Why do some people think that Uchiha bodies couldn't handle bijuus?

[Your Creepy Stalker]

I don't see why they couldn't be even with weak bodys. Obito, Madara and Sasuke have all pwned Bijuu with Genjutsu.

 

[The Necromancer]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

 

[AlphaScythian]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I dont think VIZ states the same with yamato there.
Kushina had special chakra, according to VIZ not strong.
Younger son was a lie, he was spoon fed, older inherited it all.

 

[BLAZE]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Scans so it did happen huh

I dont think VIZ states the same with yamato there.
Kushina had special chakra, according to VIZ not strong.
Younger son was a lie, he was spoon fed, older inherited it all.

Uchihas are said to have unparallaled chakra though
lol on Ashura's comment.So6p clearly stated he gave him power XD

 

[chaos control]

Because it's known that only a selected few with a strong enough body can do it and Uchihas aren't known to have strong bodies. No random person became a Jinchuuriki, they did tests where the Jinchuuriki couldn't handle the Bijuu such as the one who came before Bee and he even said his brother and father couldn't contain the 8 tails

You must be registered for see links

. Having strong chakra doesn't mean their body can contain Bijuus. Also not every Uchiha even had Sharingans, Sasuke said only a selected Uchihas could awaken it so it's different than the Uchihas who all had Sharingans in the time of war that Madara grew up in.


It's not that not any Uchiha could become a Jinchuuki, it's more that only a very selected few can become Jins and only Senjus and Uzumaki's are known to have strong bodies. Uchihas get the eyes to control Bijuus while Senju's/Uzumaki's have the body to contain them.

Bold: This statement just means that strong bodies aren't Uchihas' claim to fame. That doesn't mean that they have weak bodies and can't handle bijuus.

Your logic is like saying: Joe is not world famous for baking great cookies. Therefore Joe can not bake great cookies just because he is not famous for it.

In case you don't get the analogy:

It is true that the Senju/Uzumaki clans are known for their strong bodies.

It is true that strong bodies aren't the Uchiha claim to fame. That does not mean that they can't have them.

Also, how do you know an Uchiha wouldn't pass the same test that Bee did? You say that those other jinchuuriki weren't just random people, but they were just random people before they took the test. It wasn't until after they were tested that their bodies were known to be strong enough.

 

[TrollingSage]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

"Special chakra that was suited to suppressing the nine tails". It's not just having "special chakra". It has to be compatible with the biju

 

[shelke]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Damn, beat me to it with that Kushina scan. No where in the manga is it stated that Uzumakis were ideal jins. Literally no where. Kushina was an exception out of her own clan.

 

[shelke]

I wasn't talking about Hashirama. I meant this guy

You must be registered for see images

Also it's not just about life force and chakra levels. There's also the issue of compatibility. Thats why eventhough the leaf was full of senjus, they had to go all the way to The Uzumaki clan for jinchuriki

This is a scan that proves it took this many people to beat him? Lol This guy! I don't even.

 

[-Spoiler-]

Obito and Madara had Senju DNA but lets casually forget that.

 

[BLAZE]

Damn, beat me to it with that Kushina scan. No where in the manga is it stated that Uzumakis were ideal jins. Literally no where. Kushina was an exception out of her own clan.

Now when u r saying dat i gues all those thing r fanfic BS sprouted by bunch of half @$$ed theories

 

[chaos control]

Tell yourself whatever you want to, I would be the last person to do that kind of shit. It was literally the first thing I thought when I saw the title of your thread. I'll give you one last hint though (since I'm getting impatient/disappointed), and if this doesn't completely give it away then I won't be giving you the answer until tomorrow. You are only thinking about "on paper" requirements.

1. You gave no hints to begin with.
2. "On paper requirements" are better than the nothing you are giving.
3. You have not stated one manga- supported fact.
4. You still haven't stated one thing that the manga has canonically stated the Uchihas to lack that apparently Gaara and other people not related to Hagoromo have.

 

[TrollingSage]

Damn, beat me to it with that Kushina scan. No where in the manga is it stated that Uzumakis were ideal jins. Literally no where. Kushina was an exception out of her own clan.

So was Mito Uzumaki and later Naruto Uzumaki

 

[Tennis Robot]

1. You gave no hints to begin with.
2. "On paper requirements" are better than the nothing you are giving.
3. You have not stated one manga- supported fact.
4. You still haven't stated one thing that the manga has canonically stated the Uchihas to lack that apparently Gaara and other people not related to Hagoromo have.

I told you how to get to the answer. Don't blame me for your lack of deductive reasoning skill. It has nothing to do with chakra. I'm not saying that the Uchiha are physically unfit to be jinchuriki (though it is entirely possible), I'm saying that there is a very good reason why they were never chosen.

 

[The Necromancer]

"Special chakra that was suited to suppressing the nine tails". It's not just having "special chakra". It has to be compatible with the biju

You're right. But you really think none of the uchiha could ever have such a chakra? They had more powerful and evil chakra than the Kyuubi itself.

Anyone can be born with chakra that can suppress a bijuu. Uchiha are no exception.

 

[FleeOnSight]

I don't want to go scour multiple chapters for you.

Yamato stated Naruto's ability to handle such a powerful chakra was because of his own powerful chakra.

Kushina stated she was chosen to be the Jinchurki because of her special chakra.

Scans or it didn't happen.

 

[AlphaScythian]

Obito and Madara had Senju DNA but lets casually forget that.

Obito had some IT fodder DNA to be correct. Still became juubi jin and you speak as if senju DNA is all there is to be juubi jin U_U

 

[The Necromancer]

Scans or it didn't happen.

Reading is a valuable skill.

 

[Migster257]

So uchiha's can't handle a bijuu yet a newborn uzumaki baby can? Seems legit

That's because of the most powerful tech to ever exist. Plot.

 

[chaos control]

I told you how to get to the answer. Don't blame me for your lack of deductive reasoning. It has nothing to do with suitability. I'm not saying that the Uchiha are physically unfit to be jinchuriki (though it is entirely possible), I'm saying that there is a very good reason why they were never chosen.

Well then Mr. Genius, you missed the entire point of the thread! The title of the thread is: Why do some people think Uchiha bodies couldn't handle bijuus? Emphasis on the word bodies! If you were thinking something along the lines of why did the village never choose them, then that is a whole different topic! Stay on the topic of the thread before you go acting all self-righteous and stuck up. Did I ask why the village didn't choose them? No I did not! If you want to go that route, then why was the Sarutobi clan not chosen to have a jinchuuriki? Why not the Aburame? Why not the Hyuuga? This could go on and on.

If you actually look at some posts of people, you will see that some people think that Uchihas are actually physically unfit to be jinchuurikis. That is the issue that the thread is addressing! Now stay on topic.

 

[-Spoiler-]

Obito had some IT fodder DNA to be correct. Still became juubi jin and you speak as if senju DNA is all there is to be juubi jin U_U

Obito's DNA came from Hashirama's Living Clone