And break his promise? Regard both Luffy and Shanks' character. They wouldn't come.
What?
Huh?
Dafuq are you saying? You do know when BB came to capture Luffy, right??????????
What. The. ****.
Last edited:
[Discussion] Who would save luffy?
- Thread starter WhistleBlower
- Start date
Depends on when he was captured, if it was after sabaody, we dont really know when BB would have caught up with him:
- SH crew
- dragon and at least some closest to him in the army
- garp would turn at some point if dragon and luffy were fighting
- shanks
- ace definitely and maybe he would drag WB along
- maybe rayleigh
And thats enough
You might Say some of these would definitely not come but if the government would parade his execution around and shove it down his allies' throats like they did with ace they would surely do something
- SH crew
- dragon and at least some closest to him in the army
- garp would turn at some point if dragon and luffy were fighting
- shanks
- ace definitely and maybe he would drag WB along
- maybe rayleigh
And thats enough
You might Say some of these would definitely not come but if the government would parade his execution around and shove it down his allies' throats like they did with ace they would surely do something
Bobby Brown
Member
they would get destoryed
and leave his years of revo planning for some kid he never gave a shit about
if he didn't for ace, why would he for luffy
nope
And thats enough
You might Say some of these would definitely not come but if the government would parade his execution around and shove it down his allies' throats like they did with ace they would surely do something
Pervy Wrath
Active member
Well, this would've happened prior to Luffy meeting Boa, so you have to count her out.
Only ones I can think of are the ones you mentioned. Maybe, and this is the biggest 'maybe' EVER! Maybe Shanks would do it.
Only ones I can think of are the ones you mentioned. Maybe, and this is the biggest 'maybe' EVER! Maybe Shanks would do it.
I dont think there would be a public execution.
If there is it would be to draw dragon out if they know he is his son.
SO dragon would definetly come. Ivan thought dragon was going to come because Ace was Dragons son. So he would definetly go save luffy.
HOwever, back to my first point I dont think there would be a need to publicly execute them.
If there is it would be to draw dragon out if they know he is his son.
SO dragon would definetly come. Ivan thought dragon was going to come because Ace was Dragons son. So he would definetly go save luffy.
HOwever, back to my first point I dont think there would be a need to publicly execute them.
Dragon, is probably waiting for, Luffy which is why he hasn't made his move.
If you pay attention to the info about him and his army and the things he had done you'll see that, Luffy may be the key to his plans and withought him he would never be able to take the WG down. Luffy, won't ever be caught anyways. It's obvious that, Dragon would try to save, Luffy if he were ever caught.
Professor Finesser
Active member
First of all.... and also the last.
If Luffy was captured, he would never be sentenced to death (let alone a public execution). The most likely destination for him would be Impel down. And Once at Impel down Blackbeard himself would have come to free him, as he needed to get the Level 6 people for his crew either way, so it would just snowball together somehow.
So strawhats + Blackbeard would have saved him.
If Luffy was captured, he would never be sentenced to death (let alone a public execution). The most likely destination for him would be Impel down. And Once at Impel down Blackbeard himself would have come to free him, as he needed to get the Level 6 people for his crew either way, so it would just snowball together somehow.
So strawhats + Blackbeard would have saved him.
Professor Finesser
Active member
No they'd definitely execute the son of Dragon, and I doubt Blackbeard would release the person he put in jail, that's kinda dumb
Thinking they would have him executed is dumb. You don't follow the manga well. Ace was only executed because he was the Pirate kings son. And tell me one other pirate apart from those related to the pirate king that have been publicly executed??
Professor Finesser
Active member
I think the son of the "most wanted man alive" would certainly be executed.
1.) That may be possible, but Dragon didn't seem to care that much when he found out Luffy is a pirate, all he said was: "pirate, that's good." Implying that it's a good thing he didn't choose his fathers (Garp's) way of life. Furthermore, saying Dragon is waiting for Luffy, is putting a generic Shonen theme ("chosen one" etc...) on OP, which Oda has avoided thus far.
2.) Even if they were to go save Luffy, the amount of casualties the Revo's (commanders included) will suffer; will send Dragon's plans of overthrowing the WG miles back.
1.) @B: That could perhaps be true.
2.) The only reason BB wanted to capture Luffy was so he could use him as a bargain chip and become a Warlord. And he only wanted to become a Warlord so he could get access to ID. So he wouldn't go to ID to save Luffy, he'd just recruit L-6 prisoners. So thus he would lose his spot as Warlord. But, even if he did that, he wouldn't become an Emperor. Because he only became an Emperor after he seized WB's territoty, and since Luffy is the one who got capture, WB would still be alive and all BB would be is a normal pirate.
Lol. Akainu, said that he needs to be executed. They would execute him. It's a fact. You're the one that doesn't follow the manga well. Watch the marine ford arc again to enlighten yourself or your info on one piece will be flawed.
@ziggyZ you don't know anything do you?
He saved his son at Logue town for a good reason. He said to smoker that its best to not get in the way of his destiny. That means he knows what, Luffy's destiny is. Everyone knows, Luffy will change the world and cause a war. You think, Dragon is gonna sit back and let, Luffy do the war alone with his friends? You need to pay attention to info that's given. You can't seem to figure it out.
He knows that somehow, Luffy will bring the world to peace and his thoughts on what he would be while doing that was "a pirate? So be it". It had nothing to do with, Garp. He knows that, Luffy inherited, Rogers will and that will is to take down the WG. Whitebeard further explained this right before he died. It's all facts.
Last edited:
oye oye are you serious??
What happened at marineford was a war........ do you know what a war is?? Its that zone where killing is permitted and you don't answer to anyone if you are on the winning list. Akainu did not come to marineford thinking "Yes Monkey D. Luffy will come to save Ace and I will kill him there" or Sengoku did not order the marines "People at Marineford Monkey D. Luffy will come whom we have to kill.".
He was just considered a future threat against the marineforces, so he was just prioritized as a target to kill.
If he was given to the marines by BB the matter would have rested in Sengokus hand, who considering Garp as his partner in such a long time, would have most likely sent him to impel down.
What's your point? I payed attention to every detail of that arc - marineford
They still want to execute him so that means you were incorrect, again what's your point?
Sengoku, is a marine. Kizaru, asked if he could execute, Luffy and the people he brought with him and Sengoku said he could. You're incorrect again.
Just how, Roger was the most wanted man in the world, Dragon is the most wanted. They executed his son and now they want to execute, Dragons son.
Just accept the facts.
Don't forget that it's not up to, Sengoku even if he wanted to send, Luffy to impel down which I proved he doesn't. It's up to the WG. They said that they want him dead. They sent, Kuma to eradicate all of the SH's and when he didn't come back with, Luffy's head, Sengoku got pissed at, Kuma. Sengoku, also told, Garp angrily to his face that if he weren't a hero in the marines he would pay for the sins of his family which basically tells you that, Sengoku doesn't give Damn about, Luffy or, Garps feelings.
Last edited:
Goddamn, how'd ya know? Guess my secret of being incapable of not knowing any nothing as been discovered.
You must be registered for see images
Huh? May you please provide a scan of when he states something about "destiny". 'Cos AFAIK, he said "why stop a man from sailing?"
Well, nooo. If he gets a hold of OP, then a war will erupt, and after the war will he change the world. Not the other way around. No way can it work out like that.
Yes, quite true - because I've never made a thread regarding the "Promised War" nor have I ever reiterated it in other threads
You must be registered for see images
Wait, you're implying that Dragon knew Luffy inherited Roger's will even though he's never communicated with him (because that's the only reason WB ever realized it), and he knew so just by knowing Luffy is his son, correct? Well I can't agree because that seems dyslexic. Furthermore, do you know when abouts in the manga we are discussing over? If not; we are discussing the time just before they ascended on the "knock-up" stream. And I'm pretty sure at that point in the story, neither the WG, nor his father would know of his "destiny", they'd just think of him as someone who has the "ultimate lineage" and a pirate who shares the "D.".
You didn't state any facts and you made no valid points.
You need to read manga that have correct translations. Dragon, said destiny.
Are you senseless? Everyone knows, Luffy inherited, Rogers will. It's not just, Rogers will. It's the will of D.
I don't need to post any scans. This is basic information everyone knows.
Don't make convenient excuses for yourself just because you don't want to accept the fact that you were incorrect.