[Theory] Meadows: Whitebeard's Champion of D-Block?!

WhistleBlower

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Messages
27,716
Kin
4,460💸
Kumi
1,041💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
With the new chapter around the corner, D-Block has ended. All but one fighter, who went unseen, lays defeated. However, one of the named fighters did not appear on the defeated panels: Meadows.

I'm betting this man is the victor of D-Block, and will actually be revealed to be Vista of the Whitebeard Pirates. Before I get into why I think it would be Meadows, I will explain why I do not believe it will be Rebecca with Haki (the second most likely case), or the idea that Meadows is Kaidou which has been tossed around for a while today.

First off, I find the idea of it being Conquerer Haki to be unlikely. First we have Chinjao using Conquerers in the C-Block fight . Not only did it not leave a huge plum of smoke hiding his presence, but many fighters had no issue surviving it. I find it unlikely that everyone in Block-C are ALL levels above D-Block. I also do not think that Rebecca (if she used it) would be able to use it better than Chinjao or Luffy who have had YEARS to train it. Many fighters at Marineford even survived it.

All in all... I feel it is unlikely that CoC was the culprit.

Some people have also claimed this is Kaidou; however, there's no way it should be Kaidou. Just look at Big Mom. The thought of making a deal with Luffy drove her to rage. Blackbeard sent a SUBORDINATE to go get it. Why would Kaidou go himself?

A high ranking/first mate level Kaidou pirate would be a better guess, but Kaidou seems only into Zoans. Also, I think he's in a position to simply tell Doflamingo he wants it.

You must be registered for see images


Firstly, we know Oda ALWAYS brings everything into his works. I mean even Doflamingo's "Smile" comment later on was given purpose. Of the D-Block fighters... Meadows was the only one who wasn't shown in the fighting. Which means Oda has to have some plan for him. In my opinion... it is him as the victor of this fight.


I also believe that he is Vista for the following reasons.

1. With Ace's fruit on the line, the Whitebeard Pirates should seemingly make a move for it.

2. Sabo's comment of, "I've heard rumors of this." could possibly reference to Sabo's earlier talk with Koala. Sabo had wanted to be at the Summit War, but couldn't make it. This could mean that Sabo heard rumor of Vista's attack, but has never seen it.

3. Appearance wise, he can plausibly match.

You must be registered for see images


A) His moustache is similar... the key differences being that his is not split, and his is more upright... but we still haven't seen him post-timeskip.


B) The grin Vista has parallels Meadows's grin.


C) They have similar teeth styles.


D) They have similar Noses during close ups.





3. This idea would also parallel the Blackbeard Pirates' actions here.


A) We know that the Blackbeard Pirates have taken on the use of the same Division system Whitebeard used, and Burgess was sent. Similarly, we could say with Marco now in charge, Vista was sent.


B) Burgess entered the tournament he hid himself in disguise. Vista would be hiding his face and calling himself with the Cheetah mask.



4. The name Meadows. One could think of a meadow as a field of flowers. Vista is known as the, "Flower
Swordsman." So the name could also symbolize his fighting style.





Naturally it is hard to say for now. Aside from this, the other two plausible situations would be Rebecca with Conquerers or plausibly Meadows being someone else. Considering what we saw with Luffy and Chinjao using Conquerers as well as Rebecca being seen down (even if her eye appears open), I find her more likely to have lost.


Meadows being the only one left, it simply depends on if he is Kaidou's man, Vista, or even his own entity; however, based on what I've said above, I feel like Vista is a pretty solid shot.
Instead of these recent thoughts, I believe our D-Block victor is Meadows who is actually Vista.

NOT MINE: TAKEN FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE

 
Last edited by a moderator:

sleepinsleuth

Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2012
Messages
451
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
my bet is that it's going to be demask. you can see fire on the ring; and he is a pyromaniac. also two of his three straps; for his mask, aren't shown to be strapped in his collapsed pic. he probably wheres like a hanzo mask thing because he breaths fire. so he can cap it.
 

reizon

Banned
Legendary
Joined
Sep 5, 2012
Messages
10,244
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
everytime I read any op threads, I get goosebumps.!!
op being onepiece... lol.!!

since its all going to make sense, its good reading op threads, understanding things that you neglected.!!
 

TheLastSamurai

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 29, 2011
Messages
4,521
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I actually hope the OP is correct, it would be a nice moment for the WB pirates to come back and maybe assist the Straw hat's in their battle against Doflamingo/Kaidou.
 

WhistleBlower

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Messages
27,716
Kin
4,460💸
Kumi
1,041💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I actually hope the OP is correct, it would be a nice moment for the WB pirates to come back and maybe assist the Straw hat's in their battle against Doflamingo/Kaidou.
I really hope so too!!! :nuts: Its a absolute must to see the remnants of the Whitebeard Pirates ASAP!!
:x3:
Plus, i can see them finding out about the prize of the tournament and coming. How awesome would it be if all them came to dressrosa or are nearby on standby
You must be registered for see images


Marco, Jozu, Vista would be of great help > Donquixote Pirates :whip:
 
Last edited:

Dr Strangelove

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 20, 2011
Messages
10,057
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Read this before.
Don't think it will be Vista.
Cool if it was, but I think they still look very different.
Although it is very likely to be something to do with Meadows as to why D Block got like that.
 

Caliburn

Supreme
Joined
Apr 6, 2009
Messages
20,771
Kin
2,805💸
Kumi
525💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
With the new chapter around the corner, D-Block has ended. All but one fighter, who went unseen, lays defeated. However, one of the named fighters did not appear on the defeated panels: Meadows.

I'm betting this man is the victor of D-Block, and will actually be revealed to be Vista of the Whitebeard Pirates. Before I get into why I think it would be Meadows, I will explain why I do not believe it will be Rebecca with Haki (the second most likely case), or the idea that Meadows is Kaidou which has been tossed around for a while today.

First off, I find the idea of it being Conquerer Haki to be unlikely. First we have Chinjao using Conquerers in the C-Block fight . Not only did it not leave a huge plum of smoke hiding his presence, but many fighters had no issue surviving it. I find it unlikely that everyone in Block-C are ALL levels above D-Block. I also do not think that Rebecca (if she used it) would be able to use it better than Chinjao or Luffy who have had YEARS to train it. Many fighters at Marineford even survived it.

All in all... I feel it is unlikely that CoC was the culprit.

Some people have also claimed this is Kaidou; however, there's no way it should be Kaidou. Just look at Big Mom. The thought of making a deal with Luffy drove her to rage. Blackbeard sent a SUBORDINATE to go get it. Why would Kaidou go himself?

A high ranking/first mate level Kaidou pirate would be a better guess, but Kaidou seems only into Zoans. Also, I think he's in a position to simply tell Doflamingo he wants it.

You must be registered for see images


Firstly, we know Oda ALWAYS brings everything into his works. I mean even Doflamingo's "Smile" comment later on was given purpose. Of the D-Block fighters... Meadows was the only one who wasn't shown in the fighting. Which means Oda has to have some plan for him. In my opinion... it is him as the victor of this fight.


I also believe that he is Vista for the following reasons.

1. With Ace's fruit on the line, the Whitebeard Pirates should seemingly make a move for it.

2. Sabo's comment of, "I've heard rumors of this." could possibly reference to Sabo's earlier talk with Koala. Sabo had wanted to be at the Summit War, but couldn't make it. This could mean that Sabo heard rumor of Vista's attack, but has never seen it.

3. Appearance wise, he can plausibly match.

You must be registered for see images


A) His moustache is similar... the key differences being that his is not split, and his is more upright... but we still haven't seen him post-timeskip.


B) The grin Vista has parallels Meadows's grin.


C) They have similar teeth styles.


D) They have similar Noses during close ups.





3. This idea would also parallel the Blackbeard Pirates' actions here.


A) We know that the Blackbeard Pirates have taken on the use of the same Division system Whitebeard used, and Burgess was sent. Similarly, we could say with Marco now in charge, Vista was sent.


B) Burgess entered the tournament he hid himself in disguise. Vista would be hiding his face and calling himself with the Cheetah mask.



4. The name Meadows. One could think of a meadow as a field of flowers. Vista is known as the, "Flower
Swordsman." So the name could also symbolize his fighting style.





Naturally it is hard to say for now. Aside from this, the other two plausible situations would be Rebecca with Conquerers or plausibly Meadows being someone else. Considering what we saw with Luffy and Chinjao using Conquerers as well as Rebecca being seen down (even if her eye appears open), I find her more likely to have lost.


Meadows being the only one left, it simply depends on if he is Kaidou's man, Vista, or even his own entity; however, based on what I've said above, I feel like Vista is a pretty solid shot.
Instead of these recent thoughts, I believe our D-Block victor is Meadows who is actually Vista.

NOT MINE: TAKEN FROM SOMEWHERE ELSE

There has been speculated quite a lot about Meadows the past few weeks, but personally I still prefer the Kaidou theory. Fact is that quite a lot of your arguments you give for it being Vista can easily apply, and sometimes even better, to Kaidou. On top of that your argument that you give for Meadows not being Kaidou isn't very strong.

Following common sense it would indeed be highly unlikely for someone who is one of the most powerful people in the world to go undercover and participate himself. The problem is that you are talking about someone you know nothing about. We know nothing about his personality, so regardless whether it's logical or not, it's possible he is so weird he would do it. I mean how many of these people are normal?

On top of that Kaidou has every reason to be involved in this matter as Doflamingo is his dealer in artificial DF for his army. This is not a small matter and could definitely be considered important enough for him himself to move out. I already explained this more detailed a while ago in the official chapter discussion thread.

I mean there is a vague picture of Kaidou, one that shows he has a very similar mustache to Meadows, much more than Vista. Likewise you say meadows is a flower field, I looked it up a while ago too and it said it was a grassy field, which could be tied to Kaidou's animal theme as such an environment is suited for animals. As you can see you can almost freely interpret something like that till it fits you.

The comment about Sabo I personally find quite random and just turned in such a way you can use it. I mean Sabo was anticipating the attack of the captain of the 5th WB division?

Personally I also find that that one picture of Meadows and the ones we have of Vista don't really resemble each other much:

You must be registered for see images


Quite a long face, while Meadows has quite a wide face. I admit that the one picture of Meadows isn't a very clear one, but still.

Similar teeth and nose? Those are extremely common, especially the teeth. Also Meadows smile is much wider than Vista's. Vista's smile doesn't exceed the line of his eyes, however Meadows' smile does. The eyes don't really match either. Of course this could all be just Oda's drawing, he does that regularly.

But there is one flaw with your Vista theory and that is that why would Vista disguise himself? The WB pirates definitely have a reason to be there, but why the disguise? I mean Luffy is disguised because they are at war with Doflamingo and Burges is a wrestler, he likes such drama, the fact that he revealed his identity after he won the first round clearly proves that. But why would Vista do it? From what we have seen he really doesn't seem to have the personality to start cosplaying and there is currently no reason for the WB pirates to hide themselves as far as we know. You draw a parallel with the BB pirates, but I don't really see why that is needed as they aren't particularly connected in such a way that they have to mimic everything the other one does.
 
Last edited:
Top