[Discussion] Whitebeard is Stronger than Garp

[Blazing Phoenix]

This was stated by Buggy, a crew member of Roger. "Whitebeard is... he is... A legendary "MONSTER" who was once the only man who could ever match the Pirate King Roger!!! HE IS WITHOUT A DOUBT, THE MOST POWERFUL PIRATE IN THE WORLD!!!! THE MAN CLOSEST TO THE "ONE PIECE"!!!! And the one thing Whitebeard will not stand for AT ALL is the death of his crew!!! THIS IS ABSOLUTE!! THAT'S WHAT KIND OF MAN HE IS".

I just wanted to clear up any confusion.

 

[Pirate King]

That's obvious

 

[Sherlock.]

Don't think so. Garp once went toe to toe with Roger. Both Garp and WB were old but Garp wasn't on salines like WB. They are almost at par with Garp being somewhat stronger.

 

[ethris]

This was stated by Buggy, a crew member of Roger. "Whitebeard is... he is... A legendary "MONSTER" who was once the only man who could ever match the Pirate King Roger!!! HE IS WITHOUT A DOUBT, THE MOST POWERFUL PIRATE IN THE WORLD!!!! THE MAN CLOSEST TO THE "ONE PIECE"!!!! And the one thing Whitebeard will not stand for AT ALL is the death of his crew!!! THIS IS ABSOLUTE!! THAT'S WHAT KIND OF MAN HE IS".

I just wanted to clear up any confusion.

what are you dummb? garp isnt a pirate..you didnt clear up anything

 

[UltimateHawk]

Yeah thats obvious though whitebeard would beat garp high diff.

 

[ethris]

Yeah thats obvious though whitebeard would beat garp high diff.

the only thing we know is garp is strong enough to go toe to toe with roger, we have no feats to support any other claims, we cant say garp is stronger than WB and we cant say WB is stronger than garp, this argument is pointless. garp and WB are able to go toe to toe with roger, the rest is speculation end of story

 

[xXMadaraUchiaXx]

garp is more impressing he is old too but still crazy haki mother****er beast. while whitebeard. yeah is old and has his fruit and is a half giant

 

[Blazing Phoenix]

what are you dummb? garp isnt a pirate..you didnt clear up anything

Read it again. "The only Man".

People like you are the reason why i'm this thread.

 

[Sherlock.]

Read it again. "The only Man".

People like you are the reason why i'm this thread.

The manga says otherwise.

 

[UltimateHawk]

the only thing we know is garp is strong enough to go toe to toe with roger, we have no feats to support any other claims, we cant say garp is stronger than WB and we cant say WB is stronger than garp, this argument is pointless. garp and WB are able to go toe to toe with roger, the rest is speculation end of story

Yeah but WB is more hyped.

 

[Blazing Phoenix]

The manga says otherwise.

A man who was on the Pirate King's ship say's otherwise.

Post an image/proof.

 

[Sherlock.]

A man who was on the Pirate King's ship say's otherwise.

Post an image/proof.

I won't Lol cause you are too damn cocky. Read the manga again carefully. Its been stated Garp and Roger had numerous stalemates.

 

[Blazing Phoenix]

I won't Lol cause you are too damn cocky. Read the manga again carefully. Its been stated Garp and Roger had numerous stalemates.

Excuses. Have a good day.

 

[Sherlock.]

Excuses. Have a good day.

Ignorance. Live in bliss Lol

 

[Blazing Phoenix]

Ignorance. Live in bliss Lol

I actually provided evidence to support my claim. I can't say the same for you. Since it's been said that they were equal "countless times" you should be able to produce some evidence.

 

[Sherlock.]

I actually provided evidence to support my claim. I can't say the same for you. Since it's been said that they were equal "countless times" you should be able to produce some evidence.

No you didn't. Buggy is talking about WB and Roger. I don't see him mentioning Garp anywhere. That's no evidence.

 

[Blazing Phoenix]

No you didn't. Buggy is talking about WB and Roger. I don't see him mentioning Garp anywhere. That's no evidence.

Are you illiterate? He said "Only Man", Garp fits into that category.

 

[Sherlock.]

Are you illiterate? He said "Only Man", Garp fits into that category.

I'm not only literate but I also read the manga carefully unlike you. And I don't take only Buggy's word for it when Roger himself says Garp and he are at par. Next time review the manga carefully before you make such bold claims and act like a know it all Lol

You must be registered for see images

"The two of us have nearly killed each other so many times." - Roger to Garp

Speaks for itself.

 

[Forbidden Tale]

Of course, it was stated that WB is strong as Roger, on the other hand for Garp argument, it was stated that he could fight only toe to toe with Roger, which is not the same, since fighting with someone toe to toe doesn't mean that you are equal with him.

Also, WB has title "Strongest man in the world", which speak for itself. U_U

Roger = WB >> Garp.

 

[Zorø]

By feat Whitebeard is stronger by hype Whitebeard and Garp on the same level.....these men were the only two men who could give roger a run for his money..U_U.