The Debunking of two Theories!

Sennin of Logic

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 13, 2013
Messages
8,874
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
THEORY 1

The Pseudo-jinchuriki Theory:

States that Naruto is going to get bits of all the tailed beasts's chakra and transform into a sage-like being.

Argument:

Now, let us analyze a similar situation. Obito. If people believe that Gaara retained some of shukaku's chakra after it was removed from him, which is not true, then shouldn't obito who once had all the chakra of the beasts in him be a pseudo jinchuriki and be able to survive even when the gedo mazou was removed from him? Well, that is not the case as it was even stated in the manga that he will die without the gedo mazou albeit fulfilling all the requirements of becoming a "psedo-jinchuriki".
Ever wonder why this is so? This is because since from the on set, a wrong assumption was made about Gaara. Gaara never retained any chakra from the shukaku, the only reason why he was able to pull shukaku's chakra from obito was because he was "compatible" as stated by Chiyo since his birth, that was the same reason why shukaku was sealed in him in the first place and not his siblings because Gaara was compatible. Now if you still insist that Gaara has the shukaku's chakra in him, then shouldn't he be using wind by now?

Nevertheless, this could happen as a reason of plot but even if it happens how is Naruto who only has bits of chakra from the tailed beats defeat Madara who swims in a pool of beast chakra(this is if he becomes the jinchuriki of the juubi)?

Status:
Debunked.


THEORY 2

The Other Half Transfer:

States that Minato will seal the other half of Kurama into Naruto thus reviving him.

Argument:

Is this seriously what people think? Do you remember kushina, Naruto's mother? Do you remember her affair with Minato about the beast, Kurama?
If you have been reading the manga attentively then you would remember a scene in the manga when Kushina suggested that she reseals the beast in her and die with it and then Minato refused, his argument being that the beast will revive after sometime. This should be enough to show that it is not possible to reseal a beast in a person as a measure for him to survive after it has been forcefully removed.
Here is a page for you
You must be registered for see images

Status:
Debunked.

Hope you guys can reason with me, I am no naruto hater though. All I have said above is only logical but we all no Masashi has put all logic behind him. I wanted to debunk a third theory which is Sasuke getting the rinnegan so soon without even having senju DNA (chakra is not DNA) but I am not ready for a headache just yet.

You've legitimately debunked theory 2, but not 1. The manga never really states that there isn't some sort of chakra connection between Garra and Shukaku. In fact, it would indicate the opposite. Also, Obito is psuedo jinchuriki. What do you call the Gedo Mazo? It's possible that Naruto could become a sage-like being. After all.....

You must be registered for see images


The only tailed beast chakra he'd lack at this point are Shukaku, Gyuku, and Kurama. It is possible that he's somehow going to get the chakra he lacks.


Now, you have to ask yourself, if it's not jinchuriki related, then how's Naruto going to survive? Why would Kurama tell Garra to do something to Naruto? It's not medical ninjutsu related.
 
Top