Who do you think is most to blame for the Uchiha clan Massacre?

[mikeeozua]

Who do you think is ultimately responsible for the massacre?

 

[FleeOnSight]

Obito after his attack everyone thought a
Uchiha member did it.

 

[Legendary Broly]

The Uchiha probably <.< It is a tough call >.<

 

[Fanta]

Obito.

just because I hate him

 

[NStraw]

I think the elders took the wrong decision by just going recklessly and making 3rd to allow the massacre

 

[Brooks]

Edit: Tobirama and the 3 old farts

 

[BelphaZar]

masashi kishimoto T^T

 

[Uchiha Josephus]

The Uchiha clan themselves.

Although one could say that it was Hashirama's (or was it Tobirama? oh well) fault for segregating the Uchiha in the villiage. :|

But even so, the decision was made by the Uchiha to go forward with the coup, so Elders of the village didn't have much choice.

 

[mikeeozua]

Obito after his attack everyone thought a
Uchiha member did it.

Yeah but i reckon the Uchiha still would have rebelled even if Obito didn't attack

 

[Brooks]

Obito after his attack everyone thought a
Uchiha member did it.

You're saying if i were part of a Clan and gone rogue then everything i do is also to be blame with the rest of the Clan?

Obito didn't give a shit about the Uchiha Clan.

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

there was a scene where danzo was talking with tobi

 

[Styles]

the 2nd hokage for putting them under surveillance and not trusting them which led to the rebellion and the massacre

 

[mikeeozua]

You're saying if i were part of a Clan and gone rogue then everything i do is also to be blame with the rest of the Clan?

Obito didn't give a shit about the Uchiha Clan.

True, thats like a muslim bombing america, then they blame the whole muslim race:sy:

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

the 2nd hokage for putting them under surveillance and not trusting them which led to the rebellion and the massacre

Indeed, Tobirama was the worst Hokage ever.

 

[Out Of Ctrl]

Madara Uchiha.

Spoiler

Their greatest powerful leader, Madara Uchiha, who led them through countless battles, ironically also led to their downfall.

His ideals about revolting during the first foundings of Konoha was the seed to all of this because he thought the Senju were intent on wiping out the Uchiha. Happens when you have an arrogant, power lust and paranoid leader. Albeit the fact that this story was told by Tobi, it doesnt change the fact that Madara did indeed fought Hashirama.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

So Tobirama had to manage a way in order to keep the Uchihas in check.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Now some of you may find it that its not enitrely fair that an entire race had to get punished by one guys ideals and actions. But the Uchiha clan were not entirely doing themselves any favours by the following reasons:

- Succumbing into the ideals of Madara as they noticed that they were being kept in check and decided to plan a revolution.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

- Uchiha clans absence from the attack of the Fox didnt also exactly helped and ease the tension amongst villagers.


Eventually, Fugaku and other Uchihas would plan a revolution. They were willing to risk a civil war as well as possibly a Shinobi world war (Shisui was sure of this). It couldnt also have been avoided, it seemed the Uchiha were determined to start a revolution as shown through Itachi's parents.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Obviously Tobi would have an important part in all of this but we fully dont know the details regarding his past connection so far. He may have manipulated the Uchiha elders, who knows? U_U

 

[oShux]

As much as i like the uchiha's they had it coming. And don't anyone reply to me saying some dumb shit like " but what about the kids they had nothing to do with it" LOOK AT SASUKE HE HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH IT EITHER, NOW IF ITACHI SPARED ALL THE KIDS WE WOULD'VE HAD A BUNCH OF LITTLE SASUKE'S RUNNING AROUND. One of him is already too much to handle imagine a bunch of him. The elders did what they had to do, if you don't like it oh well. That's just like how the real world is look at how the US dropped two Atomic bombs on Japan in WWII.

 

[mikeeozua]

Madara Uchiha.

​

Good theory, but konoha already knew about the Uchiha's acts before obito arrived

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

the uchihas has been opressed ever since the second hokages reign

 

[IchisaMiku]

Obito after his attack everyone thought a
Uchiha member did it.

Well an a Uchiha did do it so....yeah this is awkward -.-

 

[medal32]

They brought it on themselves