Backreading the SoulKiller's readlist, here is some analysis based on what I've read so far.
Alright, here is my reads so far, keep in mind all these reads are subject to change.
@Fait-Accompli : Honestly, I did not really have good view regarding him and alot of his posts were rubbing me the wrong way but going back and forth with him and pressuring him gave me different vibe, his reaction and the way he behaved afterwards did not really struck me as scum and so whatever suspicions I had on him decreased and actually have him on lean town for now.
I know Fait flipped town but when scum says that someone was rubbing him the wrong way, that is a good indicative that the slot is town.
@TheLukundo : Other than overthinking and making a big deal out of a first interactive post nothing really striked me out of the ordinary, no maliciousness I am getting either, him dropping off and not coming back is a bit of a dot line, right now have him null closer to town.
Hmmmm. I didn't like Lukundo's early posts with Fait and this seems like a protection, I mean, nothing out of the ordinary, no maliciousness does not match with what I read between Luk and Fait.
@Elmage G Ace : Honestly, it's tough to get a read on Elmage but I been keeping a close eye on him, he can be very valuable townie member if he indeed one so will have better understanding where Elmage lies coming DP2 if I am still alive, as of now I have him as null.
I don't know how to take this one. Was Soul Killer trying to protect Elmage or was he trying to set him up here?
What did he mean with "if I am still alive" in that whole phrase? Like, if he died, Elmage wouldn't be useful in DP2 for him? Possibly he could have chosen as his mischop push?
I think Elmage is town here.
@Nikamara : outside of her tinfoil theory loophole she was about to be sucked in, her big post I actually liked but other than that she did not really interact with members yet so honestly still need to see more of her but her big post made her make the null list for me.
He starts with a positive reality support followed by a gaslight on Nikimara.
Could be town.
@Thestatusquo : He came into the thread with his theories that me and fait are apparently scum buddies and it's stemming from my post regarding my opinion about the situation between Luk and fait, to clarify my position there I just simply disliked the heavy meta talk and needed to address it so people don't fall into that trap. However, TSQ is a very crafty player and I would not look it by him to be scheming things behind the scenes like a puppet string. I think a cop would best to look into TSQ tbh, that aside he still was giving his own opinion and theories and that has to value for something so null.
Scum lean. The logic is if he thought he was gonna flip, he'd recommend a cop check on this slot so players would read into, ok, no, he was obviously trying to drive a cop check away from his partner, but in WIFOM language it could be "don't check him If I flip red".
@DENMON : Alright now Denmon, honestly this guys is a bit of a weird one but some of his posts alarmed me, he always keep mentioning that I am filling up space, not providing much when that is far from true and not sure how he came to such conclusion, alot of times it feels like he is nitpicking for the sake of nitpicking and trying to reach into something that is simply not there, he interacted with alot of people and been fairly active which is a good thing! However, something really really rubbed me off weird. He said he wanted to place a vote on me but never did, this makes me feel he is being very careful, like he is waiting for people to vote me then he will jump into the wagon, what even was more weird is when he asked me to vote for Elmage because Denmon scum read him.
But he never really voted for elmage himself, again this gave me the vibe that he is being careful once again and does not wanna do something. Now if you are townie and you are confident then you should not be as careful as this, atleast I don't think a genuine townie would. Another thing that struck me weird is how he is confident Ansa is townie because of a single post Ansa made, but it's weird ansa did not contribute at all in DP1 and that townie post he made was because someone asked him something (if i am wrong pls correct me), yet he is giving him free pass. Which I find very weird, he never once stopped and thought something is off because Ansa was never to be seen again. Did not interact or engage on trying to find scum. All in all I have him as scum lean.
His posts alarmed him. Good! He was definitely town.
@Ansatsuken : Ansa came into this game made few posts and called it a day, now I played with the dude alot and hope everything is going well on his side but this is very scummy to me, to come into the DP and dip out out of nowhere and just disappear, he did not try pursue to catch scum either and it feels to me like he is lurking and taking a backseat. I have him as scum lean
I replace into this slot. Town.
@Alice in Noodleland : Okay alice is truly a wild card, I can't get a read on her really cause of her playstyle she was not necessarily active and made few posts here and there. I am praying she is truly townie because I can't read her type of player and due to that alice will always have a special place in my eternal scum lean list.
When I'm scum and I can't fake a read on a player, sometimes I say that I can't read the player and pass that responsibility onto another player that could. The big question here is why he couldn't fake that read? Was it because he didn't know how to set her up for a mischop or was it because he didn't know how to explain his townread on his partner? or needed distancing.
@Rej : Rej is also another wild card in mafia, I felt he was taking a backseat and not really contributing or making opinion of his own and just watching from the sidelines, I don't know but I don't really feel good about it and hope I can see more of him but until then I have him as scum lean as well.
This looks like a typical case of scum targeting an LHF. He said that Rej is a wild card but then picked on inactivity and scum leaning the slot for it.
Now I generally don't mind lynching any of my scum leans tbh, I have my vote currently on DENMON and honestly he looks like the best candidate for today lynch, if he is scum then we will gain ALOT of information out of him. That being said, I won't hold back townies ofcourse and will only change my vote if the other candidates are one of my scum leans.