I agree with everything you had to say, except one thing and that's Tsukuyomi. I know I'm going to get bashed on this but I'm only going off of what the manga told me and I'm curious on how any Rinnegan user gets past
Itachi's Tsukuyomi. The reason for this is that he controls space and time in his Tsukuyomi, it's far above the average genjutsu. He can do what he wants in his genjutsu world.
According to the Manga
only a Sharingan user with the
same blood as Itachi has the potential to get past his Tsukuyomi.
You must be registered for see links
According to the Manga a Sharingan user himself: when hit by Itachi's Tsukuyomi there's
no cancelling the effects it. "No Cancelling" means no cancelling, it's invincible. And that hasn't been proven wrong except by Sasuke for reason already stated.
You must be registered for see links
Now, despite those manga facts I'm still probably going to get "LOL Creation of all things stomp" posts. Well apparently it doesn't, and honestly COAT is overrated. It creates things, as the user breaths life into something, the Jutsu obviously has its limits and just do anything it wants like just imagining something to die. If that was the case then the Sage wouldn't of had to seal the Juubi in himself.
^^ I have to admit that you are right about it, because you even provided scan to prove your opinion;(
I know that my opinion or guess means nothing in front of proof, but maybe Kishi didn't think forward in future too much or
he simply didn't prediction to introduce Rinnengan.
It could be just hype for Itachi and Sasuke at that time of Manga, or Kishi didn't thought about Rinnengan then....
Anyway I can say that COAT counter Tsyukomii but why even use it. Remember that Rinnengan user has potential to each mastery over Yin release(Genjutsu), so Maybe as Master of Yin Release(If he reached full potential of Rinenngan even) he could take control over Tsukiyomii or simply dispel, so anyway
Master of Rinenngan could have countered Tsukyiomii
Thanks for developing debate
It does'nt seem like it has a limit since it can absorb a tailed beast's worth of chakra as shown when Nagato absorbed all of the chakra of Killer Bee's V2 form.
^^ that is true as well
I agree, I always imagined rinnegan user to be near omnipotent, especially the SO6P
There is no way I could conceive of someone like Shisui defeating him with just KA or Obito with Kamui.....it's just too simple and would defeat the purpose of the rinnegan being the ultimate doujutsu.
My only suspicion is the creation of all things; I'm sure there is a limit to what it can do since the Sage did indeed die.....and if it can create all things, then why didn't the SO6P grant himself immortality?
I hope we find out eventually.
I agree totally with you

You wrote all my thougths about it
About your question: "if it can create all things, then why didn't the SO6P grant himself immortality?"
I have few theories about it:
1) The Sage of six paths believed in Life and Death Order or something like that, so he simply accepted death
2) Juubi chakra or remains in Sage of six paths could kill him anyway even if he used COAT Again
3) He didn't have enough chakra to do COAT
4) Creation of All things has some limit to it
If you have the 'body' as well then you can use perfect izanagi which is the same as creation of all things.. you can't beaten, unless you drain out your chakra.
Otherwise, just the abilities shown by Nagato can be beaten somewhat easily.
^^ that could be true, but maybe having Senjuu and Uchiha DNA in one body give you even more benefits =D
who knows, we have to wait and see
rinnegan is so OP but awesome =)=)=)
Exactly my friend =D
madara use this
You must be registered for see images
and any rinnegan user destroyed (he wouldn't even have time to use bansho Bansho tenin)
The Sage of six paths could use Bansho Tenin much faster then Nagato, or at greater scale with greater force or even use another technique to counter it.
Remember
the Sage of six paths was said to use any jutsu
^^ Exactly with Power of Uchiha and Senjuu DNA along with most likely Sage chakra it could even repel Perfect Sussano
I was thinking more along the lines of a 1 handed CST
You must be registered for see images
^^ Exactly this
Considering Itachi never faced a skilled rinnegan user....
That is based on opinion.
^^ As I said
hahahahahaha it wouldn't even put a scratch:snick:.susanoo is pure power just like the kyuubi.
Even if it is true, then just pump even more chakra into that while even amplify it with Sage chakra then it could work
Don't understimate True Rinnengan Master The Sage of six paths
susanoo is made out of chakra lol preta path
^^Hahaha, that true considering that everything made by Nagato can be done by SOSP multiply few times at least or even 50 times
Sorry but creation of all things wont help vs izanami.
Izanami is devised against that.
Sharigan reigns supreme in battle.
Hmm... Interesting, but then Rinnengna user uses his mastery over Yin release(genjutsu) or Ying-Yang release to break through Izanami
Remember Itachi's words every jutsu has weakness, if that is true and SOSP was said to use any jutsu then SOSP > Izanami
Seems like a fap thread to me.
Just you I think, but feel free to say anything you want
yeah, actually Nagato can
The Susanoo Sword is still part of Susanoo thus made of chakra and Nagato can fly to get close to it
I'm not saying that Nagato can defeat Madara, just saying that rinnegan>sharingan and a rinnegan user can defeat a susanoo user
Also, yeah Nagato can absorb Naruto's Bijuu cloak because it's made from chakra.....Nagato was already shown absorbing Bee's V2 cloak
You must be registered for see images
^^ That guy is speaking truth

, listen to him
Always depends on the user, but sharingan has hax that rinnegan cant counter thus both can win.
I find sharingan more battle suited due to movement and jutsu reading, genjutsu and hax jutsus that cover defense and offence nicely. It's well rounded doujutsu, rinnegan is versatile but not so battle suited.
^^ Well I could disagree as Rinnengan was said to use any jutsu
You must be registered for see images