Sakura Or Kabuto. Who's The Better Medical Ninja?

-Spoiler-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Nov 14, 2010
Messages
7,020
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No he just disproved it. Yo are aware that Katsuyu uses the chakra of the summoner to heal those it's attacked to right. The scans above show that Katsuyu can't heal as well because Tsunade (the one that summoned her is low on chakra) That means that Katsuyu is using Tsunade's chakra to heal.

You stated that Katsuyu does the healing and the summoner's chakra just links everyone. It is the other way around.



No one said that. Katsuyu's chakra is directly tied into the one who summons her.

XD and Sakura haters just don't like to see Sakura excel in anything even what she is good at XD
@bold but she still have heal. so yes the scan confirmed that its Katsuyu's healing
 

Shadow Phantasm

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
11,503
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Kabuto served as Orochimaru's personal medic for years and has immense knowledge of the human body,in terms of feats and experience he beats Sakura in the medical jutsu department.
 

Umari Senju

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
12,535
Kin
238💸
Kumi
96💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Byakugou is a link between Katsuyu and her summonner. That's why without having awakened it, you can't summon her at all. It was stated in manga at least several times that it's Katsyuy's power that heals, not Tsunade's (I mean Remote Healing only ofc).

What's more, the chapter ur scan is from clearly states that Tsunade was so weak, she couldn't even maintain her Kuchiyose. Katsuyu had to do that AND heal Kage at the same time, but the healing was slow due to Tsunade being exhausted and almost dead (so the link between them was weak as well).
You are kind of right but not entirely. You can still summons katsuyu without the seal but it's healing ablitlies become extremely limited, which is what the scan above is showing with Tsunade.

For more reference to what I am talking about:

Offensively, Katsuyu can spit acid using its Tongue Tooth Sticky Acid technique, which is strong enough to melt through rock with ease. With its Slug Great Division, Katsuyu can divide itself into smaller clones to evade attacks or to serve small scale functions, and is capable of quickly reforming itself if need be. Katsuyu's clones can attach themselves to injured people, allowing its summoner to channel their chakra through it to heal the injured person. Katsuyu's clones can also telepathically share information with each other which allows the slug to serve other supplementary purposes when divided such as gathering and dispensing information.[2] Katsuyu could also put Tsunade's bisected form back together, although due to Tsunade being weakened, the process took a considerable amount of time as Katsuyu needed Suigetsu to bring the two halves of her body together before Katsuyu could rejoin her.[3]


Katsuyu begins to deconstruct.
Furthermore, due to its genetic and physical make up, Katsuyu is extremely resistant to damage, as seen during Invasion of Pain Arc. Katsuyu is also able to absorb people into its body, thus protecting them from physical impacts like the large-scale Shinra Tensei using its own high durability.[4][5] A palm-sized version of Katsuyu even survived the corrosive chakra of Naruto's eight-tailed form and Nagato's Chibaku Tensei.[6] Oddly enough, though slugs are typically slow, Katsuyu's clones were fast enough to throw themselves in front of Shizune, Ino and Inoichi before the Animal Path's rhino summon even managed to hit them.[7] Due to its ability to divide, a summoner is able to separately summon her divisions so portions of Katsuyu can be in more than one place at any given time.[8] Also due to this physical make up, the slug is able to alter its bodily form and is able to deconstruct entirely into nothing more than a pool of body fluids. This does not render it incapacitated and Katsuyu is still able to function just as it would if it were corporeal.[9]

Katsuyu has also noted that its power is directly tied in to that of its summoner and their Strength of a Hundred Seal. For that reason, when Tsunade summoned the slug in her weakened condition during the Fourth Shinobi World War, the healing proceeded slowly, as not only was Katsuyu multi-tasking but Tsunade's reserves were extremely low.

Source: narutopedia

So you are half right in this.

@bold but she still have heal. so yes the scan confirmed that its Katsuyu's healing
I am not the one who said Katsuyu can't heal. I know she can. It's just greatly improved by the one who summons her.

And As for the "who heals better" spectrum of this thread This is my final chime on the matter:

I think both kabuto and Sakura represent the 2 spectrums of medical ninja.

One being a healer who uses their gifts ethically and the other who delved into the darker and more forbidden aspects of the healing Arts.

Kabuto's seems more powered because he uses them in more offensive manners than Sakura, Whereas Sakura mainly uses her healing for support.

In terms of healing alone I would put them on par with each other. Kabuto is older so he has more experience in the field for sure. When Sakura reaches his age then we can compare who is better at Medical jutsu. But honestly, at 17 we don't really know what level of medical ninjutsu Kabuto had.

Overall in everything put together, sure Kabuto is the strongest.
 
Last edited:

Nattana

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
6,756
Kin
4💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
You are kind of right but not entirely. You can still summons katsuyu without the seal but it's healing ablitlies become extremely limited, which is what the scan above is showing with Tsunade.

For more reference to what I am talking about:

Offensively, Katsuyu can spit acid using its Tongue Tooth Sticky Acid technique, which is strong enough to melt through rock with ease. With its Slug Great Division, Katsuyu can divide itself into smaller clones to evade attacks or to serve small scale functions, and is capable of quickly reforming itself if need be. Katsuyu's clones can attach themselves to injured people, allowing its summoner to channel their chakra through it to heal the injured person. Katsuyu's clones can also telepathically share information with each other which allows the slug to serve other supplementary purposes when divided such as gathering and dispensing information.[2] Katsuyu could also put Tsunade's bisected form back together, although due to Tsunade being weakened, the process took a considerable amount of time as Katsuyu needed Suigetsu to bring the two halves of her body together before Katsuyu could rejoin her.[3]


Katsuyu begins to deconstruct.
Furthermore, due to its genetic and physical make up, Katsuyu is extremely resistant to damage, as seen during Invasion of Pain Arc. Katsuyu is also able to absorb people into its body, thus protecting them from physical impacts like the large-scale Shinra Tensei using its own high durability.[4][5] A palm-sized version of Katsuyu even survived the corrosive chakra of Naruto's eight-tailed form and Nagato's Chibaku Tensei.[6] Oddly enough, though slugs are typically slow, Katsuyu's clones were fast enough to throw themselves in front of Shizune, Ino and Inoichi before the Animal Path's rhino summon even managed to hit them.[7] Due to its ability to divide, a summoner is able to separately summon her divisions so portions of Katsuyu can be in more than one place at any given time.[8] Also due to this physical make up, the slug is able to alter its bodily form and is able to deconstruct entirely into nothing more than a pool of body fluids. This does not render it incapacitated and Katsuyu is still able to function just as it would if it were corporeal.[9]

Katsuyu has also noted that its power is directly tied in to that of its summoner and their Strength of a Hundred Seal. For that reason, when Tsunade summoned the slug in her weakened condition during the Fourth Shinobi World War, the healing proceeded slowly, as not only was Katsuyu multi-tasking but Tsunade's reserves were extremely low.

Source: narutopedia

SO you are half right in this.
You cannot summon Katsuyu without having awakened the seal in the first place. Once you have, you don't need it present on you forehead to summon her, but you cannot use Remote Healing as well in such state.
 

Miiami

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 28, 2013
Messages
772
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The reason why Orochimaru went to Tsunade for his hands is because she is the best medical ninja, Kabuto isn't. Tsunade=Sakura. So Sakura is better medical ninja than Kabuto, she can operate people, heal thousands of people at once, she can keep a DEAD person alive, she can make an anti-dote with an ease, she has same chakra scalpel as Kabuto, this is the basic thing he was seen using. He was unable to heal a simple injury from Kyuubi that Sakura recieved, he only healed a little bit, even after it Sakura was still in pain and at the moment Sakura is seen to heal much more than that.
 

Umari Senju

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
12,535
Kin
238💸
Kumi
96💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You cannot summon Katsuyu without having awakened the seal in the first place. Once you have, you don't need it present on you forehead to summon her, but you cannot use Remote Healing as well in such state.
Well it states that Katsuyu is directly tied to the seal without actually saying it is needed initiate summoning. ( I always assumed you signed a contract just like any other summon)

But yeah I don't see why this wouldn't be a prerequisite so your point is valid
 

obito uchiha the wraith

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 4, 2013
Messages
5,942
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The reason why Orochimaru went to Tsunade for his hands is because she is the best medical ninja, Kabuto isn't. Tsunade=Sakura. So Sakura is better medical ninja than Kabuto, she can operate people, heal thousands of people at once, she can keep a DEAD person alive, she can make an anti-dote with an ease, she has same chakra scalpel as Kabuto, this is the basic thing he was seen using. He was unable to heal a simple injury from Kyuubi that Sakura recieved, he only healed a little bit, even after it Sakura was still in pain and at the moment Sakura is seen to heal much more than that.
Tsunade couldnt heal orochis hands they were dead no matter what until he got his soul arms back. The fact that you had to ignore all of pt2 kabutos feats and dsm medical feats prooves kabuto is the better medic.
 

Shadow Phantasm

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
11,503
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
The reason why Orochimaru went to Tsunade for his hands is because she is the best medical ninja, Kabuto isn't. Tsunade=Sakura. So Sakura is better medical ninja than Kabuto, she can operate people, heal thousands of people at once, she can keep a DEAD person alive, she can make an anti-dote with an ease, she has same chakra scalpel as Kabuto, this is the basic thing he was seen using. He was unable to heal a simple injury from Kyuubi that Sakura recieved, he only healed a little bit, even after it Sakura was still in pain and at the moment Sakura is seen to heal much more than that.
Given the fact Kabuto acted as Orochimaru's personal medic in keeping experiments alive for longer and has techniques that can regenerate wounds,I would'nt be so quick as to say Sakura is a better medical ninja than him.Keep in mind that Sakura had the greatest medical expert around to teach her while Kabuto is mostly self taught.
 

Nattana

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 5, 2013
Messages
6,756
Kin
4💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Given the fact Kabuto acted as Orochimaru's personal medic in keeping experiments alive for longer and has techniques that can regenerate wounds,I would'nt be so quick as to say Sakura is a better medical ninja than him.Keep in mind that Sakura had the greatest medical expert around to teach her while Kabuto is mostly self taught.
I would risk saying that Orochimaru is the most knowledgeable character in NV in terms of sinister medical jutsu, so saying that Kabuto had no teacher is false.
 

Shadow Phantasm

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 29, 2013
Messages
11,503
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I would risk saying that Orochimaru is the most knowledgeable character in NV in terms of sinister medical jutsu, so saying that Kabuto had no teacher is false.
Does Orochimaru know medical jutsu?No.
Can he heal others?No

So aside from the fact Orochimaru having no medical experience beyond knowing what makes the human body tick and no medical jutsu to speak of, how is the claim of Kabuto being self taught false exactly?
 

super yang

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jun 2, 2014
Messages
4,204
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: Sakura Or Kabuto. Who's Has better supplementary NINJUTSU~

the thread title is insubstantial. they both have mystical palms

Kabuto has the much better yin/inton -ninjutsu-...sakura only has one
 
Last edited:
Top