is Naruto manga still a great or good manga to you or not anymore?

[Joseph Gomes]

It started to get stale during the last arc with illogical asspulls and plot holes. Plus, the pairings have ruined it. It's just fanservice now.

Also retcons like indra + asura chakra = rinnegan and hagoromo sealing the juubi alone in the moon

 

[Ansatsuken]

Have u even read other manga's :|



Seinen is for elders
its Plot and story line blitz Shonen like Naruto neg diff :|

May you give me some good seinen to read.

 

[uchihamad]

It's good and better compared to some mangas. I will rate 7/10.

 

[Ansatsuken]

That's harsh rating you do know that Naruto is in 3rd spot in all time manga least .. By the way what anime is your ava??

I think manga ranking spot cant be a mirror or image to actual manga quality.

its more about long term fans than quality

What I seek here is about opinion on manga quality and its popularity right.

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

Have u even read other manga's :|



Seinen is for elders
its Plot and story line blitz Shonen like Naruto neg diff :|

Yeah i have downloaded all the chapters too the mangas below to my computer.

1)Assasination Classroom
2)Bakuman
3)Code Breaker
4)Deadman Wonderland
5)Death Note
6)Enigma
7)Fairy Tail
8)Full Metal Alchemist
9)Hamatora
10)Higurashi
11)History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi
12)Hunter X Hunter
13)Katekyo Hitman Reborn
14)Nisekio
15)No Game No Life
16)Onani Master Kurosawa
17)One Piece
18)Shaman King
19)Shaman King Flowers
20)Shingeki No Kyojin
21)Nanatsu No Taizai
22)To Love Ru
23)To Love Ru Darkness
24)Tonari No Seki Kun
25)World Trigger

I also have some Dragonball and Toriko chapters.Naruto is my favorite manga.

I think you are the only one here that think this manga is great with all BS it has.

But to each their own opinion

What BS are you be speaking of?

 

[Made in Heaven]

That's harsh rating you do know that Naruto is in 3rd spot in all time manga least .. By the way what anime is your ava??

OT: 8.0/10 for me .. I was really happy seeing Sasuke and Naruto reunion . 698 was MVP of the War Arc..

No it isn't, not in terms of sales anyways. And my avatar is not from an anime, it's from a game.

 

[Anduril]

It is a good manga to me.
It used to be great upto the 5 kage summit and a little after it.

 

[JStar King]

Also retcons like indra + asura chakra = rinnegan and hagoromo sealing the juubi alone in the moon

True. True.

You must be registered for see images

 

[1Told]

Dats Seinen u know :|

ok ok so Saint Seiya is great imo, it's a shonen right :mew:

 

[BLAZE]

May you give me some good seinen to read.

Kingdom,Vagabond.Tokyo ghoul :|

Yeah i have downloaded all the chapters too the mangas below to my computer.

1)Assasination Classroom
2)Bakuman
3)Code Breaker
4)Deadman Wonderland
5)Death Note
6)Enigma
7)Fairy Tail
8)Full Metal Alchemist
9)Hamatora
10)Higurashi
11)History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi
12)Hunter X Hunter
13)Katekyo Hitman Reborn
14)Nisekio
15)No Game No Life
16)Onani Master Kurosawa
17)One Piece
18)Shaman King
19)Shaman King Flowers
20)Shingeki No Kyojin
21)Nanatsu No Taizai
22)To Love Ru
23)To Love Ru Darkness
24)Tonari No Seki Kun
25)World Trigger

I also have some Dragonball and Toriko chapters.Naruto is my favorite manga.

Toriko Negs :|
Try bolded ones

ok ok so Saint Seiya is great imo, it's a shonen right :mew:

Yeah
Haven't tried it though

 

[Shanks]

I think manga ranking spot cant be a mirror or image to actual manga quality.

its more about long term fans than quality

What I seek here is about opinion on manga quality and its popularity right.

Yes, It is still a good manga . He is def one of the respected Mangaka in Japan as far has i know.

 

[Ansatsuken]

Yeah i have downloaded all the chapters too the mangas below to my computer.

1)Assasination Classroom
2)Bakuman
3)Code Breaker
4)Deadman Wonderland
5)Death Note
6)Enigma
7)Fairy Tail
8)Full Metal Alchemist
9)Hamatora
10)Higurashi
11)History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi
12)Hunter X Hunter
13)Katekyo Hitman Reborn
14)Nisekio
15)No Game No Life
16)Onani Master Kurosawa
17)One Piece
18)Shaman King
19)Shaman King Flowers
20)Shingeki No Kyojin
21)Nanatsu No Taizai
22)To Love Ru
23)To Love Ru Darkness
24)Tonari No Seki Kun
25)World Trigger

I also have some Dragonball and Toriko chapters.Naruto is my favorite manga.




What BS are you be speaking of?

Retconn, Asspull on many thing just for the manga can go forward and its never been explained until the end, Nerfing a characters, unnessesary fan services, some of it.

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

Also retcons like indra + asura chakra = rinnegan and hagoromo sealing the juubi alone in the moon

Are simple retcons even bad? Indra and Ashura have been mentioned in the story since the Kage Summit.While it was revealed how to get the Rinnegan in chapter 670. Before then,based on Madara taking Hashiramas cells,and awakening the Rinnegan,it was believed it was due to having Senju cells, but the truth was revealed later.

Complaining about simple retcons is like complaining that the truth of something was revealed.I don't see the problem.

Retconn, Asspull on many thing just for the manga can go forward and its never been explained until the end, Nerfing a characters, unnessesary fan services, some of it.

What were the asspulls? And the only thing that can be considered fanservice is chapter 700,which isn't bad.Alot of stories end off showing the future,who the main characters got with,and showing their kids.what's wrong with that.

Knowing what the canon pairings are is better than the story never ending and having the fans endlessly guess,and wish it was shown.

Kingdom,Vagabond.Tokyo ghoul :|


Toriko Negs :|
Try bolded ones


Yeah
Haven't tried it though

Indeed,Death Note,FMA,Bakuman,Toriko,and OP are among my favs.

 

[Shanks]

No it isn't, not in terms of sales anyways. And my avatar is not from an anime, it's from a game.

but Naruto is not a terrible series , I read some Shonen Manga which are far worse and Mediocre .. Anyway its your opinon i will not comment on that .

Name of the game please.

 

[take it easy]

8.5/ 10 and one of the greatest shonen manga evar.

 

[Joseph Gomes]

Are simple retcons even bad? Indra and Ashura have been mentioned in the story since the Kage Summit.While it was revealed how to get the Rinnegan in chapter 670. Before then,based on Madara taking Hashiramas cells,and awakening the Rinnegan,it was believed it was due to having Senju cells, but the truth was revealed later.

Complaining about simple retcons is like complaining that the truth of something was revealed.I don't see the problem.

Retcons are bad because they are second thought. And they alter previously established facts

I am not saying Naruto is bad though. It was brilliant until kage summit arc. It became really bad after Obito got TNJ...

 

[BLAZE]

Indeed,Death Note,FMA,Bakuman,Toriko,and OP are among my favs.

Code Breaker had so much Potential though

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

Retcons are bad because they are second thought. And they alter previously established facts

I am not saying Naruto is bad though. It was brilliant until kage summit arc. It became really bad after Obito got TNJ...

I doubt this one was an afterthought,considering how much sense it makes.It was already explained by Tobi that Indra and Ashura are the Sage's sons who inherited half his power,and later we find out that combining their power awakens the Rinnegan,since putting their power together makes the Sage's.

That's a better explanation than Uchiha + Senju = Sage. Instead it's specifically Ashura's chakra + Indra's = the Sage chakra/Rinnegan rather than,for example, fodder Uchiha + Fodder Senju = Rinnengan.

Code Breaker had so much Potential though

I'm only on chapter 30,But what happened? Did it go on a long haitus then suddenly ended? I remember seeing a big time gap between when chapter 229 came out and 230 or something like that.

 

[BLAZE]

I'm only on chapter 30,But what happened? Did it go on a long haitus then suddenly ended? I remember seeing a big time gap between when chapter 229 came out and 230 or something like that.

It ended after Chp 230 :| with a seven page epilogue

 

[Naruto X Hunter]

It ended after Chp 230 :| with a seven page epilogue

There was never a long haitus?