So Roshi's Magma style was not a KKG, but a Jinchuurinki power....

[Floydical]

I don't know if people thought the same way I did but up until this chapter, I believed Roshi's Magma style or Lava style was a result of a KKG passed down through family heritage. It would be comparable to the Mizukage's Lava style variation, who has multiple KKG's and is not a jin.

I always believed that he was chosen as a Jin BECAUSE he was strong and had things in his arsenal like Magma style. Turns out his trademark ability is simply borrowed from his Biju, too bad if you ask me.

 

[HashiramaDescendant]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

 

[Young Vongola]

I thought this was obvious a long time ago tbh. Its Just like every other jinchuriki, what would make him any different?

 

[Champ]

thought this was common sense he got his power from the Biju

 

[Dagcy16]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

wait... gaara does not inherit the sand from the shukaku.... maybe this applies to bee and gyuki to the point that bee can use ink clones, but maybe not gaara...

 

[xhelou]

Or, in the other hand, Roshi was the aproppriated Jinchuuriki because of their compatibility. I mean, maybe Roshi had that Kekkei Genkai of Lava Release. Don't forget this is just speculation yours and mine because there is no fact, we just saw Son lending his lava-based chakra to Naruto, just that.

 

[Tobi98]

wait... gaara does not inherit the sand from the shukaku.... maybe this applies to bee and gyuki to the point that bee can use ink clones, but maybe not gaara...

Yes he does

 

[Cauzing]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

this is the answer^

 

[Cruciatus]

It's both. Roshi got it from Son, but Dodai and Terumi got it from it being a KKG.

Edit: Oh I misread, yeah I agree with you, disregard the previous part of this post.

 

[Dagcy16]

Yes he does

i think no.... really really no.... i dunno why but no...

 

[Floydical]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

Not really. It was confirmed that the sand protects him independent of his will as a result of his mother. Its not that he inherited the power from his Biju, rather he was given it by his mother.

I thought this was obvious a long time ago tbh. Its Just like every other jinchuriki, what would make him any different?

thought this was common sense he got his power from the Biju

It might have been obvious to you but what other Biju commands a KKG?

Kurama has no elements. Hachibi has no elements. Six tails has goo, but its not an element. Three tails might have water, but not a KKG. One tails has wind by not a KKG.

Was it really so logical, knowing of this trend, to assume that one of the Biju commands a KKG? I think it. I thought it was clear, before this chapter, that it was a KKG Roshi had.

 

[Umari Senju]

wait... gaara does not inherit the sand from the shukaku.... maybe this applies to bee and gyuki to the point that bee can use ink clones, but maybe not gaara...

I think you are right. The sand justsu Gaara uses was developed by the 3rd Kazekage who used Sand/Iron to mimic that of Sukaku's sand release. At least that was what I read. I don't know if this was fact though.

 

[YoungDragon]

Uhm? I believed (still do) that Roshi had the Lava Release KKG, just like Son Goku, and that that was the reason he was chosen to be his Jinchuuriki.

 

[Dagcy16]

Sand Control [via wiki] As a host of Shukaku, Gaara possesses the ability to freely manipulate sand to serve various purposes.


i remember that i read it somewhere else in the net that gaara uses his chakra (wind chakra as i remember) to carry the sand....


oh goodness....


Error 404: Brain not found!

 

[Floydical]

Or, in the other hand, Roshi was the aproppriated Jinchuuriki because of their compatibility. I mean, maybe Roshi had that Kekkei Genkai of Lava Release. Don't forget this is just speculation yours and mine because there is no fact, we just saw Son lending his lava-based chakra to Naruto, just that.

Uhm? I believed (still do) that Roshi had the Lava Release KKG, just like Son Goku, and that that was the reason he was chosen to be his Jinchuuriki.

Maybe you guys are right.... but it puts doubt into whether or not he had the KKG to begin with. If Roshi has any fans, this might hurt his reputation a bit lol.

 

[Mr Hiru]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

But Gaara's father could also use Sand (golden sand, with the magnetic release).

 

[ShadowBandit]

Roshi inherited his magma style from Son just as Gaara inherited his sand from Shukaku.

I don't know about this, since Gaara father had a kg for magnet release, which some form of it has to be within Gaara since the abilities are quite similar.

Your answer is not right, however i believe more likely Gaara kg was effected by the Shukaku to affiliate it with sand.

 

[Tobi98]

Sand Control [via wiki] As a host of Shukaku, Gaara possesses the ability to freely manipulate sand to serve various purposes.


i remember that i read it somewhere else in the net that gaara uses his chakra (wind chakra as i remember) to carry the sand....


oh goodness....


Error 404: Brain not found!

He uses his chakra to control it but the sand is created and protects Gaara necaus of Shukaku

 

[Dagcy16]

Roshi's Lava Release is not a KG?

Nature Transformation
By borrowing Son Gokū's power, Rōshi was able to use its Lava Release ninjutsu, created through simultaneous use of fire and earth-based chakra, to create a torrent of lava that can melt almost anything. In the anime, Tobi referred to him as "Rōshi of the Lava Release" (熔遁の老紫, Yōton no Rōshi),[1] further indicating his prowess with it.


oh, so you're right!

 

[Dagcy16]

He uses his chakra to control it but the sand is created and protects Gaara necaus of Shukaku

His protection does not came from Shukaku, but from his Mother, right?