[Tier] The 6 one piece tiers

[TheNuetrix]

Pirate King {Roger, Prime Whitebeard}
Yonko {Kaido, Shanks, Akainu}
Admiral {Aokiji, Fujitora, Rayleigh}
High Yonko Commander {Luffy, Katakuri, Marco}
Mid Yonko Commander {Doflamingo, Zoro, Ace}
Low Yonko Commander {Sanji, Oven, Moria}
Vice-Admiral {Smoker, Brook, Franky}
Rear Admiral {Coby, Usopp, Chopper}
Fodder {Nami, Buggy, Wapol}

I don't consider Warlord a tier because it's just too broad (Moria<<<Jinbe<<<<<<Mihawk)

 

[chopstickchakra]

Kinda weak comeback

The fact that you list Mihawk under yonkou tier while his title is a shichibukai, and you also use shichibukai as a rank is already proof enough that your list is out of whack.

Can't have it both ways.

So you can't have a title below your abilities?

I honestly feel doffy is stronger then everyone in that list with his feats previous hype and overall importance to the story (talking about people who specifically have some feats).
I mean he dismantled law and one shotted Sanji in one arc with no breaks in between. Zoro and law should go lower. Idk why burgress is even there I thought you were trolling me -.-

I agree Doffy's 1st mate at the lowest. I don't see Kid beating him as of right now.

 

[Sakazuki]

I'm just trying to figure out when I asked anybody if the commanders should be separated into tiers or if they cared that I put warlords on there as a tier ? now I did ask who you guys think should go where (with the tiers I've given)

Post automatically merged: Nov 27, 2018

Pirate King {Roger, Prime Whitebeard}
Yonko {Kaido, Shanks, Akainu}
Admiral {Aokiji, Fujitora, Rayleigh}
High Yonko Commander {Luffy, Katakuri, Marco}
Mid Yonko Commander {Doflamingo, Zoro, Ace}
Low Yonko Commander {Sanji, Oven, Moria}
Vice-Admiral {Smoker, Brook, Franky}
Rear Admiral {Coby, Usopp, Chopper}
Fodder {Nami, Buggy, Wapol}

I don't consider Warlord a tier because it's just too broad (Moria<<<Jinbe<<<<<<Mihawk)

Kinda loved you put pirate king on there. Garp should join them there.


I put warlords cause like I said, after they're replaced I'm sure warlords will have a very set level, sitting right below 3rd commanders. (I basically think crocodile is the perfect person to give a reasonable warlord level)

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

So you can't have a title below your abilities?



I agree Doffy's 1st mate at the lowest. I don't see Kid beating him as of right now.

Not to mention neither Zoro or Law has any feats /hype to put them on his level.

Doflamingo is the one who started this whole gear 4th hype and still is the only one that required a King Kong gun (after kong Gun Gamma knife etc) to be put down I don't see Law or Zoro needing that much damage to be rekt. Now Burgess should be below Law and Zoro (in my opinion). I don't see Zoro (hype hasn't gone all out yet also could repel fuji basic haki with extreme diff).or Law (his showing against dodgy and Fuji at the same time. Being able to haul ass and avoid damage with caesar on his back even saving Sanji)getting tossed around that easily by sabo like Burgess.


Honestly from what we've seen of Jesus I don't know what could separate him from the likes of Oven Genie guy Pica Diamonte Cabbage Trebol Barto chinjao.. Etc.

I will say the only interesting about him is that he hasn't taken a df yet.

 

[Sakazuki]

Not to mention neither Zoro or Law has any feats /hype to put them on his level.

Doflamingo is the one who started this whole gear 4th hype and still is the only one that required a King Kong gun (after kong Gun Gamma knife etc) to be put down I don't see Law or Zoro needing that much damage to be rekt. Now Burgess should be below Law and Zoro (in my opinion). I don't see Zoro (hype hasn't gone all out yet also could repel fuji basic haki with extreme diff).or Law (his showing against dodgy and Fuji at the same time. Being able to haul ass and avoid damage with caesar on his back even saving Sanji)getting tossed around that easily by sabo like Burgess.


Honestly from what we've seen of Jesus I don't know what could separate him from the likes of Oven Genie guy Pica Diamonte Cabbage Trebol Barto chinjao.. Etc.

I will say the only interesting about him is that he hasn't taken a df yet.

I only put Burgess there just because I feel like katakuri could wreck cracker just like sabo did Burgess... And I'd put sabo and katakuri on the same level so I just kinda put Burgess around crackers level just out of theorizing

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

I only put Burgess there just because I feel like katakuri could wreck cracker just like sabo did Burgess... And I'd put sabo and katakuri on the same level so I just kinda put Burgess around crackers level just out of theorizing

Burgess couldn't do anything to sabo I will say his durability is almost top notch though... I feel like burgers vs sabo was a negative for both parties. Sabo because it took him so long to take him out.. And burgers because this was first showing from black beard commander with title of 1st commander at that

 

[chopstickchakra]

Burgess couldn't do anything to sabo I will say his durability is almost top notch though... I feel like burgers vs sabo was a negative for both parties. Sabo because it took him so long to take him out.. And burgers because this was first showing from black beard commander with title of 1st commander at that

Yeah Burgess was pretty disappointing but I have pretty good hopes for laffitte,, Doc Q, and Pizzaro

 

[Nox]

The Admiral disrespect is ridiculous. What have Orochi, Oden, Beckman, Sabo done to warrant such placements? One hasn't even appeared. Another whose merely reputation. Of which with strength comparable to Kata or even Smoothie, is respectable. Another claim to fame is issuing a threat which Kizaru ignored. The other who was toyed with the so called new unimpressive Admiral. Plus fought him alongside 4 others. Warlord strength is so broad ot stretches from Mihawk to Buggy. Luffy's reputation and accomplishment pre TS could've seen him enter Warlord. I'll just stick to
0. God = PK
1. Top = Admiral+
2. High = NW Veterans
3. Mid = Paradise Veteran
4. Low = Fodder

Once thats situated I know within said tiers are other subdivisions. Which I can situate different characters.

 

[Passerby]

Yeah Burgess was pretty disappointing but I have pretty good hopes for laffitte,, Doc Q, and Pizzaro

What is Burgess skin made of? I mean he ate a fire fist from Sabo without showing any signs of burnt skin lol

 

[chopstickchakra]

What is Burgess skin made of? I mean he ate a fire fist from Sabo without showing any signs of burnt skin lol

Diamonds??? lol nah.

 

[Sakazuki]

Databook vivre card 3 confirmed shiliew was afraid of Magellan... Even if he didn't act like it in the manga, Oda said he was.. meaning Magellan is first commander level confirmed

 

[Skull Knight]

Databooks are not written by Oda.
They are written by his editors. He only approves them like some of the movies.
And if u consider databook canon then i guess Sabo is dead as one of the databooks said he was dead.

 

[Sakazuki]

Databooks are not written by Oda.
They are written by his editors. He only approves them like some of the movies.
And if u consider databook canon then i guess Sabo is dead as one of the databooks said he was dead.

Debate then. How's shiliew beating Magellan?

 

[Skull Knight]

Debate then. How's shiliew beating Magellan?

For that we need to see Shiliews full fighting style/abiity.
But whatever he showed its clear he's like Brook. Use swordplay with speed.
Not to forget he is extremely fast, has immunity towards Magellan's poison n now he has invisible df.

 

[Sakazuki]

For that we need to see Shiliews full fighting style/abiity.
But whatever he showed its clear he's like Brook. Use swordplay with speed.
Not to forget he is extremely fast, has immunity towards Magellan's poison n now he has invisible df.

Nah I don't see how he has immunity. If Magellan hits him once why isn't he done for?

 

[-Akuma-]

Imagine putting Kuzan and Akainu in different tiers when it was implied they had an extreme dif fight.

 

[Jerry Berry]

Imagine putting Kuzan and Akainu in different tiers when it was implied they had an extreme dif fight.

I consider them equal, but in addition to that, kuzan has been roaming and presumably fighting semi consistently, where as Akainu I doubt has seen much action lately. I'm not sure how much room for growth either have but I would bet on kuzan being stronger than we've previously seen, and akainu being fairly stagnant.

 

[Nox]

Databook vivre card 3 confirmed shiliew was afraid of Magellan... Even if he didn't act like it in the manga, Oda said he was.. meaning Magellan is first commander level confirmed

How? Was Warden Shillew comparable to 1st Mate? Current Shillew is a Commander whose grown from his involvement in the Payback War AND acquisition of Clear Clear Fruit. The databook states PRIOR to these events the consensus was Shillew = Magellan. His fearfulness towards Magellan is a quip in the same vein as databook mentioning Katarina's cruelty, Alvaro's twistedness, Vasco's brutality. Kalifa didn't become = Sanji just because he couldn't lay a finger on her. If Magellan is 1st Mate it has to be off his own merit/feats/hype.

I consider them equal, but in addition to that, kuzan has been roaming and presumably fighting semi consistently, where as Akainu I doubt has seen much action lately. I'm not sure how much room for growth either have but I would bet on kuzan being stronger than we've previously seen, and akainu being fairly stagnant.

While I don't dispute the idea of Kuzans grown esp. since Garp at 46/48 was training himself to dismantle DCJ's head. You are underselling Akainu given his participation in arguably the biggest battle in recent years. He accounts for majority contributions in stopping, injuring and confronting WB. Singlehandedly faced off against his fleet. Then he caped this campaign by defeating and sparing Kuzan; (

You must be registered for see links

). The same chapter (650) goes on to build upon his hype. The big events in the world are Akainu and Teach's actions. Be it in quality of battles experienced, impact on narrative Saka's got the upper hand.

 

[Jerry Berry]

Honestly I just don't want to believe that, albeit probably true. I'm hoping Kuzan has put some serious exp under his belt.
Edit: Also I would really like to see a rematch between the two in the future. I'm sure Oda has other plans for Kuzan, and other opponents for Akainu, but I want to see it so bad D:<

 

[Sakazuki]

Honestly I just don't want to believe that, albeit probably true. I'm hoping Kuzan has put some serious exp under his belt.
Edit: Also I would really like to see a rematch between the two in the future. I'm sure Oda has other plans for Kuzan, and other opponents for Akainu, but I want to see it so bad D:<

Kuzan might not even be alive, Blackbeard was wearing his glasses in his bounty reveal