Jirayas life.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
No if Nagato could show remorse for Jiraya, Naruto would had been caught, and the infinite tsukyomi had been shadowing the world. Besides Jiraya trains him for 3 years (7-10 years old I assume). He was just a kid - yet to experience the true world of shinobi. Jiraya had to let him experience this on his own, so that Nagato would come up with his own answer. The same goes for Naruto. He made them experience the same thing, and thus they ended up with different answers, but in the end united. Had he shown remorse for Jiraya that had not been real, and Jiraya had failed. Nagato came to his own solution and thus to do that he had to take Jirayas life.
he didnt come p with his own solutionm to went with exactly what was told to him. The same can be said for Konan, they have only had each other and one other perosn in their life and that was Jman, no matter how long that was. The story that Jman craved changed as things didnt go as planned, just like when Minato was once his the savior he concluded. This really has nothing to do with it in the end
 

Piratefish

Active member
Regular
Joined
Dec 10, 2011
Messages
1,140
Kin
0๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
While it's obvious that all are superior shinobi, that loved and admired their students, but something they each failed at was reaching all their students in return.

Third Hokage loved Orochimaru just as much as the village, more. He believed in he more than anytime and than couldn't do anything once he became aware of his ways, and let him flee knowing he will eventually take revenge. However, Orochimaru showed no remorse while fighting him, and to make things worse forced him to fight two men that he grow up admiring (1st n 2nd Hokage). Orochimaru seriously did any and every to hurt the third in return.

Minato may not have shown as much sensitivity for Obito, but it's obvious he cared for his students deeply. On the other hand, Obito not only was willing to kill him, but his wife and child.

Jman obviously has great love for Nagato, even declaring him as the savior of the ninja world. Yet, Nagato had no problem tearing him apart mentally and physically.

Kakashi favored sasuke and took him under his wing, basicially being a new big bro. Only for sasuke to spit him his face and attempt to kill with a simple arrow as if he was a bug.

now what made this students lose to the point that they had no care in the world for their teachers?? The lost of another?? Knowing that is the life of the shinobi!

With this I agree with Tobi's plan to make peace amongst everyone, where there will be no worry of a crazy student losing it and killing everyone in his way. #teamTobi #teamMadara for me.
Interesting comparisons and analysis of their respective relationships. Out of all of these, though, Jiraiya seems to be the one who is least to blame for his student's failings.

It didn't happen under his direct supervision, for one.
 

blazekev90

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
11,741
Kin
5๐Ÿ’ธ
Kumi
0๐Ÿ’ด
Trait Points
0โš”๏ธ
Interesting comparisons and analysis of their respective relationships. Out of all of these, though, Jiraiya seems to be the one who is least to blame for his student's failings.

It didn't happen under his direct supervision, for one.
thanks, i see where you're coming from. He didn't have a direct role, but he influenced Nagato's perspective of the ninja world which he took on
 
Top