Dude. How can you possibly still be trying to argue this. Lee uses gates>pain from gates from before during and after Gejnutsu. Konan stuck with rod, pain before during and after Genjutsu. You obviously avoided that one because you have no counter to it. There's more pain coming after you have a hole inside your stomach than the moment you get punctured. It's not like pain just goes away after you ave a hole in your stomach smh. That should've insta-broke Genjutsu. Just like Lee, he's in pain from the beginning, middle and end. THAT SIMPLE. I literally proved it, so I don't know why you're still going on here. Same with Danzo case, KG outlined it so I won't need to repeat it. And I will explain Genjutsu to you since you obviously don't understand it if you think it can only happen in an illusion world and not act as a continuation of the real world with variables manipulated by the caster.Huh?
No...It's a technique. A KKG one for that matter as I underlined. If it was just a reversal then it won't be classified...Sasuke reversed Itachi's Tsukoyomi, was that classified as a Jutsu? No. This case wasn't an ordinary one but a copy. Just like a smilier case of how Sasuke copies a section of Lee's Shadow of the dancing leaf and uses it to perfect his lion combo. Which was greatly emphasized here:
Thanks to the Sharingan's power, Itachi uses a similar technique.
A "similar technique" automatically made known that it's different which is why his Jutsu isn't called the same as Kurenai especially but a Genjutsu from the Sharingan. Not to mention it states it returns it back to the caster with a larger effect than anything else.
The bold...He cast the Jutsu with extra effects or so. Correct? Because the DB made it clear when it stated larger effects...So let's assume he copied it in a similar way to how he copied Shadow dancing leaf. Your points doesn't hold because he copied dancing leaf but then made it into something stronger hence the lion combo as a whole. Hence the reason why Kurenai's Jutsu isn't called the same as Itachi's.
@Underlined, If it wasn't cast by the Sharingan then it makes zero sense to classify it under a Kekkie Genkai technique which the Databook did. Shadow of the dancing leaf was copied but yet is this classified as KKG Technique? Is the name changed? It's only used as a stage for the final technique Lion Combo. Plus the fact that both Itachi and Kurenai have different names.
I looked at the DB and I saw the same with the one I posted as well. "KKK Genkai".
Flawed because every single scenario you've shown involves them going through pain before the Genjutsu is cast on them. If the Genjutsu is cast and they were in Pain then, that's different completely. The Konan was easily so I don't need to explain this one.
- B's scenario makes no sense especially seeing what occurs in the Genjutsu doesn't happen in reality. So you're telling me that B was in a Genjutsu but was still able to react and catch flamed shurikens in reality? How does that make sense? Of course it doesn't because that would mean it occurred before the Genjutsu or what happened occured inside the Genjutsu and not in reality because B won't be in control of himself in the real world. Second point is the fact that there was a hole slightly where B stood and you can also see the flamed shurikens if you look well closely on the ground..You see the hole behind B and also the flamed shurikenYou must be registered for see linksThis scan was after Hachibi broke B out of the Genjutsu. This hole was created by the tentacles which came out of B after Itachi used the Shurikens. So it's safe to say the Genjutsu was used when B tied Itachi up otherwise there would be no need for a hole in the first place as that occurred inside the Genjutsu. But there's a hole after it so we conclude the flamed shurikens were used before the Genjutsu.
- Danzo's point as well...The Genjutsu was broken when they were stabbed but was only realized after though. Like I told you, what happens in a Genjutsu doesn't occur in reality hence Sasuke shouldn't be having a mark caused by Danzo if Danzo was in the Genjutsu. Middle left panel shows the stab really happenedYou must be registered for see links. So no it wasn't still a Genjutsu because what occurs in that world doesn't happen in reality.
No you're wrong. The Gates adds more pain to the previous pain. As seen with Lee's muscles getting ripped severely and marks and bleeding being caused newly even though he was in it already. As seen with how it states "his body continues to crumble". As seen with Gai stopping midway because of the pain his has to bear and get used to while being in this Gate. It creates more and more pain added on which is different from pain already being established before. Ribs being broken and stuff like that..When you're already in pain as in the examples you showed, that is you normal state in which you are caught. However when new Pain is being caused such as muscles ripping and things like that being newly brought in, that's an interference affecting you in the Genjutsu. Which is why some cannot hold the gate for long even though they are shown bearing the pain caused previously.
No you comparison is flawed. Summonings are clearly different and you ignored my point:
- When Genjutsu is being used on a beast, the sharingan's tomoe appears on the beast eye. However for humans it's different so you can't
Plus the DB comparison as well showing that it's 2 different things as shown with the glimpse part seen with Manda being compared to the Kyuubi and not humans. I don't need to respond to the Manda question as well when the Manga has already established everything for us. Not to mention your pain and lying point doesn't even sound right when Pain has been established as a viable method of breaking Genjutsu. You can't suggest it's not using summonings as a point when that makes zero sense given the fact that those are beast and are affected differently as seen with their eyes.
She slapping him was uncalled for which should be obvious. Not to mention Apex already made it clear that lying can affect your chakra. Not sure why a touch wouldn't so yes she slapping him or even touching him could be affecting his chakra regardless. Plus the fact that one should consider chakra being used as an interference was something stated by Jiraiya in reference to Genjutsu as a whole and not just the Sahringan. Hence why we've seen what I'm saying works.
You didn't understand the Bee point because you don't understand how Genjutsu works, you don't see the full picture behind Genjutsu. Clearly from what was said here; "like I told you, what happens in a Genjutsu doesn't occur in reality hence Sasuke shouldn't be having a mark caused by Danzo if Danzo was in the Genjutsu". Just like Sasuke has shown, you can continue the fight like it was normal and all IRL conditions and only change one factor. That's what Itachi did, Bee attacked Itachi and caught his illusionary self thinking that was Itachi, but it wasn't Itachi since that was Genjutsu. Your point about the hole proves my point, and if you look at the top right panels of the chapter you'll see Kishi clearly signifies that they are making eye contact as he zooms in both of their eyes-faces
You must be registered for see links
. That's where the Genjutsu happens, you can CLEARLY see that Itachi was behind the tentacle which created the hole
You must be registered for see links
on the top left panel so what Bee saw was not reality yet what he did was within the same reality. So yes, this point stands because Itachi had him in Genjutsu from beforehand and Katon Shurikens didn't affect the Genjutsu. JUST like Deidara vs Itachi
You must be registered for see links
. He was in Genjutsu from the very BEGINNING as stated. He was acting in real life while under Itachi's Genjutsu as shown with clay still being around him and almost killing himself, etc as stated as well
You must be registered for see links
, Genjutsu is not all illusions like Itachi vs Sasuke where nothing happens IRL, some of them can be a deviation from reality but still happen in the real world since Itachi/Sasuke is controlling what the mind does and does not see.. Hope you're joking about the Danzo point... It was very clearly a continuation of reality [
You must be registered for see links
].
Last edited: