[Discussion] One Piece: Underrated & Overrated

xanonymosx

Banned
Regular
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
511
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
shanks overrate isnt because some people thinks he is the srongest in the world that could very well be true (though it`s drgon for me ) but becasue some people put him on diffrent level and a claim he would beat WB which is BS , he can comfortly high diff akainu or mihawk which is BS or he can beat other admirals with ease which is BS too he is not on roger`s lvl inb4 riker jumping and saying there is no pk lvl and roger would need extreme diff to defeat an admiral
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
shanks overrate isnt because some people thinks he is the srongest in the world that could very well be true (though it`s drgon for me ) but becasue some people put him on diffrent level and a claim he would beat WB which is BS , he can comfortly high diff akainu or mihawk which is BS or he can beat other admirals with ease which is BS too he is not on roger`s lvl inb4 riker jumping and saying there is no pk lvl and roger would need extreme diff to defeat an admiral
How you know I was bouta drop them facts on you.

Nah, you right. I mean, obviously the feat of Pirate King, which no person can ever accomplish on their own, makes the person who has it above everyone else.

Anyways, Shanks, Whitebeard, Roger, the Admirals and Mihawk are all on the same general level. You only need about half a brain to see that honestly. I don't really know why people expect Shanks and Mihawk to be regularly sparring partners if they aren't on the same level, especially when Mihawk doesn't concern himself with people who aren't a challenge for him unless you're Zoro.
 
Last edited:

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
An old, severely injured, and sick WB could beat Akainu so Roger could definitely beat Akainu and several other top tiers at less than extreme diff.
 
Last edited:

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
An old, severely injured, and sick WB could beat Akainu so Roger could definitely beat Akainu and several other top tiers at less than extreme diff.
Yes, leaving someone with the strength to take on all but two of your commanders, a former Shichibukai and dozens of other pirates with minor wounds and no sign of slowing down is defeating them, marvelous.
 
Last edited:

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yes, leaving someone with the strength to take on all but two of your commanders, a former Shichibukai and dozens of other pirates with minor wounds and no sign of slowing down is defeating them, marvelous.
Oda clearly portrayed WB as superior in that encounter but whatever. Even if Akainu was somehow stronger than WB when they fought off the second time, WB was stronger than him before he received all of his injuries and Marco commented on how WB has had a noticeable decrease in strength since his prime.

LOL How are those people overrated/underrated?
Roger and WB are underrated since some people think any top tier can push them to extreme diff.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Hexuze

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Roger and WB are underrated since some people think any top tier can push them to extreme diff.
And who are those people? A few, right? I don't see how that makes those characters underrated here since it's the minority who believes that any top tier can push them to extreme diff. It's not overrating if they do believe that either lol. There's people who think WB/Roger can mid diff. admirals dude.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
Oda clearly portrayed WB as superior in that encounter but whatever. Even if Akainu was somehow stronger than WB when they fought off the second time, WB was stronger than him before he received all of his injuries and Marco commented on how WB has had a noticeable decrease in strength since his prime.
Okay? I am not doubting that Whitebeard is stronger. Just not this much. Marco noted a decrease in his reaction speed. Never was it indicated that Whitebeard's damage output was reduced, just his reaction speed and stamina. For all we know, his Gura powers were unaffected by his age. But I digress. It's far more sensible for the top tiers of a series to be able to extreme diff each other. The fact that Whitebeard unleashing his wrath on Akainu only managed to slow him down is testament to that.
LOL How are those people overrated/underrated?
Because thinking the strongest the protagonist side has to offer can match up the strongest the antagonist side has to offer in a work of fiction is just asinine.
 

Anduril

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,892
Kin
42💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
LOL How are those people overrated/underrated?
Overrated:
Akainu/Admirals - A dying wounded WB nearly killed an admiral and people say a prime whitebeard would win against any admiral at High diff.
Sanji - He got his leg fractured (His main fighting weapon) could not save his crew on his own and still people say he is close to Zoro who has not even been injured bar some scratches here and there.
Smoker - Smoker was beaten to a pulp by vergo and people compare him with Zoro who actually has defeated a logia out of pure blood lust. And there is no way of telling that Pica's FBH was any weaker or stronger than vergo's FBH.
Vergo - Peopl seem to think his FBH is something more terrible when compared to Pica's FBH, when they have absolutely zero proof of it since both have the same black colored visual similarity.

Underrated:
Blackbeard - People think he is like the third strongest yonkou or something which is under-rating.
Whitebeard & Roger - People say prime WB or Roger would go High diff against any marine admiral which is laughable.
Rayleigh - Highly under-rated the same way as prime Roger and Whitebeard are.
 
Last edited:

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
With the way some people wank Whitebeard and Roger here, Whitebeard should have been able to send Shanks flying through the floorboards of his ship when they clashed :lol

If Whitebeard almost killed Sakazuki, then means that Sakazuki while close to death can't be taken down by all of Whitebeard's commanders bar two while they were enraged at him with only one of them being injured, and dozens if not hundreds of pirates as back-up while on his own. And that just makes him even more of a beast.
 
Last edited:

Anduril

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,892
Kin
42💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
With the way some people wank Whitebeard and Roger here, Whitebeard should have been able to send Shanks flying through the floorboards of his ship when they clashed :lol

If Whitebeard almost killed Sakazuki, then means that Sakazuki while close to death can't be taken down by all of Whitebeard's commanders bar two while they were enraged at him with only one of them being injured, and dozens if not hundreds of pirates as back-up while on his own. And that just makes him even more of a beast.


It is the same thing as Doflamingo is doing today. People said Law's Gamma knife made doffy so weak that he is 0% of his original strength which (LOL) is being hilarious.

Because the same guy has now withstood the whole Brute force of Gear 4, his Bird cage has not weakened an inch and is still beating the fodder's to a pulp. Same thing that Akainu was doing >_>

So much for wanking Law and then saying people wank WB LOL, I mean the amount of Hypocrisy in some people is so damn high.


P.S: The WB who stalemated shanks is still an old whitebeard on life support, not the whitebeard who drank sake with roger. :bdpf:
 
Last edited:

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Okay? I am not doubting that Whitebeard is stronger. Just not this much. Marco noted a decrease in his reaction speed. Never was it indicated that Whitebeard's damage output was reduced, just his reaction speed and stamina. For all we know, his Gura powers were unaffected by his age. But I digress. It's far more sensible for the top tiers of a series to be able to extreme diff each other. The fact that Whitebeard unleashing his wrath on Akainu only managed to slow him down is testament to that.


Because thinking the strongest the protagonist side has to offer can match up the strongest the antagonist side has to offer in a work of fiction is just asinine.
Whitebeard had a decrease in reaction speed, lost his Observation Haki, and lost his Kings Haki, which you are making seem like a very tiny decrease in strength. Why would they even bother naming WB the WSM if any other top tier could push him to extreme diff? Crocodile doesn't have Haki, the other pirates helping the division commanders don't have Haki, and we don't even know which division commanders besides Marco, Jozu, and Vista have Haki or not, so Akainu not receiving any serious injuries during his short fight with the division commanders isn't as impressive as you're making it out to be.
 

Hexuze

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Overrated:
Akainu/Admirals - A dying wounded WB nearly killed an admiral and people say a prime whitebeard would win against any admiral at High diff.
You do know that WB suffered more during that battle, right? Yes, I know it a wounded WB but I thought I'd make that clear for you and as Riker mentioned here, Akainu was still able to take on the rest of the WB commanders & Croc. after his battle with WB. Look what happened to WB after his battle with Akainu, look who he lost to.
Sanji - He got his leg fractured (His main fighting weapon) could not save his crew on his own and still people say he is close to Zoro who has not even been injured bar some scratches here and there.
Aside from the Vergo scenario, I doubt Zoro would of been able to save the crew. I don't see how thinking Sanji is close to Zoro would be overrating his character, if they suggest Sanji is stronger or perhaps even equal then yeah you could say that's overrating.
Smoker - Smoker was beaten to a pulp by vergo and people compare him with Zoro who actually has defeated a logia out of pure blood lust.
Are you really comparing Monet to Vergo? Monet got one shot'd by Tashigi right after. Smoker got beaten to a "pulp" because he was trying to retrieve Law's heart back.
Vergo - Peopl seem to think his FBH is something more terrible when compared to Pica's FBH, when they have absolutely zero proof of it since both have the same black colored visual similarity.
How does that make him overrated then?

Underrated:
Blackbeard - People think he is like the third strongest yonkou or something which is under-rating.
He is & it's not much a stretch to state that so I don't see how that makes him underrated. BB and his crew ran off from Akainu and BB recently got his GGnM powers, I don't see how he can master that and be competent in haki over a 2 year TS. We don't know how strong Big Mam or the rest of the yonko's, they just have hype.
Whitebeard & Roger - People say prime WB or Roger would go High diff against any marine admiral which is laughable.
It's more laughable that people think WB/Roger can mid diff a top tier.
Rayleigh - Highly under-rated the same way as prime Roger and Whitebeard are.
Same reason as above.

It is the same thing as Doflamingo is doing today. People said Law's Gamma knife made doffy so weak that he is 0% of his original strength which (LOL) is being hilarious.

Because the same guy has now withstood the whole Brute force of Gear 4, his Bird cage has not weakened an inch and is still beating the fodder's to a pulp. Same thing that Akainu was doing >_>

So much for wanking Law and then saying people wank WB LOL, I mean the amount of Hypocrisy in some people is so damn high.


P.S: The WB who stalemated shanks is still an old whitebeard on life support, not the whitebeard who drank sake with roger. :bdpf:


@bold
It's funny how you said this in another thread...
P.S: I don't understand why the word "wank" comes into this thread. Just because someone's opinion differs from the majority does not mean they wank that charachter. I also see Sanjo getting 6 votes, does that mean they wank sanji?
The level of stupidity in this thread is too damn high.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
You do know that WB suffered more during that battle, right? Yes, I know it a wounded WB but I thought I'd make that clear for you and as Riker mentioned here, Akainu was still able to take on the rest of the WB commanders & Croc. after his battle with WB. Look what happened to WB after his battle with Akainu, look who he lost to.

Aside from the Vergo scenario, I doubt Zoro would of been able to save the crew. I don't see how thinking Sanji is close to Zoro would be overrating his character, if they suggest Sanji is stronger or perhaps even equal then yeah you could say that's overrating.

Are you really comparing Monet to Vergo? Monet got one shot'd by Tashigi right after. Smoker got beaten to a "pulp" because he was trying to retrieve Law's heart back.

How does that make him overrated then?

Underrated:

He is & it's not much a stretch to state that so I don't see how that makes him underrated. BB and his crew ran off from Akainu and BB recently got his GGnM powers, I don't see how he can master that and be competent in haki over a 2 year TS. We don't know how strong Big Mam or the rest of the yonko's, they just have hype.

It's more laughable that people think WB/Roger can mid diff a top tier.

Same reason as above.





@bold
It's funny how you said this in another thread...
LMAO he's reaching. His post isn't really worth responding to.
 

A v i

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Whitebeard lost his capacity to use his haki properly,it has gotten drastically weaker thanks to his health related problems. His haki at MF was nowhere near what we have seen from him during his clash with Shanks. Someone like Sqado shouldn't be able to stab him if his haki was anywhere near as good as it should be. Shanks effortlessly blocked Akainu's magma fist where as Whitebeard took complete damage from every single attack despite having the capacity to use just as much impressive if not better haki than Shanks.

There wasn't a single instant where Akainu managed to lang a blow on him when they were fighting head on. Whitebeard was unhealthy,suffered from a stab through his chest,his reactions, haki and stamina were decreased by a great margin yet said admiral failed to put a dent on him until he actually became vulnerable to any incoming attack thanks to his chest pain. Akainu at best is capable of defeating Whitebeard with unbelievable handicaps that to with the cost of suffering from some serious damages. There is no reason to believe Akainu or any active admiral can fight on par with Whitebeard when he's in a perfect condition.

Shanks wasn't much below Whitebeard but Akainu is.
 
Last edited:

Anduril

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,892
Kin
42💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You do know that WB suffered more during that battle, right? Yes, I know it a wounded WB but I thought I'd make that clear for you and as Riker mentioned here, Akainu was still able to take on the rest of the WB commanders & Croc. after his battle with WB. Look what happened to WB after his battle with Akainu, look who he lost to.
Read the quoted part again, but I don't think you understand it :sdo:, since you quoted it and your eyes only zoomed to the "wank" part.

It is the same thing as Doflamingo is doing today. People (this was actually said by riker salad) said Law's Gamma knife made doffy so weak that he is 0% of his original strength which (LOL) is being hilarious.

Because the same guy has now withstood the whole Brute force of Gear 4, his Bird cage has not weakened an inch and is still beating the fodder's to a pulp. Same thing that Akainu was doing >_>


So much for wanking Law and then saying people wank WB LOL, I mean the amount of Hypocrisy in some people is so damn high.


P.S: The WB who stalemated shanks is still an old whitebeard on life support, not the whitebeard who drank sake with roger.



Aside from the Vergo scenario, I doubt Zoro would of been able to save the crew. I don't see how thinking Sanji is close to Zoro would be overrating his character, if they suggest Sanji is stronger or perhaps even equal then yeah you could say that's overrating.
So I'll say that you accepted the vergo scenario? Sanji got his bone cracked. Now wait for it.

Are you really comparing Monet to Vergo? Monet got one shot'd by Tashigi right after.
:lmao: I am not comparing Monet with vergo, I am comparing how a Logia was unable to bring herself together without anything like Radio knife being used on her. And Tashigi one shotted her, cause Zoro had already finished the fight.


Smoker got beaten to a "pulp" because he was trying to retrieve Law's heart back.
What? Smoker was hunting vergo, he would never help a pirate unless that was the only thing he could have done in that scenario. If he could have, he would have knocked out vergo and then handed Law his heart back LOL try something call common sense next time. Smoker helped Law as a last resort.

How does that make him overrated then?
Errm Mr. :sdo:, maybe because it was that they don't have a substantial proof but still think vergo was stronger than Pica which some people consider an example of over-rating.

And we go back to sanji, if we have no way of telling if Vergo was stronger or weaker than Pica, then considering either of those scenarios. We have Zoro who defeated a FBH without strechting it far while we have sanji who got his Leg cracked against a FBH user. So, I don't think they are close no.

Underrated:

He is & it's not much a stretch to state that so I don't see how that makes him underrated. BB and his crew ran off from Akainu and BB recently got his GGnM powers, I don't see how he can master that and be competent in haki over a 2 year TS. We don't know how strong Big Mam or the rest of the yonko's, they just have hype.
Yes the rest of the yonkou just have hype, while BB has "Yami Yami no mi - strongest Logia df" & "Gura Gura no mi - one of the most destructive paramecia type" + He already showed a pretty good use of the Gura Gura no mi against Sengoku (at least almost all the attacks WB showed), so I don't know where this mastered shit comes from. He also took control of all the WB territory, do you think the other Yonkou would have let him do that?
So the rest of the yonkou only have hype while BB has all the above things. No wonder he is weaker :sdo:

It's more laughable that people think WB/Roger can mid diff a top tier.

Same reason as above.
So you self proclaimed that all admirals are in the same league as Prime WB and Prime Roger and that makes more sense, yeah right.


@bold
It's funny how you said this in another thread...
And if you would try to understand the fact that it was another thread + your bosom buddy Riker salad was the one who used that word first.

That's it for today's the :sdo: show.
 

A v i

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Read the quoted part again, but I don't think you understand it :sdo:, since you quoted it and your eyes only zoomed to the "wank" part.








So I'll say that you accepted the vergo scenario? Sanji got his bone cracked. Now wait for it.



:lmao: I am not comparing Monet with vergo, I am comparing how a Logia was unable to bring herself together without anything like Radio knife being used on her. And Tashigi one shotted her, cause Zoro had already finished the fight.




What? Smoker was hunting vergo, he would never help a pirate unless that was the only thing he could have done in that scenario. If he could have, he would have knocked out vergo and then handed Law his heart back LOL try something call common sense next time. Smoker helped Law as a last resort.



Errm Mr. :sdo:, maybe because it was that they don't have a substantial proof but still think vergo was stronger than Pica which some people consider an example of over-rating.

And we go back to sanji, if we have no way of telling if Vergo was stronger or weaker than Pica, then considering either of those scenarios. We have Zoro who defeated a FBH without strechting it far while we have sanji who got his Leg cracked against a FBH user. So, I don't think they are close no.



Yes the rest of the yonkou just have hype, while BB has "Yami Yami no mi - strongest Logia df" & "Gura Gura no mi - one of the most destructive paramecia type" + He already showed a pretty good use of the Gura Gura no mi against Sengoku (at least almost all the attacks WB showed), so I don't know where this mastered shit comes from. He also took control of all the WB territory, do you think the other Yonkou would have let him do that?
So the rest of the yonkou only have hype while BB has all the above things. No wonder he is weaker :sdo:



So you self proclaimed that all admirals are in the same league as Prime WB and Prime Roger and that makes more sense, yeah right.




And if you would try to understand the fact that it was another thread + your bosom buddy Riker salad was the one who used that word first.

That's it for today's the :sdo: show.

Only a few selected individuals in our Narutobase community tend to have that kind of delusional beliefs. So I guess you can't really referred to it as those characters getting overrated in general.
 

Anduril

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Mar 17, 2011
Messages
12,892
Kin
42💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️

Only a few selected individuals in our Narutobase community tend to have that kind of delusional beliefs. So I guess you can't really referred to it as those characters getting overrated in general.
Well those selected members are the one's who tend to be more active on the community. But if you talk about in-general then, yeah I can only tell one name

Underrated: Blackbeard.
 

A v i

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
shanks overrate isnt because some people thinks he is the srongest in the world that could very well be true (though it`s drgon for me ) but becasue some people put him on diffrent level and a claim he would beat WB which is BS , he can comfortly high diff akainu or mihawk which is BS or he can beat other admirals with ease which is BS too he is not on roger`s lvl inb4 riker jumping and saying there is no pk lvl and roger would need extreme diff to defeat an admiral
I don't understand how it's same as him getting overrated though. He was chosen to be Rogers successor by PK himself.Rayleigh who was noted to be closest to Roger implied that Luffy's hat isn't for show.You need to have certain qualities to be wroth of being a man that can wear it.. Being one of three people with right qualities to wear Roger's hat with two of them being PK and future PK says a lot about his potential. You could actually say that Shanks is the current undisputed king of seas in OP.

Someone as short tempered as Akainu , the same guy who doesn't fear battling Whitebeard, The guy who attacked all of his commanders without a second thought just for killing Luffy completely restrained himself from making a move when Shanks stood in his path. He was disparate to kill Luffy yet hopeless to make a move as a wall that can't be broken by him stood in his way. He made a fellow Yonko quit his biggest objective, he stopped the best war in history, He made Blackbeard know his place as the later changed his mind about him being strongest as soon as he saw Shanks and quit his plans about destroying MF. He accomplished everything purely with words, without getting serious. His silent accomplishments alone says how terrifying he can be.


One doesn't make people wet their dresses while chilling around unless it's Shanks. ;)


I won't say Shanks (or even Whitebeard) is so strong that he can mid or low dif admirals but the gap is significantly big and definitely not marginal. Any admiral stands a decent chance against any top rated fighter but chances of them pulling a win or getting closer to brining them to their absolute limits in a one on one scenario are clearly equal to 0.

 
Last edited:
Top