Why I can never forgive Itachi
- Thread starter Uchihajin Sasuke
- Start date
Itachi is a good character. I don't wish to talk about Itachi's role in Uchiha murder. His reasons can be justified.
However I would like to say the way he treated Sasuke after the murder doesn't seem good to me. Itachi's way of making Sasuke stronger was wrong, I . He made Sasuke feel weak. He goaded Sasuke into seeking strength. He taught Sasuke to hate.
He used doujutsu twice on Sasuke. Wasn't it kind of torture? Why did Itachi think that was the way to make Sasuke strong so that he himself can die at his hands?
Sasuke would have sought revenge no matter when he came to know who the culprit was. I agree. But that is not the point.
Itachi made Sasuke's life more miserable, a kid whose life was already miserable. Really, you save your kid brother from possible death, because you love him dearly. His entire family is butchered. You show him how they were killed by no one other than yourself. You tell him he is worthless, weak and blah blah. Psychologically how would this affect a kid? No doubt he became so obsessed with revenge because of this.
Itachi is one of my favorites. So is Sasuke. So is Naruto. I hope it would be a happy ending for the manga with Sasuke and Naruto becoming brothers.
Peace and harmony my motto.
However I would like to say the way he treated Sasuke after the murder doesn't seem good to me. Itachi's way of making Sasuke stronger was wrong, I . He made Sasuke feel weak. He goaded Sasuke into seeking strength. He taught Sasuke to hate.
He used doujutsu twice on Sasuke. Wasn't it kind of torture? Why did Itachi think that was the way to make Sasuke strong so that he himself can die at his hands?
Sasuke would have sought revenge no matter when he came to know who the culprit was. I agree. But that is not the point.
Itachi made Sasuke's life more miserable, a kid whose life was already miserable. Really, you save your kid brother from possible death, because you love him dearly. His entire family is butchered. You show him how they were killed by no one other than yourself. You tell him he is worthless, weak and blah blah. Psychologically how would this affect a kid? No doubt he became so obsessed with revenge because of this.
Itachi is one of my favorites. So is Sasuke. So is Naruto. I hope it would be a happy ending for the manga with Sasuke and Naruto becoming brothers.
Peace and harmony my motto.
Last edited:
Cassiopeia
Active member
resurrection
Member
It depends on from what perspective u do analyze Itachi's deed.
You have to probe ur understanding deep enough to realize Itachi's deed. From naked eye Itachi's deed was a horrible crime. But if u see the true meaning behind his action, then u may forgive him.
It's just like how US destroyed Hiroshima and Nagashaki during 2nd world II. Did/do we hate US for this? Did/Do we forgive US? Some forgive and some not. And even today, nobody blamed US for using nuclear weapon against human coz it did really stop the 2nd world II.
In crude sense, Itachi did a horrible crime, but I assume Itachi did a very delicate job which is rather unfamiliar with our beliefs and which needs lots of courage, maturity, understanding, knowledge, and sacrifice. If u see the Itachi's job from manga's perspective, u might forgive Itachi.
You have to probe ur understanding deep enough to realize Itachi's deed. From naked eye Itachi's deed was a horrible crime. But if u see the true meaning behind his action, then u may forgive him.
It's just like how US destroyed Hiroshima and Nagashaki during 2nd world II. Did/do we hate US for this? Did/Do we forgive US? Some forgive and some not. And even today, nobody blamed US for using nuclear weapon against human coz it did really stop the 2nd world II.
In crude sense, Itachi did a horrible crime, but I assume Itachi did a very delicate job which is rather unfamiliar with our beliefs and which needs lots of courage, maturity, understanding, knowledge, and sacrifice. If u see the Itachi's job from manga's perspective, u might forgive Itachi.
Sasuno Tsawaki
Member
Sasuno Tsawaki
Member
Sophie Ezra
Active member
Awards
Wrong
its acutally not completely Itachi's fault if Tobi had not told sasuke the truth sasuke would have been none the wiser what happened just hapaned its apart of the story. Itachi is a great Char
you make a very good point i agree with you + Rep
Last edited:
Sasuno Tsawaki
Member
He planned it all along and if he didnt do it sasuke would be killed
You must be registered for see links
Sasuno Tsawaki
Member
Hattake Ryuzaki
Active member
Itachi is a HERO to Konoha no matter how u look at it... i just wish Sasuke would have realized this
Uchihajin Sasuke
Active member
Ask that to Kishi, I think he did it for the sake of the plot.
If I were Sasuke, instead of shifting the blame on Konoha and the new generation that has nothing do do with the massacre, I would just kill the elders and tobi, and put the rest of the blame on Itachi because he could have just declined the mission in the first place.
And ANBU eliminating the Uchiha is practically impossible because Uchiha is the strongest clan in the village, so coming up with that justification is ridiculous.
But he is a murderer to the Uchiha and his family - you need to look from my side of the view my friend :drive:
I doubt even in Sasuke's viewpoint, he would not be considered "hero". More like anti-villain/anti-hero.
Minato, Jiraiya, Sandaime, Naruto are the real heroes of the village.
Last edited:
Uchiha0023
Member
I agree 100% cause if Sasuke would have been killed that night, then Naruto would have never had the friendship bond with him.
Also Naruto wouldn't have trained so hard to bring Sasuke back, and that might have lead to him being captured by the Akatsuki and would have been killed once the nine tails had been extracted.
Apparently everything that happened in Naruto and Shippuden has happened for a reason.
Uchihajin Sasuke
Active member
I don't think that was stated in the manga. Even with the ANBU attacking the Uchiha really happened (I don't think it will because it will go to a full fledged war and that will expose the leaf villages dirty secrets around the shinobi world), with guys like Itachi and Shisui, and the rest of the Elite Uchihas, I don't think they would have been fully massacred like what really happened in the story.
Also the war braking out after the coup is also a ridiculous justification because Orochimaru and Sand village did a massive surprise attack on the leaf, and did the other villages join the war to exploit the weakened leaf? No!
Danzo just manipulated Itachi with these baseless speculations...
This thread has reached a conclusion.
