Yes but Madara shouldn't know that they knew the technique. He wasn't around during their battle with Edo Nagato. The point is that he shouldn't be able to control who or what is pulled up, anything and everything on the ground should be affected.
Possible, but that would have been easily explained. Even considering this, everything happened so fast that I don't think this was the case.
both are the most plausible explanations i've seen. More to the point, ppl seem to have forgotten about the ability ninja have to stick to something using their chakra lately.
Not a logical explanation. Madara gave no warning of using the tech and no one except Naruto had seen the tech before. Sasuke, Sakura and Kakashi had never seen it before and Kakashi admitted he had no idea what Madara was doing. That gives them no time to react by sticking themselves to the ground. There was no explanation by Naruto and Kishi gave no explanation as to how they weren't sucked up.
Simply not true, I countered this point above.
Floy, stop being a jerk and overlooking everything people say just because you dislike the direction or do not understandit. You're looking for logical explanations and we're giving them to you. Kishimoto does not need to explain a long already used aspect throughout both parts 1 and 2 over and over.
The CT stone is not a satellite as it is within Earth's atmosphere, not outside and Kyuubi Naruto is standing on a stone and being hit by the other stones, not being sucked in himself.
i said it is a plausible explanation. Meaning it is not outside the realm of possibility and it's not outside the realm of possibility since Madara gave them warning when he told them those "raindrops" were going to be harder to handle than they thought. That is warning enough. If they had the presence of mind to counter those CTs the way they did, then you can stop acting like they were completely caught by surprise.
I think you are misinterpreting some of my purpose with my responses. I'm pointing out the inconsistency going on here, its something becoming more and more common in Kishi's work. You are one of the many that will defend Kishi to the end, which is respectable, but you overlook many things. Saying they are out of range is not logical when boulders in almost direct contact with them are moving. Saying laws of gravity are in order when larger objects are attracted does not make sense. If an object is within the range of it gravitational pull, its going to be sucked in regardless of its mass.
Where did the larger body thing come into play? If something is within the gravitational pull of an object, it will be sucked in regardless of mass. There was differing sizes of gravel being pulled up and that is explained by sheer randomness. There is no reason Naruto and co. shouldn't have been pulled up with them.
And I believe you are full of crap.
No, you are pointing out something you do not understand or do not like that others do.
Lol no. Do not throw the fanboy card at me to convenience you. Not an hour ago I was a on a criticism thread revealing the criticisms I have for the series. Do not assume or generalize me. You do not know me and you never will. And clearly you overlook things as well. Do not sit there on your pedestal acting like some deep, all knowing all seeing author or critic and degrade me. I won't tolerate it. So far, you are in no way respectable.
There's no basis for that. The rocks moving beneath Gaara and Lee and not them and Madara stating the rain will be hard for them is more than enough evidence that they are out of range. Seeing boulders in the air in front of them holds no ground because you do not have a far view of them so do not play the "logical" card with me either.
"Newton's law of universal gravitation states that any two bodies in the universe attract each other with a force that is directly proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them. (Separately it was shown that large spherically symmetrical masses attract and are attracted as if all their mass were concentrated at their centers.) This is a general physical law derived from empirical observations by what Isaac Newton called induction.[2] It is a part of classical mechanics and was formulated in Newton's work Philosophiæ Naturalis Principia Mathematica ("the Principia")"
I do because you have the term completely misconceived and are carelessly abusing it. A satellite is a single mass outside a planet's atmosphere orbiting it. The CT is a force that pulls objects of the same mass in, covering it in boulders. This does not make it an actual moon or satellite. The moon is a large piece of the earth that broke off when another proto planet hit it 4.5 billion years ago and over the billions of years became spherical through the influence of its orbit.
He's standing on his feet, is outside the stones and is using senjutsu. He's using chakra to stick to the stone.
What you regard as inconsistent is subjective and subject to different comprehensions and correction. And do not lie and say my points are compelling. You are conveniently and invalidly bypassing each one without so much as attempting to debunk them. There's no intrigue in that, there's only ignorance and disrespect and it makes me ill.
Review Newton's Law that I linked already please.
No, it is explained by them breaking off of the large stones or being on top of them. If you look at when the spheres form, they are completely composed are large boulders in both this chapter and the Chibaku Tensei chapter of the Pein arc.
If they were out of range of being hit by or being on top of the boulders, which they appear to be, there is. I've given my reasoning. Either give yours or drop the topic because you're getting on my nerves.
You're right. They'd just sit there with their thumbs up there asses and watch the show.
Wow, calm down bro, you're getting mad over nothing. I don't know why you bother accusing me of putting myself on a pedestal when that is the exact thing you are doing.
