The Mangekyo Sharigan is a curse

[devil naruto]

probably right dude

 

[Illyasviel]

It is kinda a curse the rinnengan is beter then but nagato did awaken his rinnengan after his parents died

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

thank god itachi kill them all but too bad sasuke is still there lurking for power and never ending revenge

 

[Kirin Rei]

So, umm ,I was thinking...

I don't know if anyone has mentioned it in the thread before, I couldn't bring myself to read the whole 5 pages, but...

What if Madara and Izuna swapped their eyes? Wouldn' that make it possible for them to both have EMS?
Same goes for all the Uchiha siblings that have had MS throughout history. It would make the whole deal a lot more easier.

 

[-Jiraiya-]

It becomes a curse only when you spam it... Its a gift if know when, where, how to use it...

 

[Blaze Release]

**** you

Dude im an uchiha fan, unlike you im logical in what i say

 

[Kirin Rei]

Dude im an uchiha fan, unlike you im logical in what i say

Tehehe Uchiha fan.

You must be registered for see images

Sorry, I just had to do it.

 

[Blaze Release]

itachi fully admitted killing shisui he helped get rid of his body. technically he still killed him. and when tobi told sasuke the history he said in that era only madara and his brother had the MS and they gained it by killing an uchiha aswell to awaken it i dont agree with your thread buddy

You must be registered for see images

Dude ive uploaded the chapter. Itachi said, shisui died suddenly, its pretty clear.
He gave itachi his eye and then died by his own hands

Tobi never said anything about madara and izuna killing an uchiha to gain the ms. Upload the chapter. Lets not forget that he also lied about the fox being a natural disaster when we all now know that it was him who summoned it.

Also im abit sceptical about him, when he said izuna gave up his eyes. I believe desperation is what made madara take it, as itachi said

 

[lswhyte123]

Very well made thread buddy.

I have to agree, the Uchiha bloodline is soaked in...well..blood. It's a shame that there are so many downsides. However, in many species, to have power is to have a shorter timespan on this planet too. Most swords have two sharp edges.(insert wise comment)
I think there is more to the mangekyou than has been said. i don't know how Kakashi got it but when he does explain it, it may shed some light.

Again broseph. Good job on the thread. I would give you all the tea in China for this one

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

well the very history of the uchiha itself is the older son of the sage who resent his younger brother, whose been choosen as the sage successor, and yet even that was his father decision he can't accept it.

 

[Vertemixx]

nice thread.

 

[Bloody Temari]

That is a possibility. Or somehow he started to get emotional about obito again, since we have seen him go to his grave several times and one day, he activated the ms.

I do think the rin thing is most likely though

I think it could have been awakened by Itachis Tsukyomi. Causing lots of mental stress.

 

[Hei]

well good point

 

[Alkaiser]

Has this happend to Kakashi aswell? his sight going blind etc... don't think so, you know why? I think that normal Uchiha MS rules don't count for Kakashi because he is not a true Uchiha by blood, Kisihi might use this as an excuse to pull a EMS for Kakashi out of his ass

You might be right, do you think it could be because the eye was already transplanted technically?

 

[Kakashi Hatakeo]

Gotta agree with blaze release +1 rep. Just not sure if same rules apply to kakashi, true the effects are worse for him its just that we havent seen him have any eyesight trouble.

 

[Anduril]

I think i agree here it seems that the MS is a curse more than it is a power boost...But what stands in the way is why does it go on to turn into the rinnegan if it was a curse??

 

[The7thHokage]

Yeah man ....totally a curse cause, A-unlike EMS, u might loose ur light, and B-u have to kill ur best friend to get it

 

[Kronos]

Great thinking, but I was also thinking something else. Maybe the MS is only activated and applied to the one who shares the name, Uchiha. Considering Kakashi is a Hatake, maybe it doesn't apply for him.

 

[el shaarawy]

Uhhmm; yeah its a curse but at the same time, it grants you power you have never dreamt of! that just shows you how uchihas are the most unique clan in the whole of narutoverse

 

[devojoyti halder]

Killing or losing someone is nothing infront of the awsome power you get.
Your close one will someday die, didn't matter a little earlier.