Uchiha Clan Massacre was the right thing to do

[uzumakinaruto389]

the uchihas were planning to take over the village by killing/supressing the rest. How is that different from what was done to the uchiha?If the uchihas just PLAN to do it then they're bad, and if the village does that it is justified. Your logic is flawed
(PS: Im not an Uchiha Supporter)

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

the uchihas were planning to take over the village by killing/supressing the rest.

um no. we dont know what their plan was or who they intended to kill or maim. and killing people you intend to rule seems counterproductive

 

[closecombat1254]

none is better than a few.
you have no proof that the clan hated anyone or that survivors would vow revenge.
and who cares if a bunch of kids hate the village? throw them in jail and if thye hate konoha, let them.
whats immoral is killing anyone if you can avoid it and konoha could have avoided it by placating the clan.

no it didnt

how is a moral issue like genocide simple?
and you know what risks the village? turning the surviving uchiha into a psychopathic avenger

This ain't a moral issue that's what u want it to be .in war its a fight for survival simple . And its up to the winner to decide what they want to do or change. like if the uchia had won they would change things for their benefit.simple and it benefited the village to kill the uchia

 

[~Sky~]

I feel it was instigated immensely by Danzo. He's the one I think is at fault.

 

[ministerC4]

I feel it was instigated immensely by Danzo. He's the one I think is at fault.

Yeah, Danzo vastly screwed with stuff, I believe had Hiruzen been given more time things would have rolled like grain and oats..

 

[Stormblast]

It was either quell the uprising or allow the Uchiha to run rampant through Konoha and cause a world war. There's no right or wrong in this scenario, only survival.

 

[SuperChief]

No, it wasn't. The Uchiha Clan Massacre was an unnecessary move orchestrated by Danzō. It weakened Konoha as a whole, led to the desertion of Sasuke, who could've potentially turned into Madara 2.0 and destroyed the village.

 

[xxSAGExx]

and how does any of that disproves what i said, considering they were distinctly targeted like that?

Ethnicity would more of where one trace their lineage such as culture or traits but not all Uchihas suffered from this as Tobirama said there were many like Itachi who were different so it wasn't solely due to ethnicity. It's more of some Ucihhas not being able to control themselves while some could. What I'm saying is, what happened to the Uchihas were based on some of the members incapability to not remain in control when they lose someone or something they love and if their lovedid turn into a stronger hate that made them run wild then why would anyone want to live by them? I mean, Senjus and Uchiha both come from the same ancestor which is the Sage.

It's not like Tobirama could separated the Uchihas who could control themselves from those who can't, he could have hoped the ones who were like Itachi would rub off or help the others gain control better. Hashirama wanted all clans to not be bound to their clans but to move pass that and see the village as a hole as their family. Tobirama tried mediating between the clans while reinforcing and protecting the village so he didn't do it because he hated a clan or anything, he just wanted to ensure peace but it got more out of hand with Danzo

You must be registered for see links

.