Lesser of the two evils! I would kill 100 family members in real life!

[Better]

100 for 2000, i would do it also

where are these thousands of lives you guys keep talking about?

lol do you guys really think the uchiha clan, who was massacred by 2 people can cause this much damage?

 

[sG Taka]

The village was way more powerful, the coup d'etat would've failed miserably and probably children, poor olds, women and some men might of survived. You're sick, Itachi is a fail attempt of a Machiavelli type character.

Besides, he should have stood ground against his elders, love before duty, always.

 

[scrmz]

killing baby and poor olds poeple that have nothing to do in coup d'etat story?
go check yourself in rehab dude.

This.

 

[ShinobiX]

No you wouldn't, if the people in saw can't kill random people, you can't kill personal people, plus, I gather most are bigger and scarier than you are in your ninja costume. Your only hope is that they think you've gone insane and they laugh nervously. You couldn't massacre anyone. In fact, you would probably cry thinking about it xd

Don't underestimate me bro...

As Itachi Senpai said: "Don't judge people based on their appearance alone".

 

[Dupa]

Chill out people it's just a story. The only part that confuses me is that Itachi could have at least spared the kids and taken them under his wing or something, instead of going "hate me so you can kill me" on Sasuke. Look how that turned out. But again, this is a story. A story needs drama

 

[silmarill]

people who agreed on itachis actions simply dont understand what they are saying and discussion with them is pointless
they see itachi as a badass hero but they should see him as someone who commits (genocide) on his people

 

[ShinobiX]

The village was way more powerful, the coup d'etat would've failed miserably and probably children, poor olds, women and some men might of survived. You're sick, Itachi is a fail attempt of a Machiavelli type character.

Besides, he should have stood ground against his elders, love before duty, always.

He chose love and duty

I am not sick, I am noble and think about the greater good. Only one I couldn't kill is my younger brother, he is my Sasuke.

 

[Owarij]

where are these thousands of lives you guys keep talking about?

lol do you guys really think the uchiha clan, who was massacred by 2 people can cause this much damage?

The strongest clan in the village would at least kill off a few hundreds of people, But thats not the worst part, The other villages WOULD attack...because of the instability in konoha....

The THIRD kazekage going missing, Triggered the fourth great ninja war......


The strongest village having a internal war wouldn't ?

 

[NLee]

where are these thousands of lives you guys keep talking about?

lol do you guys really think the uchiha clan, who was massacred by 2 people can cause this much damage?

Yes, they could.

They never would have suspected Itachi, their prized gem and pride of the clan, to kill them. Itachi killed them quickly, quietly, and swiftly.

Had the entire clan gotten together and prepared for their assault on the village it would have been mayhem.

They'd weaken the village from the inside out just like the Sand shinobi did. How? A surprise attack.
If the Sand could cause so much destruction, then I think a clan comprised of natural geniuses could too.


After Konoha got weakened, the other villages would see that as the perfect opportunity to invade. The other villages would all want this boost in territorial power. At the same time they can't let any of the other villages succeed in overtaking Konoha because that would make them stronger than the rest. They'd all jump in and a war would begin.

Tobi explained this to Sasuke

 

[hawaiianmike]

Dude after reading this thread I can now say I have seen it all. U_U
I honestly don't know how to react to this so I'm just going to leave it at this.

We all know why Itachi did it, and don't hate him for it anymore. The hate left when we found out he was a good guy. At least mine did.

 

[Owarij]

And jesus christ people..... why do you think there was to be no survivors? Look what happened to sasuke....Now think what would happen if a entire clan eventually grew up from those kids, who would want revenge, yes...a bunch of sasukes

 

[ShinobiX]

people who agreed on itachis actions simply dont understand what they are saying and discussion with them is pointless
they see itachi as a badass hero but they should see him as who commits (genocide) on his people

IN THAT SCENARIO Genocide is justified and necessary.

 

[Gildarts Clive]

congratulations you just admitted you would kill your entire family yeah that's definitely something to be proud of

This U_U

 

[sG Taka]

He chose love and duty

I am not sick, I am noble and think about the greater good. Only one I couldn't kill is my younger brother, he is my Sasuke.

He loved his clan so much he killed them all? Yeah I'm pretty scared at your definition of love..

 

[silmarill]

And jesus christ people..... why do you think there was to be no survivors? Look what happened to sasuke....Now think what would happen if a entire clan eventually grew up from those kids, who would want revenge, yes...a bunch of sasukes

haha so its good to slaughter people bcs they can become potentially murderers ? lol dude u shud reread what u just said and think it over

 

[Better]

The strongest clan in the village would at least kill off a few hundreds of people, But thats not the worst part, The other villages WOULD attack...because of the instability in konoha....

The THIRD kazekage going missing, Triggered the fourth great ninja war......


The strongest village having a internal war wouldn't ?

Yes, they could.

They never would have suspected Itachi, their prized gem and pride of the clan, to kill them. Itachi killed them quickly, quietly, and swiftly.

Had the entire clan gotten together and prepared for their assault on the village it would have been mayhem.

They'd weaken the village from the inside out just like the Sand shinobi did. How? A surprise attack.
If the Sand could cause so much destruction, then I think a clan comprised of natural geniuses could too.


After Konoha got weakened other villages would see that as the perfect opportunity to invade. The other villages would all want this boost in territorial power. They'd all jump in and a war would begin.

Tobi explained this to Sasuke

okay lets say they do have their coup

you think lets say a group of 100 uchiha can handle the entire village every clan every ninja and itachi and shisui?

keep in mind shisui would still be alive, if this was the way it was going to go down

there wouldn't be a surprise attack because itachi is the mole, they'd wipe them out before they get a chance

it'd be an over night or maybe two night rebellion, and the next day it would be like nothing ever happened maybe like 50 dead

and if shisui got his hands on fugaku he'd just KA him and make him retreat

 

[Hipster Madara]

Lol I would totally kill 100+ ppl..

 

[sG Taka]

And jesus christ people..... why do you think there was to be no survivors? Look what happened to sasuke....Now think what would happen if a entire clan eventually grew up from those kids, who would want revenge, yes...a bunch of sasukes

I think the failure of the first coup d'etat would serve as a deterrent.

 

[ShinobiX]

He loved his clan so much he killed them all? Yeah I'm pretty scared at your definition of love..

He loved his village aswell.

 

[Dupa]

This thread has gone from Itachi "doing the right thing" to personal experiences and beliefs U_U It's just a story people. Chill out.