Better brother,Itachi or Madara

[ShiroT]

They were at war with senju. Madara's resolve for protecting his brothers never wavered in spite of that.

no. senju tried to make peace and madara fought them again thus getting izuna killed

 

[ShiroT]

Ok well when your brother kills your family, let me know if you consider him a better brother.

when i find out that my clan was going to get the lea destroyed and the leaf told my brother to kill everyone instead im going to have a different opinion.

your still not understand that madara has no brothers to consider him good or bad. you can call itachi a bad brother but madara has no brother. madara is not a brother anymore because all of them are dead.

if you had to choose between being dead or itachi's brother who is free to not persue the path of hatred, that is totally up to you

 

[shelke]

no. senju tried to make peace and madara fought them again thus getting izuna killed

What the ... ****?

 

[Lightbringer]

no. senju tried to make peace and madara fought them again thus getting izuna killed

Madara wasn't the leader of his clan until he became an adult. Until then, he fought against the senju and saw countless of his comrades die.

Do you realize how hard it would be to make peace with that? If I saw my best-friends die, I would never forgive any enemy for that.

 

[Lightbringer]

when i find out that my clan was going to get the lea destroyed and the leaf told my brother to kill everyone instead im going to have a different opinion

I smell bullshit.

 

[BLAZE]

I smell bullshit.

u r not the only one

 

[ShiroT]

I smell bullshit.

no. im not some hate filled little toddler who is going to waste his life trying to track down his brother, if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. my whole life isnt going to be based off my brother

 

[lucario14]

no. senju tried to make peace and madara fought them again thus getting izuna killed

He got killed after however Izuna received a wound that eventually killed him before they tried to make peace. They were still at war with each other.

 

[lucario14]

no. im not some hate filled little toddler who is going to waste his life trying to track down his brother, if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. my whole life isnt going to be based off my brother

Yea if that brother kills your entire family then tortures you straight after, you're not gonna bother with him?

 

[ShiroT]

Madara wasn't the leader of his clan until he became an adult. Until then, he fought against the senju and saw countless of his comrades die.

Do you realize how hard it would be to make peace with that? If I saw my best-friends die, I would never forgive any enemy for that.

thats just you. and i guess your right about the izuna part. the way i see it.

Madara
Pro: Didnt kill his family
Con: has no brothers

Itachi
Pro: Has a brother
Con: Helped kill his family

 

[Lightbringer]

no. im not some hate filled little toddler who is going to waste his life trying to track down his brother, if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. my whole life isnt going to be based off my brother

Ok, but your family is still dead and you are still an orphan.

 

[ShiroT]

Yea if that brother kills your entire family then tortures you straight after, you're not gonna bother with him?

like i said if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. but im not going to say get a truck and hike from new york to florida just to kill my brother, its a waste of time and i could be doing better things with my life. if he was living in new york and i knew this for a fact then again it would be a different story.

 

[ShiroT]

Ok, but your family is still dead and you are still an orphan.

or i could be madara's brother and be dead :|

i know some people who didnt have a family, were an orphan, they have one now and there happy :|

 

[Tennis Robot]

Do you really think that you would ever be absolutely unable to forgive someone for something?

 

[Lightbringer]

thats just you. and i guess your right about the izuna part. the way i see it.

Madara
Pro: Didnt kill his family
Con: has no brothers

Itachi
Pro: Has a brother
Con: Helped kill his family

"If that's just me" then you must not have good friends that you would easily turn the cheek when they die.

Your argument is flawed because Sasuke a main character and Izuna is not, so Sasuke is bound to survive till the end of the manga. Itachi was not there to protect Sasuke all of his life, so you can't say that because he did what he did is the sole cause of his survival.

Sasuke had so many death blows and survived because of some miracle. He had his entire chest blown off by Killer Bee and was revived by Juugo. It has nothing to do with Itachi.

Living is not a guarantee when you're a shinobi.


All I know is that I don't want my family killed and being tortured by my brother.

 

[BLAZE]

no. im not some hate filled little toddler who is going to waste his life trying to track down his brother, if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. my whole life isnt going to be based off my brother

Damn u sound like biased Itachi fapboy tbh
not saying u r one though

 

[Conspirator.]

"If that's just me" then you must not have good friends to easily turn the cheek when they die.

Your argument is flawed because Sasuke a main character and Izuna is not, so Sasuke is bound to survive till the end of the manga. Itachi was not there to protect Sasuke all of his life, so you can't say that because he did what he did is the sole cause of his survival.

Sasuke had so many death blows and survived because of some miracle. He had his entire chest blown off by Killer Bee and was revived by Juugo. It has nothing to do with Itachi.

Living is not a guarantee when you're a shinobi.


All I know is that I don't want my family killed and being tortured by my brother.

This is very true. Hell, he could have died in the Land of Waves arc if not for haku's kindness.

 

[ShiroT]

"If that's just me" then you must not have good friends that you would easily turn the cheek when they die.

Your argument is flawed because Sasuke a main character and Izuna is not, so Sasuke is bound to survive till the end of the manga. Itachi was not there to protect Sasuke all of his life, so you can't say that because he did what he did is the sole cause of his survival.

Sasuke had so many death blows and survived because of some miracle. He had his entire chest blown off by Killer Bee and was revived by Juugo. It has nothing to do with Itachi.

Living is not a guarantee when you're a shinobi.


All I know is that I don't want my family killed and being tortured by my brother.

had sasuke not dedicated his life to killing itachi, he wouldnt have to fight killer bee etc.

its fine if you'd rather be madara's dead brother im cool with that. :|

 

[ShiroT]

Damn u sound like biased Itachi fapboy tbh
not saying u r one though

no im saying life goes own, you make new friends, enjoy new things, maybe find a new family.

be madara's brother and you'd be dead. if you think thats the better option for you then im totally fine with tht

 

[lucario14]

like i said if i happen to see him then i happen to see him. but im not going to say get a truck and hike from new york to florida just to kill my brother, its a waste of time and i could be doing better things with my life. if he was living in new york and i knew this for a fact then again it would be a different story.

You could just fly...I see. No wonder you have a negative opinion on sasuke judging from that avatar of yours. I wouldn't be at ease knowing that my family's murderer was out roaming the streets and I knew where he was. I wouldn't kill him but putting him behind bars is the next best thing. For ninjas, the appropriate action would be to kill since it's what happens on a daily.