Hiruzen > Hashirama Proof!

Vexorian

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
1,000
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Even though I do agree that Hiruzen CAN win against Hashirama, most of your logic is flawed. Especially the part where Madara < Hashirama currently, seeing as how that is definitely not the case. Fool. Perfection isn't in the form of power, it's in the form of control. Part 1 Powerscaling versus Part 2 Powerscaling is the issue currently.
 
Last edited:

Kenpai

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
1,129
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I am very open-minded, so please come up with contrary evidence, and I am willing to change my opinion.

To me, Manga says that Hiruzen > Hashirama. Proof below:

1) Iruka calls Hiruzen the greatest hokage
2) Hiruzen was able to fight Hashirama, Tobirama [both with INFINITE ****ing chakra] AND orochimaru; when he wasn't even in PRIME. Madara who is weaker than Hashirama; is able to solo 5 kages. And Hiruzen alone was stronger than Madara. If Hiruzen fought non-edo Hashi at prime; he would have probably killed Hashi while reading "Icha Icha tactics".
3) Official databook says Hiruzen is stronger than Hashirama
4) Kakuzu survived Hashirama encounter
5) Hashirama was killed by random ninja


When it comes to restraining Kyubii alone, Tenzo/Yamato can do a better job than Jiraiya. But J-man will probably solo 10 ninja of Yamato's calibre.

So Hiruzen >>> Hashirama.
1. Who is Iruka in the ninja world? Like is he strong, did h contribute anything? *Do not answer that*
2. 1) Orochimaru was being an arrogant ***hole which was why he lost the use of his arms. 2) Orochimaru's edo justu IS incomplete. 3) The battle with the dead hokages was WACK has hell. Kishi should have done a better job.
3. Databook....really, really?
4. And? Tsuikage/Muu survived the encounter with Madara. Meaning Madara let him live. Same thing could have happened with 1st and Kakuzu.
5. And? Tobirama was killed by "random ninja"

And I don't understand the use of spoilers. Jman can rape both tenzo/yamato with his eyes closed.
 

stoikis

Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2012
Messages
432
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. Iruka, a fodder called him the best hokage...Madara, one of the main villain called Hashi the best shinobi.
2. Edo, but not using its full power.
3. Where???!
4. Hashi didn't like to finish off someone, he a cool man, a Hokage.
5. Please state.
i hate this hiruzen-hashirama threads
but
Iruka maybe is fodder but he is a teacher his job is to teach the kids about ninja stufff and history so he knows what he is talking about
 

Kenpai

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
1,129
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I thought everyone already knew Hiruzen was stronger
Since you're there you mind as well check out this:


I mean everyone can use youtube. The anime does a better job of showing stuff in aciton. The manga just explains it better.
 

Cascade

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
1,469
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. Iruka, a fodder called him the best hokage...Madara, one of the main villain called Hashi the best shinobi.
2. Edo, but not using its full power.
3. Where???!
4. Hashi didn't like to finish off someone, he a cool man, a Hokage.
5. Please state.
it was full power...it was just a different power scaling...please get ur facts straight.
but i agree, im sick of these threads too, but no need to be so harsh, hes got like 50 posts here, he didnt know lol
 

Kenpai

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
1,129
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
it was full power...it was just a different power scaling...please get ur facts straight.
but i agree, im sick of these threads too, but no need to be so harsh, hes got like 50 posts here, he didnt know lol
It wasn't full powered...If you compare Kabuto' and Oro's edo justu. Kabuto's is obviously superior to Oro. If they were full powered then....god bless naruto threads.

Kabuto:
1. He gave them enough free will to get the job done (Too much free will because Itachi temporarly was free of it and Madara broke out of it).
2. He allowed them to use their justus on how they seen fit.

If you rewatch or re-read the begining of the Oro-3rd fight. Oro took the free will from the hokages. That was what the seals with the kunais was.
 

Icelerate

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jun 10, 2012
Messages
9,255
Kin
37💸
Kumi
30💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It's funny, because you've presented a better argument than a large majority of people yet you have been flammed.
I believe people like you and Owarij made much better arguments.

The OP is wrong when he compares Edo Madara with Hashirama and Hiruzen.
Secondly did you just say that Jiraiya can solo 10 ninjas on the same level as Yamato, who is one of the most powerful jounin in the series and who is close to low kage level? I guess you were exaggerating but good point I guess.
 

AlexXx

Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2012
Messages
1,708
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I am very open-minded, so please come up with contrary evidence, and I am willing to change my opinion.

To me, Manga says that Hiruzen > Hashirama. Proof below:

1) Iruka calls Hiruzen the greatest hokage
2) Hiruzen was able to fight Hashirama, Tobirama [both with INFINITE ****ing chakra] AND orochimaru; when he wasn't even in PRIME. Madara who is weaker than Hashirama; is able to solo 5 kages. And Hiruzen alone was stronger than Madara. If Hiruzen fought non-edo Hashi at prime; he would have probably killed Hashi while reading "Icha Icha tactics".
3) Official databook says Hiruzen is stronger than Hashirama
4) Kakuzu survived Hashirama encounter
5) Hashirama was killed by random ninja

I am also going to go ahead and refute your evidence before you present it
a) Madara's claim that Hashirama was/is the only one who can stop him should not be taken seriously. Why? See spoiler.

Madara probably only knew Hiruzen as a child. Hiruzen probably grew leaps and bounds after that. If Orochimaru/Asuma comes back as Edo-Tensei; he will find it hard to believe that Naruto has outgrown Jiraiya. Similarly, Madara has no means to know what happened after his death. If Orochimaru is resurrected after 50 years, he will see Konohamaru as a kid. Does that mean that Konohamaru wouldn't have surpassed Orochimaru?

Also, another important point - just because Hashirama was able to restrain Kyubi easily, it doesn't make him the strongest. Why? See spoiler.

When it comes to restraining Kyubii alone, Tenzo/Yamato can do a better job than Jiraiya. But J-man will probably solo 10 ninja of Yamato's calibre.

So Hiruzen >>> Hashirama.

1. well who is iruka.
2. tobirama, hashirama werent foul power/ bad controlled
3. dont know what databook is
4. kakuzu had luck
5. we need a manga scan where this was stated

BUT THE REST is right

MADARA PROBABLY ONLY KNEW HIRUZEN AS A CHILD.
^ this said everything
 

Kenpai

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
1,129
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I believe people like you and Owarij made much better arguments.

The OP is wrong when he compares Edo Madara with Hashirama and Hiruzen.
Secondly did you just say that Jiraiya can solo 10 ninjas on the same level as Yamato, who is one of the most powerful jounin in the series and who is close to low kage level? I guess you were exaggerating but good point I guess.
I agree. I battled Owarij before on a Jman vs Pain thread for like 3 -6 pages..lol.

Yamato's fighting ability isn't that great. Matter of fact it's kinda average or below. His only low kage level because of the blood he got from the 1st which allows he to contain a biju beast.
 

Ryuu..

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jan 16, 2012
Messages
16,752
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I believe people like you and Owarij made much better arguments.

The OP is wrong when he compares Edo Madara with Hashirama and Hiruzen.
Secondly did you just say that Jiraiya can solo 10 ninjas on the same level as Yamato, who is one of the most powerful jounin in the series and who is close to low kage level? I guess you were exaggerating but good point I guess.
Well, believe me, this is a pretty good argument in comparison to the other ones people have put forward. Which made it all the more ironic that he was flammed. If certain other people catch wind of this thread, they'll begin to spread false information, and they'll do so with arrogance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Icelerate

The Hidden Shinobi

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 7, 2012
Messages
8,140
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I am very open-minded, so please come up with contrary evidence, and I am willing to change my opinion.

To me, Manga says that Hiruzen > Hashirama. Proof below:

1) Iruka calls Hiruzen the greatest hokage
2) Hiruzen was able to fight Hashirama, Tobirama [both with INFINITE ****ing chakra] AND orochimaru; when he wasn't even in PRIME. Madara who is weaker than Hashirama; is able to solo 5 kages. And Hiruzen alone was stronger than Madara. If Hiruzen fought non-edo Hashi at prime; he would have probably killed Hashi while reading "Icha Icha tactics".
3) Official databook says Hiruzen is stronger than Hashirama
4) Kakuzu survived Hashirama encounter
5) Hashirama was killed by random ninja

I am also going to go ahead and refute your evidence before you present it
a) Madara's claim that Hashirama was/is the only one who can stop him should not be taken seriously. Why? See spoiler.

Madara probably only knew Hiruzen as a child. Hiruzen probably grew leaps and bounds after that. If Orochimaru/Asuma comes back as Edo-Tensei; he will find it hard to believe that Naruto has outgrown Jiraiya. Similarly, Madara has no means to know what happened after his death. If Orochimaru is resurrected after 50 years, he will see Konohamaru as a kid. Does that mean that Konohamaru wouldn't have surpassed Orochimaru?

Also, another important point - just because Hashirama was able to restrain Kyubi easily, it doesn't make him the strongest. Why? See spoiler.

When it comes to restraining Kyubii alone, Tenzo/Yamato can do a better job than Jiraiya. But J-man will probably solo 10 ninja of Yamato's calibre.

So Hiruzen >>> Hashirama.
1) I am sorry but I take madara's word over who is strong over iruka's any day but that's just me :sy:

2) Hashirama and tobirama did not fight to their full capabilities because orochimaru was in control of them and he did not know what they were fully capable of. There was no way on earth he was going to win this battle he realised that about half way his only and I repeat his only way to take them all out and protect the village was to use RDS. How do I know this was his only way? because that jutsu requires your life as a sacrifice.

If he could seal the 1st and 2nd hokage and defeat oro he would of but the truth is he couldn't he was to old and even if he was in his prime 3 on 1? well maybe he would of found a way to seal the 1st and the 2nd because they wasn't fighting to their full capabilites but even if he did I doubt he could defeat oro as well (this is in his prime I am talking about) of course old hiruzen put up a fight he wasn't given the title of hokage for no bloody reason!

3)Where in the data book does it say "hiruzen is stronger then hashirama" provide evidence (and you want be able to)

4) Kakuzu was weak hashirama showed him mercy because he has a heart madara would of finished him then and there

5) That was a lie and I am quite angry to see you state that.

Your point about madara is actually correct he lived after the battle with hashi but he wouldn't know the strength of people born around nagato's birth and after. So everyone that was born after nagato he wouldn't know. We also don't know when he died exactly so me saying nagato is just speculation but a decent guess as he said nagato's name.

Your second point is good about restraining the kyuubi I agree:

Final word don't underestimate the power of the older son and younger son descendant chosen ones these people are: Hashirama, madara, naruto and sasuke. I think they are the strongest people from madara's time to right now well not sasuke yet but he is also a chosen one he will get to that level. After witnessing madara on the battlefield toying with the kages and praising hashirama I don't think you should take hashirama lightly as well. Just my opinion based on how OP madara is.

You comparing hiruzen to hashi in my eyes it seems like you are comparing naruto (future hashi probably surpass him) and konohamaru (future hiruzen might surpass)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kenpai

TheSages456

Active member
Elite
Joined
Aug 23, 2011
Messages
6,551
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
hiruzen doesnt even know the full extent of hashiramas power. nobody knows. thats why hashiramas power was a myth. the very few that did know tried to tell others and were dismissed because nobody thought such a powerful shinobi could exist.
 

The Hidden Shinobi

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 7, 2012
Messages
8,140
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
hiruzen doesnt even know the full extent of hashiramas power. nobody knows. thats why hashiramas power was a myth. the very few that did know tried to tell others and were dismissed because nobody thought such a powerful shinobi could exist.
This is also true hiruzen looked about 7-8 in his flash back with hashirama and tobirama and hashi died shortly after. Even hiruzen and the elders won't know the full extent this is what I am talking about when I say the people who called hiruzen the strongest don't even know the 1st and barely the second they just heard stories of the guy who founded their village. How can they judge who is the strongest when they haven't even seen a single thing the first can do.

Those anbu that watched hiruzen's death know about 40% of what he can do.

From what we seen great strength, good taijutsu skills, landscape changing abilities even though they was in a closed area. Judging from yamato decent water and earth techs. What ever yamato can do hashi can do much much better use him to learn some small things of what hashi can do (hashi's would be on a whole other scale but we can use him as a tiny guideline.

Madara is not weaker then Hashirama,he lost on purpose to gain his power (I think)
Ask you self this if he was stronger why fake his death? why not win the battle you still get his dna and the village will be unstable. Faking his death means he realised he was going to lose but found a way to make it seem like hashi had killed him and then escape.
 
Last edited:

randomuno

Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2011
Messages
139
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Why should I take Madara's opinion seriously, when he never knew Hiruzen in his prime?
If I resurrect Alfred Nobel [and if he were as arrogant as Madara], he will naturally talk about the glories of Dynamite; unless he is educated about the nuclear bomb and thermonuclear bomb.

Why should I trust Madara's outdated info over the info passed by someone who was appointed by Konoha village; as a teacher of Ninja history? Democritus is greater in stature a professor in a university. But Democritus resurrected would be under the impression that atoms are indivisible; when we know about sub-atomic particles today. Does that mean that my teacher who is like "random fodder" is wrong; and Democritus, who is like Madara of chemistry, right?

Also answer these questions:

How is Edo-Shodaime; with infinite chakra weaker than Shodaime in life?

Where does it say that Orochimaru's Edo was weaker?

Why should I trust Madara's opinion over the official databook which SAYS that Hiruzen is the strongest; and Iruka through manga also said that. Refer to First Databook, pages 117 and 265

Please read my first post again and then reply. I've made several edits to it to defend against several arguments that have been put here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top