Gaiden ch 1 mistranslated (Sasu/Sara 12yrs apart)

Shruikan

Kage in the Making ๐Ÿ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Aug 26, 2014
Messages
18,476
Reaction score
1,102
"Salad, you need to endure, because I'm the hero this forest needs."

If that Mitutski guy is an OOtutski I wouldnt be surprised if he just pulls off a "Sasuke has been fighting Otutski aliens for 8 years in another dimension and his trail reached back to Konoha which would explain why he is angry
 

lndra

Legendary Shinobi ๐Ÿธ
Supreme
Joined
Jun 1, 2014
Messages
31,928
Reaction score
2,237
that changes the situation quite a bit in my eyes

I didn't care much either way but this is obviously better Lol
It still feels the same. A father leaving before the child was born would have been better under the circumstance of something, but a father knowing he has a child leaving for 10+ years. Just means he did not give a shit from the reader.
 

Made in Heaven

Legendary Shinobi ๐Ÿธ
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Reaction score
2,201
If that Mitutski guy is an OOtutski I wouldnt be surprised if he just pulls off a "Sasuke has been fighting Otutski aliens for 8 years in another dimension and his trail reached back to Konoha which would explain why he is angry

Good theory. An asspull, but good.

Was she having fun in her little make-believe fantasy of true love?

DUDE!! WTF?! Get rid of that signature!
 

Kamui Sama

Sannin of the Scrolls ๐Ÿ“œ
Elite
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
5,163
Reaction score
368
It still feels the same. A father leaving before the child was born would have been better under the circumstance of something, but a father knowing he has a child leaving for 10+ years. Just means he did not give a shit from the reader.

if Sarada remembers him during this "monogokoro" period that means they had some semblance of being a family. Its not much but I think its better than him just hitting it then leaving right after.
 

Made in Heaven

Legendary Shinobi ๐Ÿธ
Supreme
Joined
May 30, 2013
Messages
31,444
Reaction score
2,201
if Sarada remembers him during this "monogokoro" period that means they had some semblance of being a family. Its not much but I think its better than him just hitting it then leaving right after.

Salad doesn't remember Sasuke though .
 

Kamui Sama

Sannin of the Scrolls ๐Ÿ“œ
Elite
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
5,163
Reaction score
368
Salad doesn't remember Sasuke though .

I'll wait for more accurate translations :sweat:

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is that Sasuke and Sakura most likely lived together for a couple years along with Salad. He was there for a period time no matter how long that may be before he had to leave on his missions. There was a family dynamic before his departure. Beyond that I couldn't care less :coffee:

edit:

Man what's with all this uproar about Sasuke not being there? The absent father isn't a new concept to shonen or manga storylines in general. Is it just the pairing and Sakura fans being upset? I can't imagine most people caring about Salad's emotions lol

I guess Kishi's handling of the last few chapters has allowed people to actually give a crap about this little stuff
 
Last edited:

Endles Waltz

Sannin of the Scrolls ๐Ÿ“œ
Elite
Joined
Nov 22, 2014
Messages
7,605
Reaction score
523
I'll wait for more accurate translations :sweat:

Anyway, what I'm trying to say is that Sasuke and Sakura most likely lived together for a couple years along with Salad. He was there for a period time no matter how long that may be before he had to leave on his missions. There was a family dynamic before his departure. Beyond that I couldn't care less :coffee:

If that was the case then why don't they have photos as a couple or better yet as a family?

You would think if Sakura could take pictures of Sarada as a baby, and as a "Monogokoro" (Bottom left pic), she would take ones of Sasuke as well if he was there. She wouldn't need to resort to the Taka pic.
 

Kamui Sama

Sannin of the Scrolls ๐Ÿ“œ
Elite
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
5,163
Reaction score
368
If that was the case then why don't they have photos as a couple or better yet as a family?

You would think if Sakura could take pictures of Sarada as a baby, and as a "Monogokoro" (Bottom left pic), she would take ones of Sasuke as well if he was there. She wouldn't need to resort to the Taka pic.

hmmm that's true
 

dizzysasukefan

Leaf Village Regular ๐Ÿƒ
Regular
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Messages
561
Reaction score
64
If that was the case then why don't they have photos as a couple or better yet as a family?

You would think if Sakura could take pictures of Sarada as a baby, and as a "Monogokoro" (Bottom left pic), she would take ones of Sasuke as well if he was there. She wouldn't need to resort to the Taka pic.

The only thing that makes sense would be that they were never married. So if Sarada IS Sakura's..that is very..um..interesting to say the least.
 

juzumaki

Jลnin Strategist ๐Ÿง 
Veteran
Joined
Aug 2, 2011
Messages
2,328
Reaction score
121
sasuke forever trash. Not surprising :yeah:
 

Memento Mori

Kage in the Making ๐Ÿ‘‘
Legendary
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
12,577
Reaction score
612
what I'm trying to say is, i don't see why *********** is translated "i haven't seen him since i was a baby", when it clearly says in japanese, (monogokoro).

MP translated as "I never got to meet him at all....He left when I was still a baby."
MS translated as "As far back as I possibly remember....we have never met once."

at the top panel, it says ใ‚‚ใฎใ”ใ“ใ‚ใคใ„ใŸๆ™‚ใ‹ใ‚‰ไผšใฃใŸใ“ใจใŒใชใ„.
the bold, ใ‚‚ใฎใ”ใ“ใ‚ (monogokoro) is a japanese expression or phrase that represents a person's time when their personalities are already slightly developed or are grown enough to have slight memories. in other words, (monogokoro) takes place slightly maybe during the age 5. (after birth for sure).

It depends on the context we are taking into consideration.Isn't that part written in hiragana?.

ใ‚‚ใฎใ”ใ“ใ‚ - mono-gokoro------->Hiragana.

mono is used to refer the tangible noun in japanese.Gokoro(kokoro) means mind,heart,spirit etc.,.

็‰ฉๅฟƒ - monogokoro-------->Kanji.

monogokoro or monokokoro means Sense,care,Materialistic and spirit etc.

@Underline - I am not sure about that part.That may not be the case for all.
@Bold - The word monogokoro in reference to the context in the chapter will have meaning something like this.....ๅนผๅ…ๆœŸใ‚’้ŽใŽใฆ ....."Past the stage of Childhood(infancy)".So as you said certainly after the birth sasuke left the village.Whether she was still a baby or grown up at the time of Sasuke leaving depends on the view of translator.The entire context can also be seen as "I have never met him since I am known."......meaning of which Sarada never met sasuke to her knowledge.

Very good find.Do you have a raw scan for what is Sakura saying when Sarada is asking about glasses?.
 

Aznkidd

Sannin of the Scrolls ๐Ÿ“œ
Elite
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
7,437
Reaction score
401
The only excuse that sasuke can get to comfort his fan is they having xx right before he left the village. Then when he left sakura found out that she is pregnant, but she know that chasing him is not รกn option and letting him know will be his burden.
 

narutodrama

Leaf Village Regular ๐Ÿƒ
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2010
Messages
739
Reaction score
69
The new translation gives actually more questions then answers, it depends from person to person what his/her earliest memories are, mine for example is when i was 2.5 years old thats the earliest memory i have.
 

Amaterasu

Anbu Operative ๐ŸŽญ
Veteran
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
4,894
Reaction score
410
Can't people just wait before making shitty assumptions ?
 

DoubleKamui

Anbu Operative ๐ŸŽญ
Veteran
Joined
Mar 12, 2014
Messages
4,803
Reaction score
848
We'll get the VIZ version tomorrow but thanks for the clarification.
 

1Told

Anbu Operative ๐ŸŽญ
Veteran
Joined
Oct 17, 2014
Messages
2,935
Reaction score
316
doesn't change the fact that the kid was abandoned by her father, neither that Sakura is lying...
 
Top