How can people seriously think that Oda is a beter writer than Kishimoto.

[Kαmi]

even in current nah manga state kishi made battle with strategy

I'm not saying it hasn't. I'm saying it hasn't been as relevant as it used to be. Even the strategy that does get used only fails because of stronger attacks, not outwitting the opponent like we used to see. Think about the strategies SA tried on the Juubi. It did nothing because it just transformed and got stronger. Later we see senjutsu being an effective weakness. Next thing you know we see a powerful OP ass tree that just drains people chakra. The strategy and tactics aren't nearly as effective as they used to be simply cause someone just overpowers someone else.

 

[Smd]

omg kishi stomps

one piece is the worst anime ive ever watched.


My order

Kubo
Kishi
Everyone else

Oda

 

[portgas d luffy]

But hmm , even though I love One Piece , New World has been boring .

IMO .

tell me about it, all that hype is gone now
maybe the last chapter will save it,if oda doesn't skip the fight

 

[November]

Lord hajime solos King kishi and Goda with mid to high diff

 

[Fodder#5]

Oda. Everyone plays so sort of role in the story. The entirety of the crew takes part in a battle. They aren't reduced to one panel every fourth manga in a battle. He also expands on his characters, both main and side. Plus the OPuniverse is a lot more in depth and expansive. Its just so much cooler. However I believe that of the big three, Kubo has emerged as the best. He somehow managed to make everything that ever happened in the manga to be relevant in the last arc. Ichigo's past is explained and Aizen comes off as more badass. Kubo>Oda>Kishi

 

[KingHashirama]

You would be a fool to compare them... They cannot be compared. Kishimoto takes mythology and religion into account.

As for one piece. I'm starting to get tired of the most random DF.... clothe changer.. really?

But yea, One piece would be the odyssey of all Manga. While Naruto would be the Iliad.

One piece = Naruto = Bleach, the same flaws you see in Naruto are in other 2 and vice-versa.

 

[Corgi]

I agree completely.

OP sucks.

 

[Bijuu Bomber]

I feel they're both equal. Their writing and what I feel like reading is all based on my mood, I can't say which is better.

 

[Optimistic]

You would be a fool to compare them... They cannot be compared. Kishimoto takes mythology and religion into account.

As for one piece. I'm starting to get tired of the most random DF.... clothe changer.. really?

But yea, One piece would be the odyssey of all Manga. While Naruto would be the Iliad.

One piece = Naruto = Bleach, the same flaws you see in Naruto are in other 2 and vice-versa.

couldn't hav said it better myself.

 

[Fodder#5]

I agree completely.

OP sucks.

Doesn't mean anything coming from an SAO fan...

 

[ekichi onizuka]

One Piece < Naruto , deal with it !

oke i'll do it

 

[iFlowMotion]

It is ones own opinion

 

[portgas d luffy]

one piece is great but the new world sucks :|but what makes me laugh is that there are fans that call him Goda.

 

[jiraiya lives]

But hmm , even though I love One Piece , New World has been boring .

IMO .

eh the beginning stages of new world (where we are currently in) are better than the beginning stages of the pre TS...
Punk Hazzard and dressrosa are>>>>>>>the first two islands pre TS..New world isn't boring, it's just how you look at it since where coming off of a TS and a War arc. OP is in the set up phase for the Kaidou or Big mam arcs (which will most likely be better than Marineford and Ennies Lobby arc)=D

 

[scorezor]

oke i'll do it

don't edit my quote you baka!

one piece is great but the new world sucks :|but what makes me laugh is that there are fans that call him Goda.

the new world sucks? B!TCH PLZ. ppl are always B!TCHing for no reason at all , that's the way oda does his arcs ALWAYS !

 

[Klad]

eh the beginning stages of new world (where we are currently in) are better than the beginning stages of the pre TS...
Punk Hazzard and dressrosa are>>>>>>>the first two islands pre TS..New world isn't boring, it's just how you look at it since where coming off of a TS and a War arc. OP is in the set up phase for the Kaidou or Big mam arcs (which will most likely be better than Marineford and Ennies Lobby arc)=D

Pre TS >>> TS IMO .

 

[Xāvî1]

hwo the hell is mr oda?

 

[ekichi onizuka]

edit my quote i'm a baka!

oke i just did glad i could help you

 

[scorezor]

oke i just did glad i could help you

-.- fack you.

 

[ekichi onizuka]

THX a lot man

it's my pleasure really U_U