Massive Izanagi misconception i see all the time

naruttebayo

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
5,525
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No i never said they wouldn't lose their eyesight...I said it would make them OP'd.

What I meant by this is that Itachi explained the arrogant Uchihas would keep changing results until their liking. I'm guessing after the results they would lose their eyesight for good but whatever results they've made is strictly from Izanagi. That means any fodder Uchiha could do w.e the hell they want in a fight or real life situations until they feel pleased.

You must be registered for see images

i dunno how to take this ..............

so do you think an eye which casts izanagi can be used again if not pushed to it's time limit ????????????
 
Last edited:

Troyg39

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
3,369
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No i never said they wouldn't lose their eyesight...I said it would make them OP'd.

What I meant by this is that Itachi explained the arrogant Uchihas would keep changing results until their liking. I'm guessing after the results they would lose their eyesight for good but whatever results they've made is strictly from Izanagi. That means any fodder Uchiha could do w.e the hell they want in a fight or real life situations until they feel pleased.

You must be registered for see images
I get what you're saying but I think you're missing what I'm getting at just a little bit. This is why I feel like the Izanami explanation was just a bad one. Notice how Itachi says clearly that the uchihas were using it too much for themselves. He also said they were fighting one another about which result to use. So breaking this down:

He pretty much said that each Uchiha member was able to use Izanagi several times, and without losing their eye sight after one use because otherwise they wouldn't be able to use it but only twice (one time per each eye).

So taking this into consideration, that would mean that they couldn't be losing their eye sight after the results (a bolded part you said) because they Itachi implied they were using Izanagi to change various results. Now add in the fact that you said these Uchihas didnt have senju dna, and it really seems odd.

In other words how do they end up losing their eye sight after the result if they can use it over and over again? Either they reached their result, deactivated it, and saved it, or they reached their result, deactivated it, and loss their eye sight.

It's pretty much the same thing as saying without senju dna, they can change various results, but with senju dna, they can increase the time limit of the jutsu, but they will lose their eye sight after achieving one result
 
Last edited:

naruttebayo

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
5,525
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
That's why they had two eyes. They can re do things over and over again like Itachi explained.
in your previous post as you said why uchiha were inferior to senju, the answer to that answers this too i guess

I don't agree that Izanagi required senju dna. If the 1st Uchihas who discovered Izanagi were using senju dna to enhance their powers, then why haven't we've seen more Uchihas with senju powers. Wouldn't the senju dna allow the Uchihas to top over the Senju Clan. Sorry but this theory isn't probable see that Izanagi was almost common knowledge.
and how do you think there was a stone tablet for so many forbidden jutsu's including the rinnegan .
according to tobi izanagi was used by the s06p himself (i remeber it's stated somewhere)
imo using izanagi is easier than getting rinnegan but it requires senju dna.
if uchiha could use izanagi so much they will definitely be above senju
the fact that one needs senju dna and loses an eyesite is exactly the reason why uchiha were never above senju.
u see izanagi was never easy to use in the first place.
 

Dantee

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
45,244
Kin
0💸
Kumi
343💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
and how do you think there was a stone tablet for so many forbidden jutsu's including the rinnegan .
according to tobi izanagi was used by the s06p himself (i remeber it's stated somewhere)
imo using izanagi is easier than getting rinnegan but it requires senju dna.
if uchiha could use izanagi so much they will definitely be above senju
the fact that one needs senju dna and loses an eyesite is exactly the reason why uchiha were never above senju.
u see izanagi was never easy to use in the first place.
Didn't Madara create the tablet or the Elder son. I forget and I also don't remember Tobi saying that. I think you mean Creation of all things. What I'm saying is if Uchihas were using Senju Dna to make themselves stronger there were other benefits besides Izanagi to put them over Senjus. It just wouldn't make any sense. At the same time if we had Uchihas w.Senju dna back then wouldn't we see vice versa?


I get what you're saying but I think you're missing what I'm getting at just a little bit. This is why I feel like the Izanami explanation was just a bad one. Notice how Itachi says clearly that the uchihas were using it too much for themselves. He also said they were fighting one another about which result to use. So breaking this down:

He pretty much said that each Uchiha member was able to use Izanagi several times, and without losing their eye sight after one use because otherwise they wouldn't be able to use it but only twice (one time per each eye).

So taking this into consideration, that would mean that they couldn't be losing their eye sight after the results (a bolded part you said) because they Itachi implied they were using Izanagi to change various results. Now add in the fact that you said these Uchihas didnt have senju dna, and it really seems odd.

In other words how do they end up losing their eye sight after the result if they can use it over and over again? Either they reached their result, deactivated it, and saved it, or they reached their result, deactivated it, and loss their eye sight
I don't think you meant several times, but more like multiple times right?

I disagree because like the OP explained they can change results because of the time limit Izanagi has. Add to the fact another Uchiha can use it and them we have Uchihas changing realities all willy nilly. Maybe they didn't lose their eyesight because they kept changing their results? That would make the most sense imo.
 

Troyg39

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
3,369
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I don't think you meant several times, but more like multiple times right?

I disagree because like the OP explained they can change results because of the time limit Izanagi has. Add to the fact another Uchiha can use it and them we have Uchihas changing realities all willy nilly. Maybe they didn't lose their eyesight because they kept changing their results? That would make the most sense imo.
Hmm. I guess I'm having a hard time accepting it because I feel like their time limit without senju dna would be too short for them to have used it as often as Itachi seemed to implied.
 

naruttebayo

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
5,525
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Didn't Madara create the tablet or the Elder son. I forget and I also don't remember Tobi saying that. I think you mean Creation of all things. What I'm saying is if Uchihas were using Senju Dna to make themselves stronger there were other benefits besides Izanagi to put them over Senjus. It just wouldn't make any sense. At the same time if we had Uchihas w.Senju dna back then wouldn't we see vice versa?
nope tobi said about s06p that's how i remeber it
and probaly stone tablet was created by elder son most probably ............ leave it there

think about izanami and izanagi and it's use
why would izanami would be created by uchiha to stop an fellow uchiha

if you think uchiha can use it without senju dna, also if they don't lose the eyesite wouldn't they (uchiha clan) be invincible
i mean if you have izanagi users in your army throw them in to the battle and you'll never get bad result cuz the user being immune to death
fact that izanami was created by the uchiha themselves to stop another uchiha suggests that they were dangerous to their own clan. (may be stealing eye).

see the first user so6p was creater of izanagi(he already had both yin & yang)

but izanami was created latter to stop the izanagi users by the uchiha.

further i don't see that why senju dna is unimportant for the izanagi cuz you are playing with death itself.
you need both yin and yang

nagato had rinnegan he could fake the death of others
i see izanagi as a small version of that casting on oneself to avoid death, if uchiha don't need senju dna they will simply be to hax and above senju.
 

Dantee

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
45,244
Kin
0💸
Kumi
343💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
nope tobi said about s06p that's how i remeber it
and probaly stone tablet was created by elder son most probably ............ leave it there

think about izanami and izanagi and it's use
why would izanami would be created by uchiha to stop an fellow uchiha

if you think uchiha can use it without senju dna, also if they don't lose the eyesite wouldn't they (uchiha clan) be invincible
i mean if you have izanagi users in your army throw them in to the battle and you'll never get bad result cuz the user being immune to death
fact that izanami was created by the uchiha themselves to stop another uchiha suggests that they were dangerous to their own clan. (may be stealing eye).

see the first user so6p was creater of izanagi(he already had both yin & yang)

but izanami was created latter to stop the izanagi users.

further i don't see that why senju dna is unimportant for the izanagi cuz you are playing with death itself.
you need both yin and yang

nagato had rinnegan he could fake the death of others
i see izanagi as a small version of that casting on oneself to avoid death, if uchiha don't need senju dna they will simply be to hax and above senju.
Thats why people had this discussion all the time because it didn't make much sense. Tbh I'm not kishi and he doesn't clearify things to often but I just don't see Uchihas having Senju dna outside of Madara and Tobi.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Troyg39

Troyg39

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
3,369
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Thats why people had this discussion all the time because it didn't make much sense. Tbh I'm not kishi and he doesn't clearify things to often but I just don't see Uchihas having Senju dna outside of Madara and Tobi.
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Don't know if you are right about it not requiring senju dna, but you are right that you can release it and save the eye before it loses it's eye sight
 

naruttebayo

Active member
Elite
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
5,525
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Thats why people had this discussion all the time because it didn't make much sense. Tbh I'm not kishi and he doesn't clearify things to often but I just don't see Uchihas having Senju dna outside of Madara and Tobi.
as you can see the image i posted above (#19)

it was not that tough to get senju dna

further in the stone tablet which existed long before madara, must have indication on how to get izanagi .
that's right both yin and yang as madara said.
it's not a big deal if people before madara were using izanagi. it looks like izanagi was known even outside (danzou)

izanagi fakes the death that's why it requires both yin and yang.
izanami is simply the greatest genjutsu it doesn't require yang.

however both technique require the sacrifice of an eye.
 

Dantee

Member
Joined
Jan 29, 2012
Messages
45,244
Kin
0💸
Kumi
343💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
as you can see the image i posted above (#19)

it was not that tough to get senju dna

further in the stone tablet which existed long before madara, must have indication on how to get izanagi .
that's right both yin and yang as madara said.
it's not a big deal if people before madara were using izanagi. it looks like izanagi was known even outside (danzou)

izanagi fakes the death that's why it requires both yin and yang.
izanami is simply the greatest genjutsu it doesn't require yang.

however both technique require the sacrifice of an eye.
Besides the fact you don't have any proof and it's highly improbable..... it would be bad story telling on Kishi's part if Uchihas knew senju dna would strengthen their powers (Madara aside.) I don't agree with you but you are entitled to believe what you want.
 

FlemSmack

Active member
Regular
Joined
Aug 31, 2012
Messages
921
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Izanagi is not a genjutsu. It actually changes reality.

When you cast it you are going to lose the eye no matter if you needed it or not.
 
Top