[Discussion] was whitebeard's sending portgace D ace to kill blackbeard a smart decision from him????..

[minamoto]

i------------------>.


1s- blackbeard is strong..

2-blackbeard has strong nakama..

3-ace is wanted pirate...he is target of world gov..


these 3 factors makes it almost a inpossible mission for ace to capture blackbeard....

don't tell me whitebeard didn't take into considerations these ...he isn't that type of pirates who makes decisions without thinking..
..so why white beard still decided to send ace???


also remember...ace death changed course of Manga :

-it caused ace death...

-it caused whitebeard death...

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

Nope. Blackbeard may have played weak for a while, but WB should've known Ace couldn't win the moment Shanks mentioned the scar on his eye. It's not even like Ace specifically had to do it. WB probably could've killed BB if he sent one of his stronger commanders.

 

[minamoto]

Nope. Blackbeard may have played weak for a while, but WB should've known Ace couldn't win the moment Shanks mentioned the scar on his eye. It's not even like Ace specifically had to do it. WB probably could've killed BB if he sent one of his stronger commanders.

thats what im saying... but if we r forced to thnk whitebeard was smart pirate...that means him sending ace was part of his secret plan..

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

thats what im saying... but if we r forced to thnk whitebeard was smart pirate...that means him sending ace was part of his secret plan..

Whitebeard must know that Ace will be sent to Raftel upon dying

 

[minamoto]

Whitebeard must know that Ace will be sent to Raftel upon dying

poor writing from oda here isn't it????..

or whitebeard had secret plan wich means geniius writing from oda..

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

poor writing from oda here isn't it????..

Depends on if it's in character for Whitebeard. Smart people can do dumb things if it's pride or creed driving them. I can't remember how it all went down, so I can't really give you my thoughts. If I remember right, I think Ace insisted on going or something.

 

[Wrappering_]

He did not send him, Ace left after D. Teach on his own accord. Ace was way too confident in his Logia abilities that he even disregarded Shanks's advice against pursuing BB, and ended up paying for it with his own defeat.

 

[Im_not_Osama_bin_laden]

Didn't he go on his own accord?

He did not send him, Ace left after D. Teach on his own accord. Ace was way too confident in his Logia abilities that he even disregarded Shanks's advice against pursuing BB, and ended up paying for it with his own defeat.

Yeah I thought so.

 

[chopstickchakra]

WB knew he wouldn't win but he also knew the type of person Ace was, he went through Ace's tenacity first hand in the many attempts on his life Ace made despite knowing he couldn't. He wasn't going to stop Ace but he should have sent others to back him up.

 

[Sakazuki]

If I remember correctly whitebeards didn't want him to go, dumbass

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

If I remember correctly whitebeards didn't want him to go, dumbass

WB also didn't stop him though.

 

[minamoto]

If I remember correctly whitebeards didn't want him to go, dumbass

i see u still havn't recovred from ur mental illness...wish to u a speedy mental recovery anyway..

 

[Uchiha seeker]

Nah he threw a fit and crew tried to stop him. WB was like hmmmmmmmmmmm.

Ace the type to try and 1v3 the admirals cause they took his dinner

 

[minamoto]

i thoiught Whitebeard pirates live by a code that they must avenge a fallen comrade...so since ace was comender means he was one logically who should be sent kill blakbeard...

 

[Berlecluka]

But still, him not going would only make Luffy dead

 

[Uchiha seeker]

i thoiught Whitebeard pirates live by a code that they must avenge a fallen comrade...so since ace was comender means he was one logically who should be sent kill blakbeard...

Your English a lot better now fam.
I think Ace actually mentioned that he had to do it twoooooooo day yeeeeeee