Better brother,Itachi or Madara

[ImpreZ]

The one that took care of their little brother

Spoiler

none

 

[WalksInShadows]

i would sooner go with the brother that would defend the hair's on my hair rather than the one who would toy with my life.

 

[Colonel Armstrong]

naruto to sasuke lol

itachi over maddy in this thread only

 

[-immortal-]

Madara for sure. He wanted to save the Uchiha. Itachi killed them Lol

 

[-immortal-]

The one that took care of their little brother

Spoiler

none

You must be registered for see images

You can now leave.... smh

 

[From the Dark Spire]

Neither of them where good brothers but based off of the situations surrounding each, I would give it to Madara. He didn't torture his brother or kill his family.

Madara, purely because of the fact that madara actually respected his brother's wishes and didn't treat him like little puppy. Also madara never conformed to konoha's rule by D riding the senju and ousting the uchiha like itachi did. He was a loyal uchiha through and through.

Both of these, so, so much.

 

[xxxLegacy]

Madara is way better brother. OMG to this ppls who says Itachi he killed his parents to protect his brother ? Looool what for idea U_U

 

[JStar King]

Madara is way better brother. OMG to this ppls who says Itachi he killed his parents to protect his brother ? Looool what for idea U_U

I started a similar thread about this.

You must be registered for see links

 

[Conspirator.]

Madara for sure. He wanted to save the Uchiha. Itachi killed them Lol

Very true.

 

[shelke]

Madara all the way. He loved his Clan / people and his brother. Itachi caused Sasuke nothing but utmost misery and slaughtered his clan over politics. He was nothing but a treacherous man, one devoid of heart and justice. He's one of the worst governmental lapdogs in the manga, and one of the worst people - a cruel, cold, and a devious man.

 

[Optimistic]

Madara. Itachi is a scumbag.

 

[Conspirator.]

Madara all the way. He loved his Clan / people and his brother. Itachi caused Sasuke nothing but utmost misery and slaughtered his clan over politics. He was nothing but a treacherous man, one devoid of heart and justice. He's one of the worst governmental lapdogs in the manga, and one of the worst people - a cruel, cold, and a devious man.

That's a very good point. Couldn't have put it better myself.

 

[Tennis Robot]

This feels like a trap question. Itachi was probably the better brother though, since he actually managed to ensure his brother's survival.

 

[Conspirator.]

This feels like a trap question. Itachi was probably the better brother though, since he actually managed to ensure his brother's survival.

@bold
It isn't. The question is what it is.

 

[Tennis Robot]

@bold
It isn't. The question is what it is.

I meant it in the sense that the question would lead to a huge argument. I'm glad it hasn't though. But it still seems to me that people are too quick to condemn Itachi...

 

[xxxLegacy]

This feels like a trap question. Itachi was probably the better brother though, since he actually managed to ensure his brother's survival.

Naruto did more as Itachi.......ITACHI was like that Naruto always wanted to help Sasko

 

[BLAZE]

I meant it in the sense that the question would lead to a huge argument. I'm glad it hasn't though. But it still seems to me that people are too quick to condemn Itachi...

Dude this not USSJ's thread
and @bolded people bash sasuke and praise itachi tbh

 

[Aquaglow]

At least Itachi protected Sasuke as long as he was alive and even gave his life instead of killing him.
Madara wasn't able to protect no one. He couldn't even come to a compromise given the fact that Hashirama/Tobirama repeatedly won their battles.

Itachi was smarter and protected his brother from dying as long as he was alive, even tough he manipulated sasuke and hurt him, he would never kill him. while Madara chose to fight everyone and to be honest, he was the leader of his clan. Hashirama gave him multiple chances, but he never accepted them.
Izuna died because of madara's selfish desire to kill Senju.

Madara could've prevented Izuna's death by making peace with Senju, but he chose to fight, and he payed the price.
Whereas Itachi prevented the war and his brother's death, which was inevitable because he was an Uchiha and would get killed.
gg

Itachi all the way no doubt

Remember it was Izuna who persuaded him Madara really wanted peace. Although everyone betrayed him in his clan and he could have killed all of them but he didn't because Izuna wanted him to protect the uchiha. I love Itachi but I guess in reality Madara was a a
better brother.

 

[ShiroT]

itachi tortured sasuke so he would come back to kill him and be the hero

madara watch all his brothers die because he wasnt strong enough to save them

Its kinda iffy

 

[ShiroT]

Remember it was Izuna who persuaded him Madara really wanted peace. Although everyone betrayed him in his clan and he could have killed all of them but he didn't because Izuna wanted him to protect the uchiha. I love Itachi but I guess in reality Madara was a a
better brother.

izuna was killed because madara didnt want peace. he then blames tobirama for izuna