[Discussion] Rank the SHs based on intelligence

[Uzumaki Macho]

Here's how I would organize them into tiers:

Genius: Robin, Nami, Franky

Smart: Sanji, Chopper (excellent at medicine but too naive), Usopp, Brook

Average: Zoro

Dumb : Luffy


Here's my ranking for them (not completely confident with some of these):

1. Robin
2. Nami
3. Franky
4. Chopper/Sanji
5. Sanji/Chopper
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Zoro
9. Luffy

 

[Belserion]

Agree with Robin but I think Usop is underrated.

Good list

 

[Sakazuki]

Yeah I'd put chopper and usopp higher than franky

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Yeah I'd put chopper and usopp higher than franky

Franky has to be pretty smart if he could make himself into a cyborg and build the Sunny Go, so he should be above those two.

 

[Dgrayman]

I agree fully, perfect list

 

[Azarath Metrion Zinthos]

Yeah I'd put chopper and usopp higher than franky

Usopp is more coward smart, bro.

 

[Love Cook]

Here's how I would organize them into tiers:

Genius: Robin, Nami, Franky

Smart: Sanji, Chopper (excellent at medicine but too naive), Usopp, Brook

Average: Zoro

Dumb : Luffy


Here's my ranking for them (not completely confident with some of these):

1. Robin
2. Nami
3. Franky
4. Chopper/Sanji
5. Sanji/Chopper
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Zoro
9. Luffy

I agree almost completely with this list, but I would rate Sanji on 4 and Chopper on 5.

Chopper knows a lot of medical stuff, but he still is a little dumbass every now and then. You won't catch the top 4 doing any rash or stupid things, but the rest has some questionable behavior.

 

[Bimbonium]

I don't agree with the genius tier. Robin is pretty smart learning to read the poneglyphs at such a young age is an impressive feat, but her intelligence hasn't yielded anything in recent years. (can't really recall anything particularly smart she's done since joining the SHs).

Also, can't really call Franky intelligent, he learnt how to build ships and he's very good at it (probably the best), but then it just about ends there. he's very intelligent (only) when it comes to building things, hasn't shown any other intelligence feat.

If you put all the SHs in a room with some haxx puzzle. I see them solving it in this order.

Robin
Sanji/Usopp
Usopp/Sanji
Nami
Chopper
Franky
Brook
Zoro
Luffy.

 

[MickNerks]

1. Robin
2. Franky
3. Chopper/Nami
4. Nami/Chopper
5. Sanji
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Zoro/Luffy
9. Luffy/Zoro


If this is a list on intelligence than Franky should definitely be higher than Nami. And Choppers knowledge of Medicine should be on par with Nami's Navigation.

 

[ArabianLuffy]

Some ranking I agree on with Uzumaki Macho, but here's my ranking:

[table="width: 500"]
[tr]
[td]Uzumaki Macho's Ranking[/td]
[td]ArabianLuffy's Ranking[/td]
[/tr]
[tr]
[td]1. Robin
2. Nami
3. Franky
4. Chopper/Sanji
5. Sanji/Chopper
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Zoro
9. Luffy[/td]
[td]1. Robin
2. Nami
3. Sanji
4. Franky
5. Usopp
6. Brook
7. Chopper
8. Zoro
9. Luffy[/td]
[/tr]
[/table]

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

1. Robin
2. Franky
3. Chopper/Nami
4. Nami/Chopper
5. Sanji
6. Brook
7. Usopp
8. Zoro/Luffy
9. Luffy/Zoro


If this is a list on intelligence than Franky should definitely be higher than Nami. And Choppers knowledge of Medicine should be on par with Nami's Navigation.

Why are Luffy and Zoro equal? Zoro isn't an idiot.

 

[Sakazuki]

Usopp is more coward smart, bro.

Still, though out the story he seemed one of the more intelligent members too me

 

[squalll]

1. Nami
2. Usopp
3. Franky
4. Chopper
5. Robin
6. Sanji
7. Usopp
8. Zoro
9. Luffy

 

[Itachi Minato]

Zoro is not a moron lol. He just has a shit sense of direction.

1. Robin
2. Sanji
3. Nami
4. Franky
5. Brook
6. Ussop
7. Chopper
8. Zoro
9. Luffy

 

[LBeezy]

Your list is pretty solid..

But, Nami above Franky tho?

I think I'd also put Usopp above Brook and maybe even Chopper..

Sanji may also be above Nami as well..

 

[Skull Knight]

So where does jimbei stands in the list???

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

You put the tech-wiz Usopp under Nami, the one who's been inventing her weapons for years now and sanji on par with a medical doctor chopper?
Sanji is as aware as Zoro realistically speaking. Zoro's stupidity in loss of direction is equivalent to Sanji moronic activities pertaining to anything female related.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

You put the tech-wiz Usopp under Nami, the one who's been inventing her weapons for years now and sanji on par with a medical doctor chopper?
Sanji is as aware as Zoro realistically speaking. Zoro's stupidity in loss of direction is equivalent to Sanji moronic activities pertaining to anything female related.

Oda said that Nami was the 3rd smartest character from the East Blue (with Beckman as #1 and Kuro as #2). This automatically puts Nami above the other crew members from the East Blue.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Oda said that Nami was the 3rd smartest character from the East Blue (with Beckman as #1 and Kuro as #2). This automatically puts Nami above the other crew members from the East Blue.

If we're using that SBS shouldn't she be #1 then?

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

Oda said that Nami was the 3rd smartest character from the East Blue (with Beckman as #1 and Kuro as #2). This automatically puts Nami above the other crew members from the East Blue.

What Sbs was this because I know it's an old one. I don't see Kuro being the second smartest either regarding other legendary pirates that came from there.
Unless you're saying nami is smart enough to create her own Clima-Tact?