You might consider crying when Tobi's mask comes off lol.
.Let's clear a few things up here.
First of all, I'm not the one assuming Tobi is Izuna, you are. I'm just explaining why he may not be dead. But since you wanna go here, I'll go here.
Dude, get real. Honestly answer this: would you even have made this thread if not for the question of Tobi's ID? I think we both know what you're discussing, so no need to play dumb.
For your first question, possibly because he couldn't. Rinne Tensei taxes stress on the user and possibly death, perhaps Izuna couldn't handle a Rinnegan in his weakened state after having lost his eyes which is why he sought out Nagata; an Uzumaki with vitality to be raised his whole life with the eyes.
Well, there are all kinds of possibilities. But even then there are some problems with what you're saying.
According to you're theory, Izuna might be alive because Madara used Rinne Tensei to revive him. There is no proof that this tech would bring Izuna back in the state he was just before he died. Otherwise, Kakashi would have been bleeding when he was revived in the Pain arc. But this was NOT the case with him or anyone else brought back. They were as good as new, w/o any sign of being in the same physical condition they were in just before they died.
Bolded^, correction: Madara knew Nagato, Izuna or whoever might be Tobi did'nt seek out sh!t, keeping Nagato in the picture was Madara's plan all along.
This then brings up the question, how can Izuna use Madara->Nagato's Rinnegan now? Possibly because of Senju DNA which we know Tobi possesses (he may have acquired it after his revival) and which would increase his ability to use Rinnegan.
Exactly. But then if you suppose that, please explain how in the world Izuna came across this DNA after the 2nd shinobi world war, when most of the Senju became MIA(its a mystery what happened to them).
Izuna didn't develop S/T, it's Obito's eye, presumably with Obito's latent power.
This is the most damaging possible statement to your position.
Why in the world did Izuna want a random half dead kid's 2 tomoe sharingan, and not another more skilled Uchihas? This simply makes no sense at all.
We've never seen whether Tobi has MS or not, it's still unconfirmed. Plus it wouldn't even matter if you believe Tobi is Izuna, since he possesses Obito's eye and Madara's Rinnegan, we wouldn't see his original MS pattern anyway.
What are the odds that EVERY time his eyes have been shown they have only been in the tomoed state, even when he took control of the Kyuubi. Again you're climbing on a thin rope here with this Izuna might be alive/Tobi stuff. ANd the question i ask you is why did'nt Izuna have his eyes when revived by Rinne Tensei? And in the fight against Konan his other eye was revealed, it was still just a regular sharingan in apperance, nothing like Izuna's Mangekyuo.
Newsflash! Rinne Tensei is different than Edo Tensei. While Edo Tensei revives one IN HIS/HER PRIME, Rinne Tensei revives one in HIS/HER ORIGINAL BODY. Izuna presumably died eyeless, which is why he was revived without his eyes and hence, his MS.
That's what i've been trying to tell you. It is different. It does'nt make you a zombie, but there is no proof that Izuna if he were revived would'nt have his eyes.
Another fail on your part. What exactly do you mean by 'original body'? But never mind, explain why Kakashi had his ORIGINAL BODY revived in a perfectly fit condition,
with all the damage done to it repaired, yet in Izuna's case the damage of losing the eyes is not repaired?
And again, you don't know if Tobi can or can't use MS.
No, but it is far more likely that he cannot than he can. That's like saying a Senju could have awoken the sharingan since Senju and Uchiha are related, but obviously its unlikely.
