Who has more talent?

[Bronze]

Most of Minato's techniques are copied, so literally no talent. The only talent that can be made is his Rasengan, but a case can be made for Itachi, who enhanced Tsukuyomi to levels that time and space can be manipulated; essentially making him a god. For Minato, we only have hype and no feats. For Itachi, however, we have hype, feats and praise from many top tiers.

• Wise as Hokage at the age of 7.
• Mastered the Sharingan at the age of 8.
• Became an Anbu Captain at the age of 13.

Itachi's genius even went beyond what we thought: He defeated Orochimaru (someone at the level of Minato) with genius.​

 

[LuckyMan]

When flee-on-sight orders are given to shinobi should they see Itachi, then you can remake this thread and it can be discussed.

 

[Genjutsu da]

Minato is the most talented. Itachi is number two though

 

[Darkakatsuki]

Minato because Itachi came from a clan with greatness, many uchiha were good fighters based on their sharingan, take away his sharigan and he is weaker than iruka.

Minato came from a unknown clan, invented rasangan, mastered a uzumaki seal, perfected 2nd hokages ftg

Minato has way more natural talent

Itachi has more clan talent which isn't even a talent since it was given to him via family

Since when is talent not given through family? Talent is passed down through genetics, therefore sharingan and strong chakra passed down through family is talent. This is not a 'who's smarter' or 'who's more of a genius' thread, the op talks about talent and therefore things like sharingan and strong chakra have to be taken into account. I'm a Minato fan but what you just said is unfair to Itachi, your words lack objectivity, in other words, you're being biased.

 

[Xāvî1]

Itachi solos....