Or Yonko' door.Welp, they're screwed. That's what happens when you keep knocking on the Devil' door.
![]()
The rockets were never going to work since they were a kill shot and Oda doesn't kill many characters especially when Luffy's involved in fighting them. But the plan to beat BM is still alive since she's susceptible to something as minor as falling and it makes her bleed so with the power in the room they may be able to beat her down still. The escape plan is also destroyed which is something no one seems to be pointing out, so with no retreat route how else will they get out of the situation if not by beating BM?Damn the plan backfired real quick, I felt the plan was too simple to ever work especially on a yonko anyway.
Now it really looks like BM won't be going down this arc, after the flashback, I think Elbaf would be a fitting place for her end.
BM crew beats them down and cue James Bond trope. Big Mom starts gloating as he crew holds them at weapon-point, she opens the Tamebako box, it explodes and weakens her, her crew drops post to rush to her head, they bail out. Badda bing, badda boom, move on to the objectively better Big Mom vs Kaido storyline.The rockets were never going to work since they were a kill shot and Oda doesn't kill many characters especially when Luffy's involved in fighting them. But the plan to beat BM is still alive since she's susceptible to something as minor as falling and it makes her bleed so with the power in the room they may be able to beat her down still. The escape plan is also destroyed which is something no one seems to be pointing out, so with no retreat route how else will they get out of the situation if not by beating BM?
So in other words they have to beat BM enough to cause the rest of her crew to divert attention from them to her to allow them to leave. And how is that that different than our side of the BM bet?BM crew beats them down and cue James Bond trope. Big Mom starts gloating as he crew holds them at weapon-point, she opens the Tamebako box, it explodes and weakens her, her crew drops post to rush to her head, they bail out. Badda bing, badda boom, move on to the objectively better Big Mom vs Kaido storyline.
I could give a damn about your bet. This is how they can escape without actually defeating BM even if she has the power advantage on her side, nothing more, nothing less.So in other words they have to beat BM enough to cause the rest of her crew to divert attention from them to her to allow them to leave. And how is that that different than our side of the BM bet?
But they would end up defeating her though, if BM's hurt by the bomb to the point SH's and Bege can leave WCI unchased then they defeated her. For someone who couldn't give a damn about the bet you sure were arguing hard against it for the last month or so, I was just pointing out that technically if it went the way you said that'd be a win for the Luffy side of the Luffy beats BM bet.I could give a damn about your bet. This is how they can escape without actually defeating BM even if she has the power advantage on her side, nothing more, nothing less.
That is in no way defeating her.But they would end up defeating her though, if BM's hurt by the bomb to the point SH's and Bege can leave WCI unchased then they defeated her. For someone who couldn't give a damn about the bet you sure were arguing hard against it for the last month or so, I was just pointing out that technically if it went the way you said that'd be a win for the Luffy side of the Luffy beats BM bet.
In what way would it not be beating her? If she's damaged to the extent her crew rushed to check on her disregarding all else, what else would you call it? If the bomb leaves her in a state too weak to pursue or stop the SH's from leaving what is it? What do you consider beating her? Does Luffy have to do it himself for you to consider her beat?That is in no way defeating her.
I don't care about your little bet with all these technicalities. My argument has always been Big Mom's defeat will be at Kaido's hand later in the story, not in WCI by Luffy's.
Defeating her would be what happened to Crocodile, Rob Lucci, Enel, Crocodile, Moriah, or Caesar. Big Mom slumping long enough for them to pull off a quick escape is not defeating her, it's retreating, which means it's Big Mom's W.In what way would it not be beating her? If she's damaged to the extent her crew rushed to check on her disregarding all else, what else would you call it? If the bomb leaves her in a state too weak to pursue or stop the SH's from leaving what is it? What do you consider beating her? Does Luffy have to do it himself for you to consider her beat?
Why do you insist both can't happen? Just because Luffy beats her now wouldn't mean she'd be unavailable to fight Kaido also.
Now we're just splitting hairs on the speed of the retreat really. You call it a quick escape I call it them being able to walk off and we're both saying it our way because it helps our case. If she doesn't get up before their boat leaves the island that's not a W for her, that's equivalent to someone walking into your house wrecking your living room knocking you out then driving home and you wake up later pissed off looking for revenge. If she retains consciousness through the explosion then sure but if she's KO'd then I disagree.Defeating her would be what happened to Crocodile, Rob Lucci, Enel, Crocodile, Moriah, or Caesar. Big Mom slumping long enough for them to pull off a quick escape is not defeating her, it's retreating, which means it's Big Mom's W.
This is true but it would also serve to boost Luffy's hype while down playing hers. And just because something would be less impactful if A happened first isn't a reason it can't happen. And if it happens the way of the Tamatebako then I don't see the real issue as Luffy's strength wouldn't have defeated her but his luck and in that case it would be just as impactful.Wouldn't have the same impact if she's already been defeated by Luffy, someone clearly below her level, when Kaido defeats her. Be way more impactful if her fearsomeness as an Emperor is shown by her group defeating Luffy's, forcing them to retreat. If it's someone Luffy's group can handle, then it's underwhelming to see Kaido defeat them.
Uh, no, that's not what it's like at all. It's like a group walking into your home, wrecking your living room, knocking out one person, and then needing to run away because they realized the group who live in the home would beat the shit out of them all. If two parties are fighting, and one needs to retreat because the other one was stronger, then that's not a defeat for the overwhelming party.Now we're just splitting hairs on the speed of the retreat really. You call it a quick escape I call it them being able to walk off and we're both saying it our way because it helps our case. If she doesn't get up before their boat leaves the island that's not a W for her, that's equivalent to someone walking into your house wrecking your living room knocking you out then driving home and you wake up later pissed off looking for revenge. If she retains consciousness through the explosion then sure but if she's KO'd then I disagree.
I'd prefer Oda to remain consistent, to boost Luffy's hype without having to sloppily dismantle others', and give us something new while doing so.This is true but it would also serve to boost Luffy's hype while down playing hers.
Lol right, because the less epic option is always what every story should rush towards.And just because something would be less impactful if A happened first isn't a reason it can't happen. And if it happens the way of the Tamatebako then I don't see the real issue as Luffy's strength wouldn't have defeated her but his luck and in that case it would be just as impactful.
You just said her crew would rush to tend to her allowing the SH's to leave, you can't have it both ways either she's hurt enough it draws their attention away or she's hurt but not so bad that the rest of her crew attacks in her place. @bold tell that to every guerilla army ever. You can still get a W even if you have to flee by doing enough damage during the skirmish. IF BM comes back then Luffy will have won this skirmish but not the war thus BM can still fight Kaidou without losing any hype since Luffy's victory here is based on luck not raw power. So the argument of "epic" starts to lose ground when Luffy's W doesn't come from Luffy himself.Uh, no, that's not what it's like at all. It's like a group walking into your home, wrecking your living room, knocking out one person, and then needing to run away because they realized the group who live in the home would beat the shit out of them all. If two parties are fighting, and one needs to retreat because the other one was stronger, then that's not a defeat for the overwhelming party.
I'd prefer Oda to remain consistent, to boost Luffy's hype without having to sloppily dismantle others', and give us something new while doing so.
Lol right, because the less epic option is always what every story should rush towards.
What the hell are you talking aboutYou just said her crew would rush to tend to her allowing the SH's to leave, you can't have it both ways either she's hurt enough it draws their attention away or she's hurt but not so bad that the rest of her crew attacks in her place.
Not really. If you run away because you can't beat the enemy force, then that's your loss regardless of what damage you caused.@bold tell that to every guerilla army ever. You can still get a W even if you have to flee by doing enough damage during the skirmish.
It's not as epic to see a force like Kaido beat Big Mom if a far inferior force like Luffy's can do the same thing. If Luffy can get it done, even with the Tame box, then Kaido doing it goes from "Holy shit, he actually did it" to "Well, yeah, that's what you were supposed to do Kaido." It reduces the impressiveness of it way too much.IF BM comes back then Luffy will have won this skirmish but not the war thus BM can still fight Kaidou without losing any hype since Luffy's victory here is based on luck not raw power. So the argument of "epic" starts to lose ground when Luffy's W doesn't come from Luffy himself.
Two Emperors going at it and one taking the other out IS "unexpected" because it's not something that's ever happened before in the manga. We've had indication that Emperors don't fight each other much, so it'll be a major event for the entire OP world. The contrary is a cliche "Main character has to beat everyone" story. This would be amazing given the scale of the characters, and it'd not only be new for One Piece, but it'd be objectively good writing because it avoids a cliche.And just out of curiosity why is it more epic to you to have a power like a Yonko defeat another Yonko rather than someone unexpected?