[Discussion] who the strongest of the supernovas

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
How is Capone a lower level SN when only one of them has the feats to suggest they can bypass his ultimate defense?
I actually agree with you on this, Big father has some pretty good defenses that imo would make a fight against it difficult, G4 specifically. It took an enraged punch from BM and didn't immediately collapse, your actually helping my opinion a little bit.

The only reason I called him a lower level SN is because I have no idea how good its attack power is.
 

LBeezy

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
2,190
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
How is Capone a lower level SN when only one of them has the feats to suggest they can bypass his ultimate defense?
Which SN are you referring to when you say "feats to suggest they can bypass his ultimate defense"?

Cause I can think of at least 4..
 

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Only Law has feats that suggest he can bypass Capone's defenses, since his power ignores durability. None of the others have shown that they have strength on par with Big Mom.
Wait, so what you're trying to say is that none of the SNs besides Law can damage Big father at all because it didn't immediately get destroyed by BMs fists?

I admit Big fathers defenses are impressive but we have no idea how strong BMs fist are in comparison to any one elses abilities. We know that with a hakified arm BM blocked a KG with ease, but she never even used haki on Big father and still nearly killed Capone.

I think BF defenses would give every SN an extremely tough time destroying but I dont believe its impossible to take down, especially considering it may or may not have a time limit. Its offense also doesn't seem great either, this is probably some G4 level attack but instead of having great offense it has great defense instead.
 
Last edited:

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
Wait, so what you're trying to say is that none of the SNs besides Law can damage Big father at all because it didn't immediately get destroyed by BMs fists?

I admit Big fathers defenses are impressive but we have no idea how strong BMs fist are in comparison to any one elses abilities. We know that with a hakified arm BM blocked a KG with ease, but she never even used haki on Big father and still nearly killed Capone.

I think BF defenses would give every SN an extremely tough time destroying but I dont believe its impossible to take down, especially considering it may or may not have a time limit. Its offense also doesn't seem great either, this is probably some G4 level attack but instead of having great offense it has great defense instead.
The only one of them who's displayed feats of strength that could possibly place them up there with BM is Luffy, and even that doesn't appear likely given how he was portrayed in their clash(Maybe Zoro with cutting Pica? not sure on that one).

Until other SNs show that kind of strength, I'm not saying they can take it down. Simple as that.
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
T

Lol what does the distance have to do with anything, you can look at the panel and see the shields breaking, that's not assuming shit, that's fact its not debatable, if Luffy was allowed to keep punching those shields they would have crumbled that's fact. It just proves my point, he didn't need Namis help when he was in G4 as clearly shown on panel when she didn't help, just needed her help when it ran out.

Luffy isnt mid diffing Law though, your right about Capone he is a lower level SN. But the Top SN aren't far apart in power, what you seem to be trying to tell me is that Luffy is so much weaker than Cracker that even Snack and Urouge would beat him rather easily that's BS. With your garbage ass logic Luffy wouldn't even beat the commander weaker than Snack whoever that is.
The distance is relevant simply because if it were a longer distance that would have given Luffy more time to pound at the shields. And did you forget the soldiers have more than one shield? And no, it's not a fact they would have fully broken before they got to Luffy. He clearly did need her help, the panels show Luffy not even being able to lay a finger on Cracker.

Luffy in G4 is mid-diffing Law. Look at you now, changing your arguments already. First ALL Supernovas are equal and now only the high tier ones are :sdo: That's not my logic dumbass. I said there's a noticeable difference between Luffy and Cracker, that doesn't mean him and Urouge are beating him easily.

@bold

Good thing there's no sweet commander below Snack....Dumbass :lmao:
 

arv993

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 22, 2011
Messages
6,999
Kin
193💸
Kumi
2💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It's also unlikely Urouge ever fought Cracker with his own true strength, so your argument falls flat immediately.
And what indicates that? the reason I said urouge likely never saw cracker's true form was because of how surprised cracker was that luffy broke his armor and said he was surprised someone like him could do that. That statement indicated that another supernova most likely never broke through crackers defenses.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
And what indicates that? the reason I said urouge likely never saw cracker's true form was because of how surprised cracker was that luffy broke his armor and said he was surprised someone like him could do that. That statement indicated that another supernova most likely never broke through crackers defenses.
Because when Cracker showed up, Urouge in all likelihood would have already exhausted himself defeating Snack. Unless you think Snack is so much weaker than Urouge that the SN beat him without exhausting himself.
 

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The distance is relevant simply because if it were a longer distance that would have given Luffy more time to pound at the shields. And did you forget the soldiers have more than one shield? And no, it's not a fact they would have fully broken before they got to Luffy. He clearly did need her help, the panels show Luffy not even being able to lay a finger on Cracker.

Luffy in G4 is mid-diffing Law. Look at you now, changing your arguments already. First ALL Supernovas are equal and now only the high tier ones are :sdo: That's not my logic dumbass. I said there's a noticeable difference between Luffy and Cracker, that doesn't mean him and Urouge are beating him easily.

@bold

Good thing there's no sweet commander below Snack....Dumbass :lmao:
I didn't forget they had more than one shield, but it doesn't matter, regardless those shields were going to be destroyed they were still crumbling and weren't exactly close enough to Luffy.

He didn't need her help when he was in G4, show me panels of him being in any kind of danger when he was in G4 and had or needed Namis help. The only time Cracker landed a good clean hit was when Luffy had no idea the real Cracker was hiding within a clone, he had no Intel. No sir, the panels show any time after that they never landed a clean blow on each other so this shit about him not being able to lay a finger on Cracker is overblown, quit trying to blow that shit out of proportion to fit your needs.

Never said they were dead equal but they all seem pretty close in power. Even Capone with Big Father has a G4 level power up.

You ****ed up dumbass I never said anything about a sweet commander I said commander, implying the other ministers. Maybe I should have been more clear.
 
Last edited:

LBeezy

Active member
Veteran
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
2,190
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Only Law has feats that suggest he can bypass Capone's defenses, since his power ignores durability. None of the others have shown that they have strength on par with Big Mom.
You really don't think Teach has feats to suggest he can bypass Capone's ultimate defense?
 

arv993

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 22, 2011
Messages
6,999
Kin
193💸
Kumi
2💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Because when Cracker showed up, Urouge in all likelihood would have already exhausted himself defeating Snack. Unless you think Snack is so much weaker than Urouge that the SN beat him without exhausting himself.
First of all we dont know the time difference between when urouge defeated snack and him having to face cracker, no one said it was immediately after it could have been after a few days or a day. Second even if he was tired and again he likely had some time to recuperate b4 facing cracker, if the guy cant break one of cracker's armor or push him like luffy did, that means he would be absolutely crushed by cracker unlike luffy who with G4 can put up a decent fight until the time limit goes out. It can be possible that snack can be weaker than cracker by a good margin but again we dont have all the info all we know is cracker beat uruoge easily enough that he didnt get exposed.
 
Last edited:

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
First of all we dont know the time difference between when urouge defeated snack and him having to face cracker, no one said it was immediately after it could have been after a few days or a day. Second even if he was tired and again he likely had some time to recuperate b4 facing cracker
Doubt it. When Luffy defeated Cracker, the Enraged Army showed up that very same day while Luffy was still tired. Makes absolutely no sense that Cracker would wait days before showing up for Urouge. There's also the fact that Cracker showed up to fight Luffy shortly after Luffy and the others got to the Seducing Woods, meaning it makes even less sense that he'd show up there even a day later when Urouge defeated Snack.

Also, if Luffy is stronger than Urouge as you claim, and Luffy was still weak by the time the army showed up, then there's absolutely no way Urouge fully regained his strength in a day when Luffy couldn't/can't.

if the guy cant break one of cracker's armor or push him like luffy did
Like I said before, and you still have to refute, it's unlikely Urouge even got the chance to go all out against Cracker in the first place.
 

arv993

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 22, 2011
Messages
6,999
Kin
193💸
Kumi
2💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Doubt it. When Luffy defeated Cracker, the Enraged Army showed up that very same day while Luffy was still tired. Makes absolutely no sense that Cracker would wait days before showing up for Urouge. There's also the fact that Cracker showed up to fight Luffy shortly after Luffy and the others got to the Seducing Woods, meaning it makes even less sense that he'd show up there even a day later when Urouge defeated Snack.

Also, if Luffy is stronger than Urouge as you claim, and Luffy was still weak by the time the army showed up, then there's absolutely no way Urouge fully regained his strength in a day when Luffy couldn't/can't.


Like I said before, and you still have to refute, it's unlikely Urouge even got the chance to go all out against Cracker in the first place.
Main difference was urogue was in sea by the time, meaning he was able to get some space between BM and her crew. Luffy was point blank in their territory so its much easier to track him down. We cant assume that it takes the same time since its much easier to find somebody on land and in your own territory with all the recon in the world.

Second according to the dB urogue powers are to convert damage he inflicted into his own strength meaning even if he lost he should have had enough power to break through cracker's defenses but he could not.

There is nothing about refuting here, we are both speculating on what happened, it could have been cracker + enraged army vs uruoge or if it was uruoge and crew vs cracker + enraged army. but they made it seem like cracker by himself most likely defeated uruoge. And uruoge isnt luffy where he needs stamina to go G4, his condition is unknown but we do know that he can convert his pain into strength and even if he didnt defeat cracker my basic expectation is for him to atleast get through cracker's primary armor. Thats what makes me question the gap between snack and cracker.

I never outright said luffy is stronger than uruoge by a big margin or anything, their feats are both impressive, I am just questioning snack's strength based on uruoge's performance against cracker. If we get more details on uruoge's encounter with cracker we can have a clearer picture until then we got to speculate whos better and my opinion is luffy by a slim margin.
 
Last edited:

chopstickchakra

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Kin
4,684💸
Kumi
129💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Doubt it. When Luffy defeated Cracker, the Enraged Army showed up that very same day while Luffy was still tired. Makes absolutely no sense that Cracker would wait days before showing up for Urouge. There's also the fact that Cracker showed up to fight Luffy shortly after Luffy and the others got to the Seducing Woods, meaning it makes even less sense that he'd show up there even a day later when Urouge defeated Snack.

Also, if Luffy is stronger than Urouge as you claim, and Luffy was still weak by the time the army showed up, then there's absolutely no way Urouge fully regained his strength in a day when Luffy couldn't/can't.


Like I said before, and you still have to refute, it's unlikely Urouge even got the chance to go all out against Cracker in the first place.
Idk though based on his powers he may have been at his best chance to take on Cracker right after the fight with Snack since he converts damage to power and all.
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
I didn't forget they had more than one shield, but it doesn't matter, regardless those shields were going to be destroyed they were still crumbling and weren't exactly close enough to Luffy.

He didn't need her help when he was in G4, show me panels of him being in any kind of danger when he was in G4 and had or needed Namis help. The only time Cracker landed a good clean hit was when Luffy had no idea the real Cracker was hiding within a clone, he had no Intel. No sir, the panels show any time after that they never landed a clean blow on each other so this shit about him not being able to lay a finger on Cracker is overblown, quit trying to blow that shit out of proportion to fit your needs.

Never said they were dead equal but they all seem pretty close in power. Even Capone with Big Father has a G4 level power up.

You ****ed up dumbass I never said anything about a sweet commander I said commander, implying the other ministers. Maybe I should have been more clear.
Those shield and the clones weren't all going to crumble at such a short distance LMAO. And they weren't that close? Either you're lying or retarded, pick one:



Are you dense? Luffy had failed to make any grounds on Cracker and he already sustained injury. Cracker would have pushed him back and overwhlemed him eventually if he wasn't for Nami water. Me saying he never landed a blow on Cracker isn't OVERBLOWN BECUASE HE DIDN'T.

They didn't seem close, not at all.

How did I f**k up if you say at the end you had to be clear? You dumbass. And even if you include the ministers your ****ing post still makes no sense.....If Luffy doesn't stand a good chance against Cracker that doesn't mean he can't beat a minister. The minister themselves should be a decent amount BELOW CRACKER.
 

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Those shield and the clones weren't all going to crumble at such a short distance LMAO. And they weren't that close? Either you're lying or retarded, pick one:



Are you dense? Luffy had failed to make any grounds on Cracker and he already sustained injury. Cracker would have pushed him back and overwhlemed him eventually if he wasn't for Nami water. Me saying he never landed a blow on Cracker isn't OVERBLOWN BECUASE HE DIDN'T.

They didn't seem close, not at all.

How did I f**k up if you say at the end you had to be clear? You dumbass. And even if you include the ministers your ****ing post still makes no sense.....If Luffy doesn't stand a good chance against Cracker that doesn't mean he can't beat a minister. The minister themselves should be a decent amount BELOW CRACKER.
The clones weren't going to overwhelm G4 and there's nothing proving they were. In fact, if they were bound to overpower him why did Cracker jump right in front of them and attack himself? Why would a guy who dislikes pain jump out and attack on his own if the clones had it all under control? You can bring up the fact that Luffy had his focus elsewhere but if the clones were in fact going to overwhelm Luffy as you say, he could have just stayed put.

The clones were crumbling in the ****ing chapter wtf are you talking about? Those clones weren't all up in Luffys grill for him to get overpowered by them they weren't getting no ground on Luffy which is why Cracker attacked himself.

Its hilarious how you call me the dumbass but you're the only dumbass mfer arguing that the shields weren't crumbling even though they clearly were in the link you provided. I dont know why the **** you think so highly of those clones for, we already saw what G4 can do to one, and it got destroyed in like 2 hits. He's doing that exact same thing to each and every one of them, there not on G4s level. Unlike you I dont make up baseless shit, the manga has clearly shown that those clones are not on G4s level.

I'm not talking about regular Luffy I'm talking about G4, the only way Cracker is overpowering Luffy is when he's not in it. That's the only reason he needed Namis help, was when the mode ran out. Unless you can show me on panel proof of G4 being overpowered by Cracker this is just a baseless assumption. And I'm not talking about no ****ing surprise attack.
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
The clones weren't going to overwhelm G4 and there's nothing proving they were. In fact, if they were bound to overpower him why did Cracker jump right in front of them and attack himself? Why would a guy who dislikes pain jump out and attack on his own if the clones had it all under control? You can bring up the fact that Luffy had his focus elsewhere but if the clones were in fact going to overwhelm Luffy as you say, he could have just stayed put.

The clones were crumbling in the ****ing chapter wtf are you talking about? Those clones weren't all up in Luffys grill for him to get overpowered by them they weren't getting no ground on Luffy which is why Cracker attacked himself.

Its hilarious how you call me the dumbass but you're the only dumbass mfer arguing that the shields weren't crumbling even though they clearly were in the link you provided. I dont know why the **** you think so highly of those clones for, we already saw what G4 can do to one, and it got destroyed in like 2 hits. He's doing that exact same thing to each and every one of them, there not on G4s level. Unlike you I dont make up baseless shit, the manga has clearly shown that those clones are not on G4s level.

I'm not talking about regular Luffy I'm talking about G4, the only way Cracker is overpowering Luffy is when he's not in it. That's the only reason he needed Namis help, was when the mode ran out. Unless you can show me on panel proof of G4 being overpowered by Cracker this is just a baseless assumption. And I'm not talking about no ****ing surprise attack.
The clones would have reached Luffy and he would have had to stop the gataling in order to dodge any moves coming from them. If Luffy needed a Kong Organ just to take out 5 of them a bunch of them + the orignal Cracker is overwhelming Luffy up close. I just said why he jumped out in the other post, he saw an opening. Just because he hates pain doesn't mean he's stupid, he saw an opening and took it.

No ground? They were close to Luffy and were advancing, while the only things that were crumbling were their shields.

When did I say the SHEILDS (plural) weren't crumbling? I said the main clone body themselves weren't crumbling. Only one of the clone's sheilds were crumbling in the link I posted and they weren't even fully destroyed, you stupid f**k. When did I say the CLONES THEMSELVES were G4 level you dumb****? This discussion wasn't CRACKER'S CLONES vs Luffy, it is CRACKER vs Luffy.

Luffy was making no grounds on Cracker and when Cracker and the clones attacked together Luffy couldn't go on the offensive.
 

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The clones would have reached Luffy and he would have had to stop the gataling in order to dodge any moves coming from them. If Luffy needed a Kong Organ just to take out 5 of them a bunch of them + the orignal Cracker is overwhelming Luffy up close. I just said why he jumped out in the other post, he saw an opening. Just because he hates pain doesn't mean he's stupid, he saw an opening and took it.

No ground? They were close to Luffy and were advancing, while the only things that were crumbling were their shields.

When did I say the SHEILDS (plural) weren't crumbling? I said the main clone body themselves weren't crumbling. Only one of the clone's sheilds were crumbling in the link I posted and they weren't even fully destroyed, you stupid f**k. When did I say the CLONES THEMSELVES were G4 level you dumb****? This discussion wasn't CRACKER'S CLONES vs Luffy, it is CRACKER vs Luffy.

Luffy was making no grounds on Cracker and when Cracker and the clones attacked together Luffy couldn't go on the offensive.
Like I said there's nothing proving those clones were going to overpower Luffy, all this shit your saying just sounds like a big ass assumption. Those clones are so weak to G4 he can two shot them, how in the hell would they overpower him? The number of the clones also doesn't change a thing when he can simply two shot all of them.

They never got in close enough though so this is baseless, they never had the opportunity to overwhelm Luffy, and as Cracker was telling them to advance there shields were crumbling one by one, if G4 can two shot these clones individually he sure as hell isn't getting overpowered by them.

He found an opening and still failed to significantly harm Luffy who was focusing on the clones and were bound to destroy them. Your not proving anything with this shit.

The clash between G4 and the clones was like a few panels not even a few pages, it didn't last long enough for the clones to get destroyed honestly. Regardless Cracker tried to attack when he found an opening and still failed. SIMPLE

Cracker didn't do jack shit to Luffy in that instance either, so he was making no grounds on Luffy either. SIMPLE
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
Like I said there's nothing proving those clones were going to overpower Luffy, all this shit your saying just sounds like a big ass assumption. Those clones are so weak to G4 he can two shot them, how in the hell would they overpower him? The number of the clones also doesn't change a thing when he can simply two shot all of them.

They never got in close enough though so this is baseless, they never had the opportunity to overwhelm Luffy, and as Cracker was telling them to advance there shields were crumbling one by one, if G4 can two shot these clones individually he sure as hell isn't getting overpowered by them.

He found an opening and still failed to significantly harm Luffy who was focusing on the clones and were bound to destroy them. Your not proving anything with this shit.

The clash between G4 and the clones was like a few panels, not even a few pages, it didn't last long enough for the clones to get destroyed honestly. Regardless Cracker tried to attack when he found an opening and still failed. SIMPLE

Cracker didn't do jack shit to Luffy in that instance either, so he was making no grounds on Luffy either. SIMPLE

It was obvious that Luffy was going to get overwhelmed, not overpowered by the clones. 5 clones nearly fully advanced on Luffy and Luffy had to immediately stop his attack the second the real Cracker stepped in, where in that confrontation do you see Luffy even engaging the real Cracker when he can't even deal with the clones?

They never got close in? I LITERALLY POSTED THE SCAN OF THEM BEING RIGHT NEXT TO LUFFY. When they got close in the real Cracker advanced and then the fight was taken off panel. Abd two shotted? When the Crackers have their shields up they're not getting two shotted.

Okay, he didn't hurt Luffy in the one case? That's not my point, Luffy can't even go on the offensive against Cracker while Cracker can easily bring the fight to Luffy.

Hurting Luffy=/=Making grounds. Luffy couldn't even finish one full move before he was forced to dodge the real Cracker. Luffy was unable to fully initiate the offense while Cracker was able to easily, while Nami made Cracker's ability useless and Luffy couldn't overpower in a 11 hours time span.
 
Top