Why do some people think that Uchiha bodies couldn't handle bijuus?

[Migster257]

1. You gave no hints to begin with.
2. "On paper requirements" are better than the nothing you are giving.
3. You have not stated one manga- supported fact.
4. You still haven't stated one thing that the manga has canonically stated the Uchihas to lack that apparently Gaara and other people not related to Hagoromo have.

Not to disagree with you or anything, but there are things Uchiha don't have. Uzumaki lineage. Gaara's lineage. Bee's lineage. Namikaze lineage.

 

[AlphaScythian]

Obito's DNA came from Hashirama's Living Clone

Is what madara said, but BZ said its IT victim U_U

 

[The Necromancer]

Not to disagree with you or anything, but there are things Uchiha don't have. Uzumaki lineage. Gaara's lineage. Bee's lineage. Namikaze lineage.

So Bee's, Gaara's, and Minato's family can handle Bijuu despite not being of the clan given the Sage's powerful body, but the Uchiha can't because they were not given the Sage's powerful body...?

Hypocritical...?

 

[xxSAGExx]

Bold: This statement just means that strong bodies aren't Uchihas' claim to fame. That doesn't mean that they have weak bodies and can't handle bijuus.

Your logic is like saying: Joe is not world famous for baking great cookies. Therefore Joe can not bake great cookies just because he is not famous for it.

In case you don't get the analogy:

It is true that the Senju/Uzumaki clans are known for their strong bodies.

It is true that strong bodies aren't the Uchiha claim to fame. That does not mean that they can't have them.

Also, how do you know an Uchiha wouldn't pass the same test that Bee did? You say that those other jinchuuriki weren't just random people, but they were just random people before they took the test. It wasn't until after they were tested that their bodies were known to be strong enough.

Reread my post, I said no random person as in they didn't go out and pick a random person off the street and make then a Jinchuuriki that can withstand a Bijuu. They did test to those they suspect could handle it and when it failed they kept trying until they found the right host. Me bringing up the Uchihas not being known for having strong bodies like Senjus only means that they would be like normal people where they'll have to test if they can handle the Bijuus and when fail they'll die until someone who can handle it become it. Sure an Uchiha might be able to become a Juubi Jin but many would die until they find the right one(s).

Where????What????

Bullshit.

Obito is uchiha and has some zetsu goo as part of his DNA which is probably from some IT fodder and he can be juubi jin let alone single biju. So could madara.

The strong body of younger son was a lie. The son was fodder until sage gave him power.
Indra thus elder bro had it all.

Zetsus all had Hashirama's DNA, Madara didn't use people to make Zetsus, Hashirama's DNA grew them. That's why Hashirama and Tobirama both said Orochimaru white Zetsu body was made up of Hashirama's cells. Obito and Madara had Hashirama's DNA in their bodies. Read what I said above for rest. Also Hagaromo said Ashura's chakra bloomed so you are incorrect since that was before getting any power from Hagaromo.

 

[Tennis Robot]

Well then Mr. Genius, you missed the entire point of the thread! The title of the thread is: Why do some people think Uchiha bodies couldn't handle bijuus? Emphasis on the word bodies! If you were thinking something along the lines of why did the village never choose them, then that is a whole different topic! Stay on the topic of the thread before you go acting all self-righteous and stuck up. Did I ask why the village didn't choose them? No I did not! If you want to go that route, then why was the Sarutobi clan not chosen to have a jinchuuriki? Why not the Aburame? Why not the Hyuuga? This could go on and on.

If you actually look at some posts of people, you will see that some people think that Uchihas are actually physically unfit to be jinchuurikis. That is the issue that the thread is addressing! Now stay on topic.

I misspoke. It is a problem with their bodies (technically). There is something that the Uchiha lack.

 

[The Necromancer]

I misspoke. It is a problem with their bodies (technically). There is something that the Uchiha lack.

Tell me what the Uchiha lack that random fodder clans with no relation to Hagoromo have.

 

[Migster257]

So Bee's, Gaara's, and Minato's family can handle Bijuu despite not being of the clan given the Sage's powerful body, but the Uchiha can't because they were not given the Sage's powerful body...?

Hypocritical...?

How am I a hypocrite lol? I just pointed out things that Uchiha don't have. It's not necessarily the reason for them not being a good candidate for a Jin.

 

[new sage of 6 paths]

If Madara could handle it against his fight with hashirama, wiuldnt he have sealed it in himself...its much more convernient and versatile...buh he chose to control it
Many Naruto haters in this thread, Logic is absent in this thread.

 

[LustyLover]

If the Uchiha couldn't house Bijuu because they didn't have Uzumaki bodies then how did Gaara and all the other non-Uzumaki lineage individuals manage to? Anyone care to enlighten me? There might be a reason, just not one I have come across.

 

[Migster257]

If the Uchiha couldn't house Bijuu because they didn't have Uzumaki bodies then how did Gaara and all the other non-Uzumaki lineage individuals manage to? Anyone care to enlighten me? There might be a reason, just not one I have come across.

Well, there's one. Two as a matter or fact. Kishi's inconsistencies and plot.

 

[shelke]

Now when u r saying dat i gues all those thing r fanfic BS sprouted by bunch of half @$$ed theories

Naruto fans are known to create yarns. If that is anything new. Kushina herself admits that she was someone special out of her own clan; an exception. That's all I need to know.

 

[The Necromancer]

If Madara could handle it against his fight with hashirama, wiuldnt he have sealed it in himself...its much more convernient and versatile...buh he chose to control it
Many Naruto haters in this thread, Logic is absent in this thread.

Without training at the Falls of Truth, all the Kyuubi would give Madara is more chakra, which would be absolutely useless in his fight. Try again.

 

[chaos control]

I misspoke. It is a problem with their bodies (technically). There is something that the Uchiha lack.

Something that the Uchiha lack, that apparently Gaara and Yugito and other random shinobi have?

Keeping this in mind:

1. Kaguya is the juubi.
2. Uchihas are direct descendants of Kaguya.
3. Uchihas are therefore direct descendants of the juubi.

Yet some random shinobi's body is more likely to be suitable for a bijuu?

 

[AlphaScythian]

Zetsus all had Hashirama's DNA, Madara didn't use people to make Zetsus, Hashirama's DNA grew them. That's why Hashirama and Tobirama both said Orochimaru white Zetsu body was made up of Hashirama's cells. Obito and Madara had Hashirama's DNA in their bodies. Read what I said above for rest. Also Hagaromo said Ashura's chakra bloomed so you are incorrect since that was before getting any power from Hagaromo.

Zetsus are prior IT victims that came off gedo. It just so happens that they and hashi share mokuton. Stilll zetsu is much degraded to be of a factor in Obito becoming juubi jin so main reason is him bing uchiha.


Bloomed into what?, Bloomed enough? Bloomed after his power up maybe?
Yea sage also said that the power came from people(help) and then he gave him some more power and then sons killed each other. Fodder it is U_U

 

[Tennis Robot]

Something that the Uchiha lack, that apparently Gaara and Yugito and other random shinobi have?

Keeping this in mind:

1. Kaguya is the juubi.
2. Uchihas are direct descendants of Kaguya.
3. Uchihas are therefore direct descendants of the juubi.

Yet some random shinobi's body is more likely to be suitable for a bijuu?

You're still thinking about it the wrong way.

 

[TrollingSage]

Without training at the Falls of Truth, all the Kyuubi would give Madara is more chakra, which would be absolutely useless in his fight. Try again.

Not so sure. He got done in by Hashirama's clone trick because he had to turn off his sharingan to conserve chakra. Just saying.

 

[LustyLover]

Well, there's one. Two as a matter or fact. Kishi's inconsistencies and plot.

I suppose. However, I recall the manga stating that Uzumaki bodies were preferable but not absolutely necessary. So I fail to see why Uchiha cannot host Bijuu.

 

[Zavage10]

Once again rin was the three tails jin and she was fodder as ****. OFC they can.

 

[AlphaScythian]

Not so sure. He got done in by Hashirama's clone trick because he had to turn off his sharingan to conserve chakra. Just saying.

He wasted some on delayed izanagi before, just saying

 

[-Spoiler-]

Is what madara said, but BZ said its IT victim U_U

BZ is full of shit, Obito was able to use Mokuton none of the other zetsu could use Mokuton except for the one had Yamato (another person with Senju DNA).