[Discussion] Pain and Itachi

Pain VS Itachi.. Who Would Win?!?!?


  • Total voters
    160
Status
Not open for further replies.

Stampy

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 14, 2010
Messages
711
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
AGREED. However, when people claim that pain wins for sure just because he has 6 bodies, I have to defend itachi's side as well. All I'm saying is that this isn't a battle that has a clear winner so let's all agree with this. And if someone actually says that one of them wins 100% they should start reading every argument that was brought up until now.

Nice debate guys! Both sides deserve respect for bringing up so many strong points.
Yup. Agreed. (BTW I gave arguments on both sides lol, even I aren't decided).
 

NarutoVsGoku

Active member
Elite
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
5,036
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
wow this discussion went on longer than i expected it to... once again i appreciate everyones input..

i didnt go through everyones arguements yet and i wish i had participated more but skimming through i think Pain has the best arguements and best chances of winning this fight..

biggest reasons are

1. Rinnegan vs Sharingan (Mangekyou)- Rinnegan is a more powerful technique. both Nagato and Itachi were masters of their doujutsu but Nagato has the better eye jutsu

2. 6 on 1. Pain geniusly spreads his Rinnegan and powers to 6 bodies. each Pain is a force on its own but to take on 6 at a time is murder. Itachi would put up a good fight, maybe even take out most of the bodies but his chances are low because he's outnumbered.

3. Pain's techniques are very secretive. Itachis techniques arent. Pain has the element of suprise.. only technique that Itachi could suprise Pain with is the Sealing Sword (forget the name) that his Sasuno wields and the Sheild also..
 

Stampy

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 14, 2010
Messages
711
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
wow this discussion went on longer than i expected it to... once again i appreciate everyones input..

i didnt go through everyones arguements yet and i wish i had participated more but skimming through i think Pain has the best arguements and best chances of winning this fight..

biggest reasons are

1. Rinnegan vs Sharingan (Mangekyou)- Rinnegan is a more powerful technique. both Nagato and Itachi were masters of their doujutsu but Nagato has the better eye jutsu

2. 6 on 1. Pain geniusly spreads his Rinnegan and powers to 6 bodies. each Pain is a force on its own but to take on 6 at a time is murder. Itachi would put up a good fight, maybe even take out most of the bodies but his chances are low because he's outnumbered.

3. Pain's techniques are very secretive. Itachis techniques arent. Pain has the element of suprise.. only technique that Itachi could suprise Pain with is the Sealing Sword (forget the name) that his Sasuno wields and the Sheild also..
I think you forgot THE key element: Chibuka Tensei.
 

-The Agent-

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 27, 2010
Messages
4,511
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
wow this discussion went on longer than i expected it to... once again i appreciate everyones input..

i didnt go through everyones arguements yet and i wish i had participated more but skimming through i think Pain has the best arguements and best chances of winning this fight..

1. Rinnegan vs Sharingan (Mangekyou)- Rinnegan is a more powerful technique. both Nagato and Itachi were masters of their doujutsu but Nagato has the better eye jutsu

2. 6 on 1. Pain geniusly spreads his Rinnegan and powers to 6 bodies. each Pain is a force on its own but to take on 6 at a time is murder. Itachi would put up a good fight, maybe even take out most of the bodies but his chances are low because he's outnumbered.

3. Pain's techniques are very secretive. Itachis techniques arent. Pain has the element of suprise.. only technique that Itachi could suprise Pain with is the Sealing Sword (forget the name) that his Sasuno wields and the Sheild also..
Welcome Back.
1) Rinnegan is more Powerful than the MS
2) 6 on 1. Naruto took out all 6 with SM with the help of Katsyu (slug) about their powers. Jiraiya took out the first three pains he encountered. Itachi can probably do the same since he is smarter (than naruto), and probably stronger(than J man). Deducing each power and how to defeat each one.
3) Even so, with the MS I think Itachi can deduce each Path easily. Nagato would probably do the same to Itachi.
 

Stampy

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 14, 2010
Messages
711
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Welcome Back.
1) Rinnegan is more Powerful than the MS
2) 6 on 1. Naruto took out all 6 with SM with the help of Katsyu (slug) about their powers. Jiraiya took out the first three pains he encountered. Itachi can probably do the same since he is smarter (than naruto), and probably stronger(than J man). Deducing each power and how to defeat each one.
3) Even so, with the MS I think Itachi can deduce each Path easily. Nagato would probably do the same to Itachi.
In terms of pure strength I'm pretty sure that Jman owns Itachi. Not saying he would win against Itachi (which I don't believe so)... Just saying Jman has more brute force.
 

pemayozer

Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
328
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
this thread sucks donkeys @ss.....
This is a no brainer still u people are fighting over it
if itachi was stronger then he would be the leader of akatsuki...
simple as it is ...
 

Anub

Active member
Regular
Joined
Aug 11, 2008
Messages
1,575
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
this thread sucks donkeys @ss.....
This is a no brainer still u people are fighting over it
if itachi was stronger then he would be the leader of akatsuki...
simple as it is ...
No, it's not. Itachi joined only after the akatsuki was established. How could he be a leader if there was already a leader? Also, he didn't even want to be the leader of akatsuki. And the leader was Tobi in fact and Tobi WAS afraid of Itachi (if you don't know why, please refer to the manga). Your logic is flawed.

i didnt go through everyones arguements yet and i wish i had participated more but skimming through i think Pain has the best arguements and best chances of winning this fight..
Well if you didn't go through all the arguments how can you say that pain has the best ones? I'm pretty sure I mare some strong arguments for Itachi, which from a logic point of view work quite well in his favor.
 
Last edited:

pemayozer

Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2010
Messages
328
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No, it's not. Itachi joined only after the akatsuki was established. How could he be a leader if there was already a leader? Also, he didn't even want to be the leader of akatsuki. And the leader was Tobi in fact and Tobi WAS afraid of Itachi (if you don't know why, please refer to the manga). Your logic is flawed.



Well if you didn't go through all the arguments how can you say that pain has the best ones? I'm pretty sure I mare some strong arguments for Itachi, which from a logic point of view work quite well in his favor.
my boy u have taken being wary as being taken afraid..
reading managa is not it u have to understand...
in all his heart itachi wanted to protect konoha, it was very dear to him, dear enought for him to kill off his own clan including his mom and dad.
If he could kill so mant people for konaha to be @ piece wat would stop him from killing pein knowing what big of a threat akatski is....
the ans is simple wat stopped him was the fact he knew he culdnt defea pain, so he chose to stay with akatsuki and keep an eye on them..
and as far as my logic goes, if itachi was that almight he could have replcaed pein.
 

nrto60

Active member
Regular
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
730
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
And don't forget itachi was a born prodigy.... Extremely intelligent... His strongest point is genjutsu or was since he is dead... Anyway, he didn't like to get in the mess of physical attacks and battles...... And only an uchiha could break free of tsukuyomi, like sasuke did.... And if pain was easily caught in the sage frog genjutsu, i don't think that the battle b/w itachi and nagato would last more than 10 mins...... No exaggeration here...., even madara was afraid of itachi, and madara was the one pulling strings behind akatsuki from the beginning...... Madara himself admitted that if itachi knew everything about him, then he would have been dead..... And thats sayin somethin.......
 

nrto60

Active member
Regular
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
730
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
my boy u have taken being wary as being taken afraid..
reading managa is not it u have to understand...
in all his heart itachi wanted to protect konoha, it was very dear to him, dear enought for him to kill off his own clan including his mom and dad.
If he could kill so mant people for konaha to be @ piece wat would stop him from killing pein knowing what big of a threat akatski is....
the ans is simple wat stopped him was the fact he knew he culdnt defea pain, so he chose to stay with akatsuki and keep an eye on them..
and as far as my logic goes, if itachi was that almight he could have replcaed pein.
Itachi did love konoha, but he didn't want anyone to know this fact..... No one besides the three head councillors, 3rd hokage and madara, knew that itachi was a good guy..... Itachi himself posed as a bad guy, rogue ninja... And itachi wanted sasuke to defeat him and become a hero to konoha, he NEVER wanted to tell sasuke or anyone that he loved his village and wasn't rogue..... He took the blame on himself and died hoping that no one would know his truth....... Thats why he remained a part of akatsuki, to pose as a rogue ninja....... And in case you haven't noticed, he never wanted to capture naruto.... He sort of liked naruto cuz naruto loved sasuke....... And itachi believed that naruto would be able to change sasuke's heart...... But that bit didnt go as planned, you see, madara knew everything about itachi and itachi was afraid that sasuke might learn the truth.... So he implanted amaterasu in sasuke's eyes HOPING THAT IT WOULD FINISH OFF MADARA........
 

nrto60

Active member
Regular
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
730
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I think i have provided enough info to clear the fact that why itachi remained as a part of akatsuki if he was stronger than pain.... He wanted everyone to believe that he was the BAD guy....
 

platinum69

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 11, 2008
Messages
2,692
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Itachi will own with Susanoo and the sword that can seal anything and the shield that cant be broken... plus Genjutsu...

Nagato Vs Itachi would be awesome...
 

-The Agent-

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 27, 2010
Messages
4,511
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Itachi will own with Susanoo and the sword that can seal anything and the shield that cant be broken... plus Genjutsu...

Nagato Vs Itachi would be awesome...
That's what I was thinking Susano'o with Yata Mirror, and Totsuka sword is pretty much impossible to beat..
Even without Susanoo, Jiraiya took out three Paths with a SM style genjutsu and we know Itachi is a genjutsu master he could probably do the same with stronger Genjutsu techniques.

Nagato vs Itachi would be a hell of a battle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top