[VS] BM Minato vs Edo Madara

Who wins ?


  • Total voters
    37

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Minato is never forming a large TBB, Madara can do something about any Bijuu Dama that takes time to prepare (big ones, obviously) and tank or absorb any of the smaller ones.

Madara isn't stopping him from forming a large Bijuu Dama.


More so, he can use Jukai Kotan to change the trajectory of any TBB Minato launches, when he claimed he could change the trajectory of the TBB tree's Bijuu Dama [ ].
I've posted a counter to this. Warping them straight onto markings in the battlefield prevents him from changing their trajectory. Not to mention without knowing exactly how he could change their trajectory, making an argument saying he'll do this against Minato's Bijuu Dama is hard. You don't if the way the Bijuu Dama were set up lets him change it, nor do you know if he needed the alliance to make the Doton Wall before he could deviate it to sea.

What I do know, is that when Hashirama needed to deviate a Bijuu Dama's trajectory, he used Rashomon and not Jukai Kotan. That says something.



Nagato's Preta absorbed an entire v2 shroud from Bee. You are probably thinking TBB's chakra>V2 shroud. That is wrong. Bee and Hachibi were nearly drained at the end of the Kisame fight [ ]. Bee lost a 6 tailed shroud twice, was reverted from his v2 to his v1 shroud, and a full v2 shroud. v2 shroud is technically 13 tails in a v1 shroud, since Kisame can absorb 6 at a time. If you make all of these into 6 tailed shrouds, Bee lost 31 tails, or 5 shrouds, until he and the Hachibi were out of chakra. What does this mean? It means Preta absorbed the full v2 shroud, which is 13/31=42% of Hachibi and Bee's Chakra in one go. For the sake of argument, i'll say the Raiton and Ink cost Bee 2% (probably much less) of his chakra. If Bee can fire 8 average TBB's in order to exhaust himself, that would mean it is 1/8th of his chakra, or 12.5%. That means the Preta absorbed somewhere along the lines of 3.4 chakra's worth of Bijuu Dama's. Mokuton clones are present, so it is doubtable. Asura gives an extra pair of hands as well. Clones use Deva or lower versions of Susano to keep Minato at bay for that brief moment.

That proves that B's Standard Bijuu Dama contains less chakra than his V2 State. Kurama has much more chakra and casually throws at much much larger Bijuu Dama. This doesn't begin to prove that Minato's Super Bijuu Dama contains less chakra in it than 1 V2 Cloak from Killer B.

Asura Path is useless since more hands doesn't mean faster absorption.

Deva has a 5 second limit which Minato can easily abuse, and Susanoo can't be used while Preta Path is active. Even if its a clone, as the original Madara failed to absorb the Jinton properly because his clones were using Susanoo.



Super Bijuu Dama gets its trajectory changed in the same way Juubito's TBB was about to. Super Bijuu Dama is easily interrupted with an ST, PS shockwave or other long range projectile if he doesn't choose to change its trajectory.
ST isn't going to do anything, PS shockwaves are blocked by the tails. Same goes for any other long range projectile, assuming it'd even be strong enough to interrupt the Bijuu Dama.


Fair enough, my memory failed me. Either way, something like this on a larger scale would certainly suffice [ ]. Don't forget that chakra rods are also an option [ ], and would disrupt his chakra moulding rather easily.

He had to use a rock to deflect the Bijuu Dama. He didn't interrupt it. And there is no rock large enough in this area that he can grab and use to smack Minato in the face, and divert his mouth away so that the Bijuu Dama misses. Especially when he can block with his tails.

And Madara needs to be close to apply his chakra rods, as he doesn't have the large ones Obito used, nor does he have a way to apply them from long range like Obito did. And if he gets close, he gets murked...not like he'd be able to get close and apply enough chakra rods to suppress Minato before Bijuu Dama is charged and fired anyway.

If it creates a large enough repulsion, it could make the TBB detonate due to the sheer impact of the initial clash. Preta absorbs thee TBB's AOE much more easily when it's further away from the epicentre, as the energy decays as you go further and further from it at exponential rates.
Why? Naruto smacked 5 Bijuu Dama away when he first went Bijuu Mode, and it didn't explode until slamming into the Mountains. Using Shinra Tensei to push it back will just push it back and nothing else..allowing Minato to hit it back at Madara with his tails, or by making one of equal size and slamming them both into him during the cooldown.

Except he won't be far enough away for it to make a real difference.


Non - Sequitur; "TBB and Juubi laser have a higher overall energy output, therefor PS shockwaves cannot affect Kurama's BM". PS shockwave can slice a mountain with penetrative force. Penetrative force is not the equivalent of energy blasts no matter how you look at it. I've seen your energy output argument, it's fallacious. Put up a wall of kevlar. It takes over 1 million Joules to melt Kevlar. To cut it, imagine there was a knife that was about to be used. If the knife was thrust at 200 km per hour, and the knife weighed 0.10 kilograms the knife would have a kinetic energy of about joules. Using kinetic energy formula, you only reach 154 J, despite the difference, the correlation is clear. Naruto's body being resistant to an energy attack like Juubilaser, or even TBB, doesn't imply his body is resistant to cutting attacks. Another example of this is the Hachibi. He's had his tails cut by just about every shinobi in NV, but he was able to survive his own TBB without being extremely affected. Naruto tanking Juubilaser doesn't give him the implicative feats to tank PS shockwaves.
Uh, yes it does. The Juubi Laser doesn't explode as the manga shows, it penetrates. So that renders this whole comparison invalid. Not to mention PS blades being cutting attacks while Bijuu Dama is an explosive attack doesn't mean that one will kill him on impact while the other won't. Makes no sense. At the end of the day, all attacks output energy and the one that outputs the least energy is the weaker one. PS Slash takes the power of a Bijuu Dama and focuses it along the edge of the blade instead of spreading it out explosive wise, so it'd probably do more damage to Naruto than a normal Bijuu Dama would. But there is zero evidence I see from your post that PS Slashes output more energy along its edge than the Juubi Laser did as a whole.

Hachibi is a terrible example since his tentacles aren't shown to be durable, and he was seriously injured when he took his Bijuu Dama. Overall, the Bijuu Dama did more damage to him than any attack that has ever cut his body has ever done to him. So I'm not seeing your point. Not to mention you aren't factoring in damage per unit area. Weaker attacks can do more damage than stronger attacks if they affect a lesser amount of area on the target. Rasengan might not do as much damage as Chidori did to Ay because Chidori focuses the power Rasengan has into a single point, while Rasengan spreads it all out. The only way you could say a cutting attack or a piercing attack is automatically superior, is if you are talking about an explosive attack that is equal in output to the piercing attack.

"Different types of attacks" isn't a good enough reason for me to believe that PS Slashes, which only have the power of a standard Bijuu Dama focused on the edge

Cutting Attacks and Explosive Attacks not being the same doesn't give you the right to claim that PS cuts through the Kurama Avatar with no evidence backing it. Seen so many people use this argument....lol.


Edo Tensei doesn't grant infinite chakra, it merely grants you the ability to use the maximum yield of chakra you have infinitely. That was the case for Tobirama's 2 Kage Bunshin's, it is the case here too. Madara can create Mokuton Bunshins who use large scale Mokuton techniques, Rinnegan abilities on par with Nagato's, EMS techniques and his underrated Gunbai, which can deflect any of their jutsu right back at them. Don't forget the fact that once a Mokuton location has been manifested, the clones and Madara can come in and out of the Mokuton however they please. Madara doesn't need to uphold a PS the entire fight, only towards the end, once the FTG kunai's have been buried deep within the Advent of flowering trees or have been essentially destroyed by the Susano/Asura wielding clones.

That is exactly why he isn't doing all of the stuff that you say he is going to do at once. His Chakra Pool hasn't changed, the only difference is that their chakra regenerates back to full as they use it up.


Flowering tree world isn't being destroyed when any TBB directed at it gets its trajectory changed in the same way the TBB tree's Bijuu Dama were about to be. He doens't need to use Perfect Susano the entire fight, he can use his normal legged Susano and spread the love; allowing all of his clones to use his Mokuton, MS and Rinnegan techs. PS isn't the only option for Madara to end Minato, but it definitely is one of them. Gedo is an option. Flowering Tree world is an option. Etc.

1. Read above for Bijuu Dama.

2. Madara can't use the Gedo as an Edo Tensei.


3. Flower Tree World isn't an option.
 

Haizaki

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
May 4, 2013
Messages
6,233
Reaction score
295
- Minato told Gai to not stop at anything, and it was never stated or even hinted that he wasn't at full speed. So, please, don't make up some fan-fiction things because you don't like what happened. What you said is no more than base-less assumption in your part.

- What does that prove? Minato was in front of him, and the next second he was in Konoha, what's your point?
and we know that Gai gets faster with each step, so the scan you posted he was actually slower according to Lee.


- Lol, except Minato was not moving, even a moving snail is faster than him, when he's not moving. On the other hand, Gai was moving, so that is not a very intelligent comparison.

- And Minato reacted to 8th Gate, I don't know why are you talking what you like, and ignore what you don't like. Lol
as for kicking the air, that's true in the 7th Gate, however, it's not true in the 8th Gate case, and almost all of Gai's attacks against
madara was when he was flying. Lol

Lmaoo this guys inability to comprehend is horrible..Sees this scan , and then says Lee notes Gai was slower...My goodness I'm speechless Lol. No and no.

So Gai can fly with the 8th gate now Lmaooo??????? Again this is a horrible comeback.

Gaara's sand was keeping up so nooo he wasn't at full speed...Lee followed his movement and threw Minato's kunai in front of a moving Gai...If you think 6G Lee can follow Gai's high speed movements first of all, then that's crazy alongside throwing an object in front of him.
 
Last edited:

Unorthodox

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Feb 11, 2012
Messages
16,325
Reaction score
693
people taking ababel serious kidgamer skipped my argument tsk
 

Ababeel

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
May 28, 2013
Messages
2,375
Reaction score
224
Lmaoo this guys inability to comprehend is horrible..Sees this scan , and then says Lee notes Gai was slower...My goodness I'm speechless Lol. No and no.

So Gai can fly with the 8th gate now Lmaooo??????? Again this is a horrible comeback.

Gaara's sand was keeping up so nooo he wasn't at full speed...Lee followed his movement and threw Minato's kunai in front of a moving Gai...If you think 6G Lee can follow Gai's high speed movements first of all, then that's crazy alongside throwing an object in front of him.

O.K, as you want.
You must be registered for see images
 

Yocolaw

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
1,083
Reaction score
61
lola minato cant beat tobirama in hit bm

he overated his kunai gets shenrai tensei and he teleports in spots madaz sharigan can see and destroys him

minato bm is just as good as naruto bm

neither one could handle madaz or hashirama period madara will locate all his kunai
 

Ababeel

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
May 28, 2013
Messages
2,375
Reaction score
224
lola minato cant beat tobirama in hit bm

he overated his kunai gets shenrai tensei and he teleports in spots madaz sharigan can see and destroys him

minato bm is just as good as naruto bm

neither one could handle madaz or hashirama period madara will locate all his kunai

Lol
do you even read the manga? :p

No, I suppose not.




- When has Madara even used ST? Lol
you have got too much fan-fiction there, don't you think?
 

ad0

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 4, 2014
Messages
772
Reaction score
17
That proves that B's Standard Bijuu Dama contains less chakra than his V2 State. Kurama has much more chakra and casually throws at much much larger Bijuu Dama. This doesn't begin to prove that Minato's Super Bijuu Dama contains less chakra in it than 1 V2 Cloak from Killer B.

Asura Path is useless since more hands doesn't mean faster absorption.

Deva has a 5 second limit which Minato can easily abuse, and Susanoo can't be used while Preta Path is active. Even if its a clone, as the original Madara failed to absorb the Jinton properly because his clones were using Susanoo.

Lol

Madara purposely let the jinton hit him to show hashirama faces
 

ad0

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 4, 2014
Messages
772
Reaction score
17
Madara Like to Dance so what Madara did in the war was just dancing

And some people here will say Madara Fire Style Flower Flames was his full power which was again just dancing (toying)

If Edo Madara annihilated the kages without holding back then nobody would like madara as a character.
 
Last edited:

Sakuradasoloqueen

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
517
Reaction score
20
Minato wins.

As some point will try to absorb Minato's attacks as he did with the Kakes the entire time. The first time he does that, he will get fucked. When he creates this chakra link between himself and Minato, he will be Minato's B for his entire life. U_U

Minato can Literally play with him however he likes after that. XD

The truth has been spoken.
 

Bronze

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
15,769
Reaction score
1,221
Edo Madara mid difficulty.

-Any Bijuu-Dama is held and thrown back by Mokuton: Jukai Koutan, absorbed by Preta Path, or tanked by PS.

-FTG is countered by PS's slashes.

-Bijuu Mode gets bisected by Perfect Susanoo.​
 

Minator93

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 14, 2011
Messages
14,301
Reaction score
2,260
Edo Madara mid difficulty.

-Any Bijuu-Dama is held and thrown back by Mokuton: Jukai Koutan, absorbed by Preta Path, or tanked by PS.

-FTG is countered by PS's slashes.

-Bijuu Mode gets bisected by Perfect Susanoo.​

Lel

You must be registered for see images

^^ Madara's fate against BM Minato Lol
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Madara isn't stopping him from forming a large Bijuu Dama.

Fair enough. It's fast, but still not comparable to the speed he launches his continuous TBB's at. Anyways, I didn't know you could calculate panel time to know it was a single second, and not more. I agree it's fast, but not as fast as you are suggesting. More so, PS's shockwave and sword move at extreme speeds, as shown when he was capable of spinning his sword so quickly that the shockwave reached each mountain at a nigh identical time, portrayed by the mountains top being at the same elevated place in each [ ]. If PS is active while Minato attempts this, than his Super Bijuu Dama explodes in his face, and Madara's PS, which is somewhat far from the epicentre, tanks. If Minato is close, than a simple Shinra Tensei should make him lose control while charging TBB. Inb4 the second it is charged, it is fired. Madara's sharingan perceiving chakra build up and his quickness to act don't allow for such.

I've posted a counter to this. Warping them straight onto markings in the battlefield prevents him from changing their trajectory. Not to mention without knowing exactly how he could change their trajectory, making an argument saying he'll do this against Minato's Bijuu Dama is hard. You don't if the way the Bijuu Dama were set up lets him change it, nor do you know if he needed the alliance to make the Doton Wall before he could deviate it to sea.

What I do know, is that when Hashirama needed to deviate a Bijuu Dama's trajectory, he used Rashomon and not Jukai Kotan. That says something.

That's implying they are right underneath the PS, which is unlikely ever the case, since a single step on an FTG kunai would destroy it. Randomly firing shockwaves at FTG kunai's on the floor would destroy the entire land scape and its present FTG kunai's rather easily.More so, Madara can track any FTG kunai location around him if the Raikage, who had no sharingan, could. Given this, Madara either stays away from them, has a clone dispose of them, or stomps on them. And I'm not saying he'll destroy them all, only the ones which are nearby and have the potential to endanger him. Doesn't matter, changing trajectory is changing trajectory. How the Tree is set up is irrelevant when it is being fired in the same way all TBB's are (unless you have some form of implication/evidence to deny this), and the fact that Doton walls being assumed to work by Hashirama, when he wasn't even on the battlefield when they were used, is fallacious.

No, it doesn't. The difference back then was that the TBB had destructive and penetrative properties [ ], whereas against the TBB tree it only has its destructive properties since it has none of the Susano swords attached to it. Mokuton is weak to cutting techniques, and strong/resistant to high pressure/destructive capability techniques (to some extent). Hence, the usage of the Rashomon, which logically isn't weak to penetrative force due to its thick steel like structure, makes it deal in comparison to the Jukai Kotan. So no, it says nothing whatsoever.


That proves that B's Standard Bijuu Dama contains less chakra than his V2 State. Kurama has much more chakra and casually throws at much much larger Bijuu Dama. This doesn't begin to prove that Minato's Super Bijuu Dama contains less chakra in it than 1 V2 Cloak from Killer B.

Asura Path is useless since more hands doesn't mean faster absorption.

Deva has a 5 second limit which Minato can easily abuse, and Susanoo can't be used while Preta Path is active. Even if its a clone, as the original Madara failed to absorb the Jinton properly because his clones were using Susanoo.

True, but I didn't mean his Super Bijuu Dama. I am simply implying a normal TBB from Kurama is in fact absorbable. A super Bijuu Dama is deflectable via Jukai Kotan.

Never claimed it did. I am saying Madara having extra limbs means the ability to use his gunbai to lay off the incoming clone you speak of, who somehow bypassed a Susano clone mokuton wiedling clone, and Deva clone. More so, nothing implies once one clone uses Deva, all clones attempting to use Deva are restricted by the 5 second limit. That has nothing to support it, thus 5 Mokuton clones, firing off one ST after another, along with the original doing so, allows for a safe Preta absorption. This isn't factoring in the clone using Mokuton, nor is it factoring in the clone using Susano.

Madara using 25 clones and having them use Susano is different than using 1 Susano wielding clone and using Preta. Anyhow, the Susano clone being out is simply an option. Rinnegan and Mokuton wielding clones are more than enough for stalling.


ST isn't going to do anything, PS shockwaves are blocked by the tails. Same goes for any other long range projectile, assuming it'd even be strong enough to interrupt the Bijuu Dama.

ST pushes Kurama back rather easily, when Deva Path's unconcentrated, small scale Shinra Tensei pushed back 3 toads hundred of meters away and put them on the verge of death. The weight difference isn't that big, and factoring in the fact that this ST is concentrated and on a completely superior level than Deva's, it's safe to say Kurama is pushed pretty far back. PS will be addressed later on, when you elaborate. It disrupts the chakra system in the body, Kyuubi is no exception of this. He can overpower it, sure, but it still will have a temporarily detrimental effect on the chakra moulding, invalidating his TBB.

He had to use a rock to deflect the Bijuu Dama. He didn't interrupt it. And there is no rock large enough in this area that he can grab and use to smack Minato in the face, and divert his mouth away so that the Bijuu Dama misses. Especially when he can block with his tails.

Location is unspecified. More so, Nagato was capable of pulling out stones from the middle of the water, I'm sure random stones or objects will be lying around, in which Nagato can use to make the TBB backfire. Blocking it with his tails is assuming he has knowledge of it, or can sense. Neither is the case, so I'll deem it improbable.

And Madara needs to be close to apply his chakra rods, as he doesn't have the large ones Obito used, nor does he have a way to apply them from long range like Obito did. And if he gets close, he gets murked...not like he'd be able to get close and apply enough chakra rods to suppress Minato before Bijuu Dama is charged and fired anyway.

Based on what? Obito has Madara's Rinnegan at the end of the day, so there's noo reason for him not to have them. Madara can always throw them, so I don't see your point.

Why? Naruto smacked 5 Bijuu Dama away when he first went Bijuu Mode, and it didn't explode until slamming into the Mountains. Using Shinra Tensei to push it back will just push it back and nothing else..allowing Minato to hit it back at Madara with his tails, or by making one of equal size and slamming them both into him during the cooldown.

Except he won't be far enough away for it to make a real difference.

That's different. Naruto created an equilibrium with the other TBB's, and it only exploded upon contact with something else because the TBB itself didn't trigger such a thing at equilibrium. Minato's TBB being touched by another force when it isn't moving will conclude in an explosion, in the same way 100% Kurama's TBB exploded once it made contact with the floor after being teleported, when Bunta briefly sat on him. Can't tell what you are hinting at, but it sounds like you are making the TBB into some form of volleyball, which isn't a plausible scenario.

The difference is in fact massive. Energy decay is exponential. The further he is from the epicentre, the less chakra quantity per unit area. Apart from the fact tat he can use Mokuton constructs to protect himself from the explosion, Madara could've simply use Jukai Kotan in the first place to counter the Super Bijuu Dama. Only regular TBB attempts will get ST attempted, Super Bijuu Dama gets deflected.


Uh, yes it does. The Juubi Laser doesn't explode as the manga shows, it penetrates. So that renders this whole comparison invalid. Not to mention PS blades being cutting attacks while Bijuu Dama is an explosive attack doesn't mean that one will kill him on impact while the other won't. Makes no sense. At the end of the day, all attacks output energy and the one that outputs the least energy is the weaker one. PS Slash takes the power of a Bijuu Dama and focuses it along the edge of the blade instead of spreading it out explosive wise, so it'd probably do more damage to Naruto than a normal Bijuu Dama would. But there is zero evidence I see from your post that PS Slashes output more energy along its edge than the Juubi Laser did as a whole.

Hachibi is a terrible example since his tentacles aren't shown to be durable, and he was seriously injured when he took his Bijuu Dama. Overall, the Bijuu Dama did more damage to him than any attack that has ever cut his body has ever done to him. So I'm not seeing your point. Not to mention you aren't factoring in damage per unit area. Weaker attacks can do more damage than stronger attacks if they affect a lesser amount of area on the target. Rasengan might not do as much damage as Chidori did to Ay because Chidori focuses the power Rasengan has into a single point, while Rasengan spreads it all out. The only way you could say a cutting attack or a piercing attack is automatically superior, is if you are talking about an explosive attack that is equal in output to the piercing attack.

It's not a complete penetrative attack. You can clearly see the chakra dispersing from where it begins to find its way past Naruto [ ] like when water at high speeds is shot at a held-in-place ball. It doesn't stay in a controlled direction, so it's more like a high pressure chakra beam rather an in-place slice of penetrative abilities. So no, it's not a penetration attack at all, otherwise it wouldn't have had such an effect upon contact with the Kyuubi. Again, no. I have already showed the comparison before. Unless the BM cloak has shown resistance to piercing attacks like it has shown resistance to explosive attacks, it cannot tank PS's shockwaves. I could require 1000000000 kJ to put a slight burn on a certain metaphysical material, and this amount of energy is being heated on the material alone, not on a large scale, but only require 10 J of energy to have a knife go through one end of the material and out the other. Not that it matters, but the PS shockwave targets a much smaller area than the Juubi laser. So until BM's cloak shows some resistance to penetrative attacks on the scale of PS shockwaves, I have no reason to accept this Non - Sequitur, in which you think because he can tank explosive energy blasts, he can tank extremely concentrated attacks with penetrative properties. I've seen you argue this many times. It's wrong and goes against accepted physics, in which an energy blast and a penetrative attack have no correlation to their energy outputs in regards to their chances of achieving a desired outcome.

I am saying his tails require TBB levels of energy to be damaged, when a simple shuriken can in fact slice them with the least of difficulties. It goes against the fact hat penetrative and explosive powers are only relevant based on energy output; since the suriken has much less energy on that one point than the TBB does.

"Different types of attacks" isn't a good enough reason for me to believe that PS Slashes, which only have the power of a standard Bijuu Dama focused on the edge

Cutting Attacks and Explosive Attacks not being the same doesn't give you the right to claim that PS cuts through the Kurama Avatar with no evidence backing it. Seen so many people use this argument....lol.

Should be.

That is exactly why he isn't doing all of the stuff that you say he is going to do at once. His Chakra Pool hasn't changed, the only difference is that their chakra regenerates back to full as they use it up.

Okay. 5 clones. 2 Rinne's, 2 Mokuton's, and 1 EMS in the case Madara switches to Rinnegan.


1. Read above for Bijuu Dama.

2. Madara can't use the Gedo as an Edo Tensei.


3. Flower Tree World isn't an option.

1. Read

2. Fair enough

3. But it is. Madara uses it while a clone uses Jukai Kotan in the case a TBB is attempted to counter.
 

MuerteMiAmigo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
1,480
Reaction score
85
maybe we would finally see Spiralling Flash Super Round Dance Howl Style Three
 

LuckyMan

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
7,768
Reaction score
464
Are people forgetting Minato can teleport away or teleport to anything his chakra is touching? Thats one of the chief perks that makes his FTG so haxed. If Madara attempts to absorb one of his attacks hes just establishing the link between he and Minato that allows him to teleport to him and finish him off swiftly while hes vulnerable absorbing w/e.
 

Apêx1

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 26, 2014
Messages
6,929
Reaction score
442
Are people forgetting Minato can teleport away or teleport to anything his chakra is touching? Thats one of the chief perks that makes his FTG so haxed. If Madara attempts to absorb one of his attacks hes just establishing the link between he and Minato that allows him to teleport to him and finish him off swiftly while hes vulnerable absorbing w/e.

Are you claiming that Tobirama can teleport to any Suiton he uses, because that would make him one of the most broken non-Rikudo based Shinobi, far above Minato. He can create a lake of water and teleport to any point he chooses to teleport to. Anyhow, you misunderstand. Minato can teleport to a clone and teleport a clone to him. Minato can teleport to his chakra only when it is placed in FTG seals, not when it is placed in normal chakra, otherwise the seals would be somewhat unnecessary. .
 

AlphaScythian

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
14,389
Reaction score
1,023
Are you claiming that Tobirama can teleport to any Suiton he uses, because that would make him one of the most broken non-Rikudo based Shinobi, far above Minato. He can create a lake of water and teleport to any point he chooses to teleport to. Anyhow, you misunderstand. Minato can teleport to a clone and teleport a clone to him. Minato can teleport to his chakra only when it is placed in FTG seals, not when it is placed in normal chakra, otherwise the seals would be somewhat unnecessary. .
Yeah, Tobirama fans dont get that, chakra transformed into nature element is no longer same shit U_U
 

KidGamer65

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
38,776
Reaction score
2,272
Fair enough. It's fast, but still not comparable to the speed he launches his continuous TBB's at. Anyways, I didn't know you could calculate panel time to know it was a single second, and not more. I agree it's fast, but not as fast as you are suggesting. More so, PS's shockwave and sword move at extreme speeds, as shown when he was capable of spinning his sword so quickly that the shockwave reached each mountain at a nigh identical time, portrayed by the mountains top being at the same elevated place in each [x]. If PS is active while Minato attempts this, than his Super Bijuu Dama explodes in his face, and Madara's PS, which is somewhat far from the epicentre, tanks. If Minato is close, than a simple Shinra Tensei should make him lose control while charging TBB. Inb4 the second it is charged, it is fired. Madara's sharingan perceiving chakra build up and his quickness to act don't allow for such.

Then he blocks with his tails, or he uses Continuous Bijuu Dama to damage it, and yes, it will damage it since an attack that is equal to the output of 11 Bijuu Dama w/ Blades in them completely eradicated PS, so its not going to take almost half that output with zero damage.

And how would Shinra Tensei make him lose control of his Bijuu Dama? Being pushed back, isn't going to stop him from building chakra.

It's not a complete penetrative attack. You can clearly see the chakra dispersing from where it begins to find its way past Naruto [x] like when water at high speeds is shot at a held-in-place ball. It doesn't stay in a controlled direction, so it's more like a high pressure chakra beam rather an in-place slice of penetrative abilities. So no, it's not a penetration attack at all, otherwise it wouldn't have had such an effect upon contact with the Kyuubi. Again, no. I have already showed the comparison before. Unless the BM cloak has shown resistance to piercing attacks like it has shown resistance to explosive attacks, it cannot tank PS's shockwaves. I could require 1000000000 kJ to put a slight burn on a certain metaphysical material, and this amount of energy is being heated on the material alone, not on a large scale, but only require 10 J of energy to have a knife go through one end of the material and out the other. Not that it matters, but the PS shockwave targets a much smaller area than the Juubi laser.

@bold: For your example to properly support your argument, it'd actually have to be true here. So unless you can actually prove that the difference between explosive energy needed to blow it up and cutting energy needed to cut through it, it doesn't hold. For PS's blade to cut through Naruto, it'd have to carry MUCH more energy on the arc of its blade (Which is much wider than the avatar's whole body) than a Bijuu Dama, since Naruto's cloak withstands attacks multiples times stronger than a Bijuu Dama. If it doesn't focus anywhere near the amount of energy as the Juubi Laser, so even with the reduced surface area

You are acting like the fact that one cuts and the fact that one blows up is the important part here, when in reality its not. The only important things are the energy output, and how much surface area that the energy is being exerted on. Chidori and Rasengan are equal, yet Rasengan would do less because it affects more surface area with its energy, thus less pressure, thus less damage to Ay. Chidori takes that energy and applies it to a smaller surface area than Rasengan does, thus it does more damage. Its not about the body's resistance to certain types of attacks, doesn't make sense and has been false no matter who's brought it up.

SM FRS didn't cut through 50% Kurama, but if I used your reasoning, it should have went right through it like butter.

For PS Slash to cut Naruto's cloak, it'd have to not be utter garbage compared to a Juubi Laser in overall output, and it'd have to affect a significantly smaller surface area than the Juubi Laser did to Naruto, which it doesn't since the blade is bigger than the Kurama Avatar, and since the blade only carries the energy of a Bijuu Dama (Standard)

It takes over 1 million Joules to melt Kevlar. To cut it, imagine there was a knife that was about to be used. If the knife was thrust at 200 km per hour, and the knife weighed 0.10 kilograms the knife would have a kinetic energy of about joules. Using kinetic energy formula, you only reach 154 J, despite the difference,

And as for your fist example, I'd like to ask for some proof of these values, cause once again, unless the difference between the energies needed to cut it and melt it are actually true, then your example doesn't hold. Not to mention multiple sources state that you can't even melt Kevlar.....so, Lol, something is up with your information.

Not to mention melting, burning and stuff like that works completely differently from explosive, blunt force, and cutting/piercing attacks. An example that uses cutting vs explosive would be an example that woks best here.


So until BM's cloak shows some resistance to penetrative attacks on the scale of PS shockwaves, I have no reason to accept this Non - Sequitur, in which you think because he can tank explosive energy blasts, he can tank extremely concentrated attacks with penetrative properties. I've seen you argue this many times. It's wrong and goes against accepted physics, in which an energy blast and a penetrative attack have no correlation to their energy outputs in regards to their chances of achieving a desired outcome.

Except there is literally no evidence from you that a PS Slash is strong enough to one shot Naruto. "He hasn't taken cutting attacks, so this cutting attack will kill him" isn't a valid argument in the slightest. I could apply this same reasoning to a Shuriken and be able to say that Obito's Shuriken bisects the Kurama Avatar just because it hasn't been shown taking cutting attacks. That doesn't make sense.

I am saying his tails require TBB levels of energy to be damaged, when a simple shuriken can in fact slice them with the least of difficulties. It goes against the fact hat penetrative and explosive powers are only relevant based on energy output; since the suriken has much less energy on that one point than the TBB does.

Except that's your assumption. The fact that B was completely wrecked by Bijuu Dama only means that Bijuu dama isn't the bare minimum for the Bijuu Dama. And I already know that penetrative and explosive powers can't be compared by energy output alone, you have to look at the effect of the attack per unit area. Bijuu Dama spreads out the energy while the Shuriken focuses it all one one tail, across the tentacle's surface. All that means is when we take that specific Bijuu Dama and that Shuriken, and we reduce the area of effect of the Bijuu Dama down to the same size as the Shuriken's, that the Shuriken exerts more energy, thus it exerts more energy per unit area than Bijuu Dama. Bijuu Dama overall is a much stronger attack.

His Main body was at the epicenter of the explosion, and I know for sure that a Shuriken isn't going to cut through it.

So yeah, PS Slash isn't one shotting Naruto. "Cutting=/=Explosive" isn't a valid argument, or I should say its not a complete argument.

Should be.
Lol what? In what universe? Cause if we operated by that logic, we'd be saying things like Shuriken cut through Bijuu's main bodies, and that FRS would cut through a Bijuu's body (Though Half Kurama already took it, and it didn't cut through), and that FRS would cut through Susanoo despite it tanking Bijuu Dama, just because its a cutting attack, which isn't the same as an explosive attack. I already know you don't believe that FRS cuts through Susanoo, so no, it shouldn't be a good enough reason.

3. But it is. Madara uses it while a clone uses Jukai Kotan in the case a TBB is attempted to counter.

Except Jukai Kotan isn't going to rush and hit Minato before he can:

A. Teleport with the Bijuu Dama to evade both attacks and then nuke them.

B. Just fire the Bijuu Dama right then and there as a counter, since a standard Bijuu Dama's charge time isn't long enough for Mokuton to be used to bind him completely.

C. Evade by simply jumping.
 

LuckyMan

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
7,768
Reaction score
464
Are you claiming that Tobirama can teleport to any Suiton he uses, because that would make him one of the most broken non-Rikudo based Shinobi, far above Minato. He can create a lake of water and teleport to any point he chooses to teleport to. Anyhow, you misunderstand. Minato can teleport to a clone and teleport a clone to him. Minato can teleport to his chakra only when it is placed in FTG seals, not when it is placed in normal chakra, otherwise the seals would be somewhat unnecessary. .

If he can only teleport to his chakra when placed in FTG seals then how did he teleport to his Shadow Clone? The clone is merely a manifestation of his chakra and he teleported to it. Rasengan and Bijuu Dama are manifestation of his chakra too so what makes them different? I'm not trying to argue he can certainly without a doubt do this, but it is plausible at the very least.
 

Brother Numpsay

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Sep 27, 2012
Messages
7,879
Reaction score
334
If he can only teleport to his chakra when placed in FTG seals then how did he teleport to his Shadow Clone? The clone is merely a manifestation of his chakra and he teleported to it. Rasengan and Bijuu Dama are manifestation of his chakra too so what makes them different? I'm not trying to argue he can certainly without a doubt do this, but it is plausible at the very least.

@Bold, if that true then why does Naruto have to add senjutsu chakra into the ball if it should naturally have senjutsu chakra to begin with, since its his manifestation of his chakra.[ ]
 
Top