[Game] Naruto Mafia Game [Game Thread]
- Thread starter Poison
- Start date
- Status
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
So it's more like knowing about player's flavor/alignment and not player's ability.
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
Or he can only learn about what ability the targeted player used at that night. And then deduce it himself using his knowledge.
Just_Red
Active member
Awards
Thank You. Good to know that Godfather is innocent, now if i ever get the role again, I'll be more cautious!
Vote: @Finalbeta
Reason: he played me, real bad
Post automatically merged:
*she
Rohan
Active member
Awards
Since I was asked here is my opinion:-
1- Danzo the Survivor was weak in this setup. With so many kills in this game the Survivor should have been given X amount of bulletproof. The Cult recruit blocking ability is also iffy because if Tsunadae died early in the game, the Cult would have been heavily weakened. As an example if Tsunadae was daykilled in Day 1, the Cult will be unable to recruit a single player. The best thing to do here would be to give Tsunadae X shot of day bulletproof ability.
2- Lovers should not be of seperate alignments, they should always be of the same alignment. Having lovers of different alignments can make the game frustrating for the players especially if one lover is Pro-Town and the other is Anti-Town. You can do it but then you must give the lovers the option of eliminating everyone and winning as a Custom lovers faction. There was no need to mention the "of any alignment" as it can cause the player to be confused.
3- [ Active Ability : Chibaku Tensai ] : The player visiting you in night phase will lose voting ability in day phase .
Voteless ability should not be used at all as it goes against the basic principles of a mafia game. A player without a vote cannot influence the flow of the day phase.
4- There is no need to post in the mafia role PM "You are immune to recruit". This should be a hidden mechanic. By doing this, the Mafia was alerted of the existence of a Cult the moment they got the Role PM which gave the Mafia an advantage through a loophole.
5- [Passive: Sage of six paths]: Once you gain the nine tail beast, you fully transform into sage of six paths. You will have power to perform and revive your faction.
Revival mechanics should not be used in mafia games as it is imbalanced and unfair. This thread makes some good points on this matter: https://animebase.me/threads/the-mafia-game-hosting-commandments.765263/.
6- Flavour is part of a role as mentioned here: https://animebase.me/threads/animebase-mafia-game-overview-and-rules.764463/#post-21900969. If role claiming is forbidden then flavour claiming by default is forbidden.
Good job hosting the game.
1- Danzo the Survivor was weak in this setup. With so many kills in this game the Survivor should have been given X amount of bulletproof. The Cult recruit blocking ability is also iffy because if Tsunadae died early in the game, the Cult would have been heavily weakened. As an example if Tsunadae was daykilled in Day 1, the Cult will be unable to recruit a single player. The best thing to do here would be to give Tsunadae X shot of day bulletproof ability.
2- Lovers should not be of seperate alignments, they should always be of the same alignment. Having lovers of different alignments can make the game frustrating for the players especially if one lover is Pro-Town and the other is Anti-Town. You can do it but then you must give the lovers the option of eliminating everyone and winning as a Custom lovers faction. There was no need to mention the "of any alignment" as it can cause the player to be confused.
3- [ Active Ability : Chibaku Tensai ] : The player visiting you in night phase will lose voting ability in day phase .
Voteless ability should not be used at all as it goes against the basic principles of a mafia game. A player without a vote cannot influence the flow of the day phase.
4- There is no need to post in the mafia role PM "You are immune to recruit". This should be a hidden mechanic. By doing this, the Mafia was alerted of the existence of a Cult the moment they got the Role PM which gave the Mafia an advantage through a loophole.
5- [Passive: Sage of six paths]: Once you gain the nine tail beast, you fully transform into sage of six paths. You will have power to perform and revive your faction.
Revival mechanics should not be used in mafia games as it is imbalanced and unfair. This thread makes some good points on this matter: https://animebase.me/threads/the-mafia-game-hosting-commandments.765263/.
6- Flavour is part of a role as mentioned here: https://animebase.me/threads/animebase-mafia-game-overview-and-rules.764463/#post-21900969. If role claiming is forbidden then flavour claiming by default is forbidden.
Good job hosting the game.
Sagebee
Active member
Awards
@Poison chan @Dr.Strange thanks for hosting probably most fun mafia game ive been in from mechanical perspective
@Dr.Strange how did 6th hokage die?
Only member I was surprised about was finalbeta really thought June was mafia.
Dragomir and madie were obvious mafia.
I say odd is mvp just for getting Michelle
Post automatically merged:
@Dr.Strange how did 6th hokage die?
Only member I was surprised about was finalbeta really thought June was mafia.
Dragomir and madie were obvious mafia.
I say odd is mvp just for getting Michelle
Last edited:
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
And I'm suspect Finalbeta
Post automatically merged:
Yeah Michelle was very tricky.
Post automatically merged:
Anything to say 6thHokage?
Last edited:
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
Thanks for the 'Premium'
My MVP nomination goes to Odd.
He was very active giving his thoughts on who were Mafia in the death chat. Very helpful.
Post automatically merged:
My MVP nomination goes to Odd.
He was very active giving his thoughts on who were Mafia in the death chat. Very helpful.
Post automatically merged:
You said every game setup need to be reviewed/examined first but how you missed that? Who reviewed Poison's Setup?
Last edited:
Rohan
Active member
Awards
I let SK do the review of the game. I was not involved.Thanks for the 'Premium'
Post automatically merged:
My MVP nomination goes to Odd.
He was very active giving his thoughts on who were Mafia in the death chat. Very helpful.
Post automatically merged:
You said every game setup need to be reviewed/examined first but how you missed that? Who reviewed Poison's Setup?
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
I want to play until the game end like usual
Post automatically merged:
Yeah I know I've killed(lynched) you a lot before. Revenge is sweet
I'm not so futile but it was your turn to die. :catthinks:I want to play until the game end like usual
Post automatically merged:
Yeah I know I've killed(lynched) you a lot before. Revenge is sweet
Michelle
Active member
Awards
This was the most enjoyable game from the perspective of a Narutard like me.
Being Itachi was awesome and very cool.
I admired Odd for his plan and I didn't have the opportunity to talk with him in the dead player chat because i had to leave that chat as a possible revival player with the use of Juubi's ability.
I take this chance to thank @Odd for showing me that Mafia should be played to win it.
About the Dead players chat i didn't read it and i would like to add me there - @Rohan if possible.
Being not for sure dead and not alive and because i didn't know how to leave the DPC in the first time i played the turbo game with my alt Felix, the fluffy user. It's a confirmation of how bad i play as scum u.u
I liked very much Ansatsuken like usual, and Red as newcomer, congrats for being so good. Gister and Sagebee played too strong and attracted unfortunately too much attention. I am sorry i didn't have patience to wait for the lynch results of the first day and so i revealed for the best intuitive players my role.
I was dissapointed by the all conversation who finished with Gutsy leaving the game. I don't want to comment more but if something like this will happen again i will leave the mafia section. I saw on other forum how toxic is an argument inside a game and i wish to ask @everyone to avoid this kind of things.
For me the MVP is @Finalbeta who played very good the innocence card until the end.
Big thanks for the hosts, @Poison chan and @Dr.Strange they were amazing.
I have just one thing, the vote format being so rigid it was impossible to see which vote is correct in day 1 too see the lynch tally.
Being Itachi was awesome and very cool.
I admired Odd for his plan and I didn't have the opportunity to talk with him in the dead player chat because i had to leave that chat as a possible revival player with the use of Juubi's ability.
I take this chance to thank @Odd for showing me that Mafia should be played to win it.
About the Dead players chat i didn't read it and i would like to add me there - @Rohan if possible.
Being not for sure dead and not alive and because i didn't know how to leave the DPC in the first time i played the turbo game with my alt Felix, the fluffy user. It's a confirmation of how bad i play as scum u.u
I liked very much Ansatsuken like usual, and Red as newcomer, congrats for being so good. Gister and Sagebee played too strong and attracted unfortunately too much attention. I am sorry i didn't have patience to wait for the lynch results of the first day and so i revealed for the best intuitive players my role.
I was dissapointed by the all conversation who finished with Gutsy leaving the game. I don't want to comment more but if something like this will happen again i will leave the mafia section. I saw on other forum how toxic is an argument inside a game and i wish to ask @everyone to avoid this kind of things.
For me the MVP is @Finalbeta who played very good the innocence card until the end.
Big thanks for the hosts, @Poison chan and @Dr.Strange they were amazing.
I have just one thing, the vote format being so rigid it was impossible to see which vote is correct in day 1 too see the lynch tally.
Ansatsuken
Active member
Awards
But you won with forgottoflush as a mafia before
Post automatically merged:
You played great. No one suspecting you. Your death was just a luck for townie. Townie actually did nothing to setup that 'trap'. Its pure luck
- Status