[Discussion] What if Luffy was sentenced to execution in Marineford?
- Thread starter USSJ Future Trunks
- Start date
Tomato God
Active member
This not to mention all the islands luffy liberated and the two warrior tribes he freed.
Black Mamba
Active member
Blazing Phoenix
Member
Dr Strangelove
Active member
Awards
I don't think he would send all of his allies and his entire crew.
I do think Ace would show up individually, maybe with a few members from Newgates crew, but not on the scale it was when Ace was up for execution.
Why would he come ? Luffy has no ties to Whitebeard. Why would he sacrifice his precious 'family' for someone he doesn't even know.
He let Ace go alone after Blackbeard
abdulmanjoo1
Member
The wHOLE wORLD WILL TRY TO SAVE HIM AND THEY WILL ESPECIALLY ACE CAUSE HE IS STILL STRONGER THAN LUFFy
Blazing Phoenix
Member
He didn't let Ace go. Ace left without his permission.
Ace has major ties with Luffy. Ace was Newgates most precious "son". If Ace went after Luffy, WB would also follow him in order to make sure his son didn't get hurt.
What is the difference ? In the end Ace left.
There is no evidence for Ace to be WB's favorite son. Also it makes no sense to go after him and 'save' his son as you say and sacrifice a lot of his other sons in the process.
Going to the war for Ace was entirely different, WB was giving a statement to the world, by going after Ace who is going after Luffy it would just be pointless.
1) Look world ! , I'm here to save my son and to show that no one can harm them and get away with it.
2) Look world ! , I can't control my son and I'm here to pick him up before he does something foolish, please excuse me because I don't have anything to do with this war.
USSJ Future Trunks
Active member
he didnt seem to care when ace could have gotten murdered by teach.
actually only grand line pirates are within range and only NW pirates/hancock/rayleigh will get there in time.
ace didnt have a whole lot of time. luffy only barely made it.
who? dory and broggy? if your talking about hancock, in this timeline he never went there. he got captured by teach on barano island.
he had already made his choice to support it over ace, moron. garp loves ace no less than luffy.
dragon's too weak or else he would ahve invaded already, luffy or no luffy.
shanks wont come. he of all people should realise that luffy is on his own path, and shanks loves his crew. luffy, he barely knew as an acquaintance.
everyone who went to save ace, knew and loved him as a brother and son. excpt obviously the impel down jailbreak men who merely followed luffy to be out of that hellhole.
plus if WB never comes, then no one is going to intercept kaidou from flanking shanks. shanks will be massacred.
to stop a war, not start one.
and with him heading to MF, kaido will flank him instead of whitebeard.
nah hes just too weak to do anything
two scenarios:
1.no one will come except SH's and entire crew will be killed by PX
2.All his former rivals will help SH's to free him.I think ace & WB,dragon,sabo & revs,shanks,rayleigh will definitely come for luffy.
because he is the hero of the story plot will save him with no logic at all.
1.no one will come except SH's and entire crew will be killed by PX
2.All his former rivals will help SH's to free him.I think ace & WB,dragon,sabo & revs,shanks,rayleigh will definitely come for luffy.
because he is the hero of the story plot will save him with no logic at all.
Forbidden Tale
Active member
Revolutionares + Red Hair Pirates + Ace (+ Possibility of Whitebeard pirates) + Straw Hat (+ possibility of Hearth Pirates). Nuff, Akainu would be raped. U_U
Blazing Phoenix
Member
The difference is you said "WB let him go" which is wrong.
He obviously was his favorite son, why else would he have wanted him to become the Pirate King? "Precious" might be the better word. Most of his sons would still be alive. With the combined forces of Shanks, Dragon, and WB the casualties should be minimum.
He'd also be able to get rid of the WG.
Like WB would run after his stubborn kid because he really really wants too, and ignore all his other responsibilities as a yonkou.
Besides do you think that Dragon, WB and Shanks all have each other on speed dial to compose their plan in the minimal time they have?
And like I said before, Luffy wouldn't get a public execution in the first place.
Dęvîa Puęrî
Active member
Blazing Phoenix
Member
What responsibilities? Whitebeard would be smart enough to leave behind most if not all of his allies. He'd really only need his main crew. They'd follow Whitebeard anywhere. Worst case scenario; Ace dying, Whitebeard understands the level of difficulty it would take to rescue Luffy (Admirals), he'd realize that if Ace went alone he'd die.
What plan? Like everyone else Whitebeard would see the news in the Newspaper and head there. They could create a plan once they arrive at Marineford.
If Whitebeard as a yonkou shows up and realizes he is in a fight he cant win, he is already screwed at that point. Admirals won't let him sail back to safety anymore.
Oh yeah, reading newspapers and making up plans on the spot to prevent a well thought out and prepared execution. That would work just fine...
But there won't be any newspaper. Luffy will be executed somewhere in Impel Down without the rest of the world knowing it, or at least too late.
Blazing Phoenix
Member
How does he lose? He's got 4 top tiers in his crew including himself. Not only that, but he'll have the combined forces of Shanks and Dragons crew. Admirals would get destroyed.
...."well thought out"? Marineford wasn't that well thought out. Whitebeard himself was able to rescue Ace. Imagine what would happen now that he has a bunch of Top tiers with him. Whitebeard made up a plan on the spot in Marineford. Sengoku stated that he was a great "tactician" or "strategist".
Moot point. The OP states that "everything occurs the same way it did with Ace". It's going to be a public execution.