Search results

I said that's the only thing relevant to me when someone accused me of caring whether or not she gets victimized. As in, my outlook on the matter was determined by her status as a male-to-female transsexual, not whether or not she's safer. We're arguing about whether or not she poses a danger...

We're arguing about whether or not she brings significant danger to the fellow inmates and whether biologically being a man is the deciding factor. But sure. We're arguing about whether or not I care if you personally do. Clearly.

As always, your reading comprehension astounds.

mfw we've been able to argue about that. Try to keep up

This makes no sense. I honestly doubt the people eating slop, showering and shitting in front of each other, and surrounded by potential danger is gonna become unbearable comfortable because of this. Like, "Yeah, it's prison, before it was alright but this is gonna be what breaks me."

When you're incapable of arguing properly but still wanna feel like you're an actual part of the conversation

Whoa, whoa, hold on a sec

You are saying that because she has the biological physique of a man, he poses a threat to these women because he's biologically stronger than most if not all of them. This argument falls through for two reasons 1. Those women already pose a danger to each other because some of them are violent...

This once again brings up the insinuation that her presence in a women's prison presents some danger they weren't already exposed to. Yeah, she's naturally stronger than other women. But there are women in the prison who are already naturally stronger, or weaker, than any other given woman also...

You're saying we should limit the handling of this situation on the fact that she is biologically male. I'm saying human beings are smart enough to not have to, and instead handle it based on things like empathy, sympathy, judging the situation socially rather than just using cold hard facts...

That IS my reasoning. I don't see why you can't understand that. You dismiss that as invalid, then so be it. But asking me the question over and over again won't change my answer. I don't care that you see it as invalid, so my answer won't change. You've said what you had to say about my answer...

And? I'm expressing my opinion on the subject. My reasoning is he underwent a male-to-female transition, and that should be deemed valid. I don't care if you find my opinion or my reasoning on the matter invalid, that is my reason. You asked me what it was, and I've told you. Either take it as...

I see it as wrong because I think his transition from male-to-female should be held valid.

No, it doesn't, because there is still the complication of pregnancies, which does not apply to this person.

Holy shit, she is still going to prison. Female prison isn't any less prison than male prison. It's not special treatment because it's still prison.

Yeah, this is why reading is fundamental. The reason I was arguing that(that wasn't even my argument) is because people were saying the women in a female prison would be in danger if she were sent there. That's a faulty argument because those women are already in danger due to the presence of...

What do you mean aside from reproducing? That IS the reason why. This is like asking "Why is stealing wrong aside from the fact that it's taking something that's not yours?" You're loading the question, and making it a very stupid one at that. I know they won't because their surgery is complete...

That's nice? This has little to affect my post. She's a transsexual male-to-female. Like I told Inanimated, I don't really care whether or not you agree with the notion she should be treated as a female, that is simply how I view the situation.

Because they're still men and haven't made a transition to being and identifying as women? The point being to prevent in-jail pregnancies? Neither of those apply to this situation.

Check the edit, and yes, someone here clarified that the surgery was complete. Thought she still has remnants, whatever that means, she can't actually get anyone pregnant. Hence, it's irrelevant to the case, which is why I forgot about it.