Why do some people think that Uchiha bodies couldn't handle bijuus?

[BLAZE]

So uchiha's can't handle a bijuu yet a newborn uzumaki baby can? Seems legit

Are you trying to tell me a baby has more life force than an adult uchiha?

If so... Get the hell out.

both comments were :xylon:

 

[Tennis Robot]

Oh well, I guess it isn't obvious.....Think about what you know about jinchuriki and what you know about the Uchiha Clan. There is a very clear reason why the two can never intermix.

 

[TrollKing]

Oh well, I guess it isn't obvious.....Think about what you know about jinchuriki and what you know about the Uchiha Clan. There is a very clear reason why the two can never intermix.

It's simple because senju and uchiha don't like one another

 

[Clouds]

How many Uchiha adults did it take to kill that Senju child prodigy?

Hashirama was like 14 years old or something That's a huge difference with a newborn baby

 

[TrollKing]

How many Uchiha adults did it take to kill that Senju child prodigy?

Naruto is opposite to a prodigy

 

[AllseeingSharingan]

It's foolish to think uchiha cannot become jinchuriki regardless of its kuruma or not. Madara never chose to be a jinchuriki because of one weakness. When extracted you die, now why would he put it in his body when he can simply control it with his dojutsu.

But Thats not the point, also it's foolish to think only uzumaki can be jinchuriki of kyuubi when Ginkaku n Kinkaku and minato fully were jinchuriki for the kyuubi aswell. The uchiha can easily be jinchuriki .

 

[FleeOnSight]

There have been multiple times where it is said that one became a jinchuriki because they had powerful or special chakra. Uchiha have powerful chakra inherently.

Scans or it didn't happen

 

[TrollingSage]

Hashirama was like 14 years old or something That's a huge difference with a newborn baby

I wasn't talking about Hashirama. I meant this guy

You must be registered for see images

Also it's not just about life force and chakra levels. There's also the issue of compatibility. Thats why eventhough the leaf was full of senjus, they had to go all the way to The Uzumaki clan for jinchuriki

 

[Sage Moonblood]

They can handle 1-7 Maybe 8 but I highly doubt they can become the nine tails jinchuriki

 

[chaos control]

Obito and Madara had Hashirama's DNA. It's also about more than just strong chakra. If you think about it for a minute, you'll realize why Uchiha can never be jinchuriki. It should be pretty obvious. Like, glaringly obvious...

No it is not. It was never said that Uchihas had weak bodies or vitality. It is just not their specialty like it is with Senjus and Uzumakis. Once again, Gaara, Bee, Yugito and other non-clan shinobi were able to handle bijuus. What do they have that an Uchiha doesn't.

One misconception:

1. Naruto is half uzumaki

2. Naruto didn't inherit his parents good genes

3. Naruto large chakra pool is due to nine tails

2. Actually, Naruto did inherit Kushina's good genes in part. His Uzumaki genes are the reason why Naruto didn't die immediately after yang Kurama's extraction like other jinchuurikis do. His vitality just isn't as good as Kushina's who was still conscious. However, it is still better than Gaara's and other jinchuurikis who died immediately.

3. Kurama is only in part responsible for Naruto's large chakara pool. You can't forget Ashura and you can't forget Kakashi's statement that without Kurama's influence, Naruto still has about 4 times Kakashi's chakara.

 

[Tennis Robot]

Ok you guys have to be trolling. I'm going to let this one marinate for a bit. I still have faith. I gave you guys a huge clue. Use it.

 

[Clouds]

I wasn't talking about Hashirama. I meant this guy

You must be registered for see images

Also it's not just about life force and chakra levels. There's also the issue of compatibility. Thats why eventhough the leaf was full of senjus, they had to go all the way to The Uzumaki clan for jinchuriki

everyone have more life force and chakra than a baby

And has it been said that only uzumaki or senju's Are compatible?

 

[Tera Path]

Most people could be a jinchuuriki.

Only times it's been a problem is with the 8 or 9 tails, because... well... they're more powerful.

 

[TrollingSage]

everyone have more life force and chakra than a baby

And has it been said that only uzumaki or senju's Are compatible?

Nope. Depends on the individual. That's why even people who arent related to the sage like Gaara and Bee can become jinchurikis.

 

[AlphaScythian]

Its a myth senju/uzumaki fans created long ago and it left to live cuz no one cared.
Thou uchiha fans stated that both madara and obito wouldnt plan on host a juubi if uchiha couldnt U_U

 

[The Necromancer]

Scans or it didn't happen

I don't want to go scour multiple chapters for you.

Yamato stated Naruto's ability to handle such a powerful chakra was because of his own powerful chakra.

Kushina stated she was chosen to be the Jinchurki because of her special chakra.

 

[chaos control]

Ok you guys have to be trolling. I'm going to let this one marinate for a bit. I still have faith. I gave you guys a huge clue. Use it.

It has been my experience to see that people generally only use that "It's so obvious" card when they don't really have an answer. Seriously think about this:

Requirements to be a jinchuuriki:

1. Strong enough body/vitality
2. Chakara that is powerful enough to suppress the bijuu
3. Large enough chakara reserve.

When has the Uchiha clan proven to just lack these traits? Remember, Itachi was sick (so don't use him as an example).

Also remember this: The Senju and Uzumaki were simply the ones known for their strong bodies and vitalities. It was their claim to fame. Just because another clan has a different claim to fame (such as the Uchiha) doesn't mean that they are weak in the area of vitality/body strength.

 

[xxSAGExx]

Because it's known that only a selected few with a strong enough body can do it and Uchihas aren't known to have strong bodies. No random person became a Jinchuuriki, they did tests where the Jinchuuriki couldn't handle the Bijuu such as the one who came before Bee and he even said his brother and father couldn't contain the 8 tails

You must be registered for see links

. Having strong chakra doesn't mean their body can contain Bijuus. Also not every Uchiha even had Sharingans, Sasuke said only a selected Uchihas could awaken it so it's different than the Uchihas who all had Sharingans in the time of war that Madara grew up in.

It's not that not any Uchiha could become a Jinchuuki, it's more that only a very selected few can become Jins and only Senjus and Uzumaki's are known to have strong bodies. Uchihas get the eyes to control Bijuus while Senju's/Uzumaki's have the body to contain them.

 

[AlphaScythian]

I don't want to go scour multiple chapters for you.

Yamato stated Naruto's ability to handle such a powerful chakra was because of his own powerful chakra.

Kushina stated she was chosen to be the Jinchurki because of her special chakra.

Where????What????

Because it's known that only a selected few with a strong enough body can do it and Uchihas aren't known to have strong bodies. No random person became a Jinchuuriki, they did tests where the Jinchuuriki couldn't handle the Bijuu such as the one who came before Bee and he even said his brother and father couldn't contain the 8 tails

You must be registered for see links

. Having strong chakra doesn't mean their body can contain Bijuus. Also not every Uchiha even had Sharingans, Sasuke said only a selected Uchihas could awaken it so it's different than the Uchihas who all had Sharingans in the time of war that Madara grew up in.

It's not that not any Uchiha could become a Jinchuuki, it's more that only a very selected few can become Jins and only Senjus and Uzumaki's are known to have strong bodies. Uchihas get the eyes to control Bijuus while Senju's/Uzumaki's have the body to contain them.

Bullshit.

Obito is uchiha and has some zetsu goo as part of his DNA which is probably from some IT fodder and he can be juubi jin let alone single biju. So could madara.

The strong body of younger son was a lie. The son was fodder until sage gave him power.
Indra thus elder bro had it all.

 

[Tennis Robot]

It has been my experience to see that people generally only use that "It's so obvious" card when they don't really have an answer. Seriously think about this:

Requirements to be a jinchuuriki:

1. Strong enough body/vitality
2. Chakara that is powerful enough to suppress the bijuu
3. Large enough chakara reserve.

When has the Uchiha clan proven to just lack these traits? Remember, Itachi was sick (so don't use him as an example).

Also remember this: The Senju and Uzumaki were simply the ones known for their strong bodies and vitalities. It was their claim to fame. Just because another clan has a different claim to fame (such as the Uchiha) doesn't mean that they are weak in the area of vitality/body strength.

Tell yourself whatever you want to, I would be the last person to do that kind of shit. It was literally the first thing I thought when I saw the title of your thread. I'll give you one last hint though (since I'm getting impatient/disappointed), and if this doesn't completely give it away then I won't be giving you the answer until tomorrow. You are only thinking about "on paper" requirements.